Verdance he/him Posted March 31 Posted March 31 11 minutes ago, Through the living Wahr said: Have never played with you before, so I dont think its impossible. But as stated Option1 is the most likely out of the 3 at least in my oppinion. Any info on mippo though?
DrakeMarshall he/him Posted March 31 Posted March 31 5 hours ago, |TJ| said: @DrakeMarshall, @Through the Living Ink, @Frozen Mint who is Gryffindor Prefect? wouldn't you like to know, weatherboy 2
Through the living Wahr He/Him Posted March 31 Posted March 31 I have the feeling that Mippo wasnt very active so far, or at least nothing he said stood out to me much, the most notable thing was forgetting to vote last Cycle but that is NAI in my Oppinion.
Verdance he/him Posted March 31 Posted March 31 22 minutes ago, DrakeMarshall said: wouldn't you like to know, weatherboy Ink did claim to be prefect. Idk how reliable that is, Ink is on my suspicion list (not on my exe list, just suspicious), so they could be lying. And if v!Ink is true, then they still could be lying to divert attention. Or they might want the elims to think they are diverting attention.
DrakeMarshall he/him Posted March 31 Posted March 31 It looks like 48 hour cycles so I’ll be back in a few hours 3 minutes ago, Through The Living Grass said: Ink did claim to be prefect. Idk how reliable that is, Ink is on my suspicion list (not on my exe list, just suspicious), so they could be lying. And if v!Ink is true, then they still could be lying to divert attention. Or they might want the elims to think they are diverting attention. Oh, yes. Ink may be the prefect.
coco.pudding she/they Posted March 31 Posted March 31 1 hour ago, Through the living Wahr said: So I dont really like whats going on with Coco/Grass here. Valid. I may be tunneling a bit here. But I just don’t like Grass not only claiming he’s not prefect, but that it was someone else, and then immediately the next cycle doing a 180 on that. And I don’t like that nobody was wiling to confirm it. But I do think it gives him some village credit that he has now claimed it and is actually willing to discuss what he wanted to do with the spell, and why he hid it in the first place. It felt extremely suspicious to me, and I figured if he was hiding a spell there was a good chance he’s elim. However, having now given an actual explanation and claim, I am willing to reconsider. Unfortunately I have already used the spell, but the things that are making me reconsider happened this cycle, so not much I (or anyone) can do about that.
Through the Living Hopper He/Him Posted March 31 Posted March 31 On 3/30/2026 at 1:57 PM, Miss Fallen said: So based on his profile, Hopper has been playing for a while. Saying negative = good is not the kind of mix-up an experienced player would make. I don’t think a newcomer would even think that. Then he failed to vote - again, experienced player. Plus, hopper was really pushing for prefect in the relatively chill ravenclaw pm(which has been stated before). All of this makes me read him as suspicious and elim. Sorry, guess I don’t have good faith. Most games don't have the +3– -3 voting, and the person with the most votes gets exed. I thought the negative votes removed votes on a player.
Aeternum Posted March 31 Posted March 31 Well it appears my lack of reading setups is going to cause me a lot of confusion this game. Unless we have a confirmed number of elims, I'm going to loosely assume 17 players means around 4 elims, so we've got some space to be wrong for at least a day here most likely. I'm getting a little confused by all the similar looking names, but I assume I should recognize at least a couple of you from previous games? There's several I don't recognize though, nice to see some new faces around! Hope you're all enjoying SE From cycle 1, Aman slot (now Drake) looks very town for how pro-town Aman's posts are. I read the convo with Through the Living Mist as v/v. This post from Through the Living Grass reads a bit like an elim struggling to find a place to start solving in the thread. And this post right after also isn't great. Gives very awkward elim vibes. This ig I could read as towny but I initially wanted to burn this post with fire so yup. Tbh this could be innocent newbie town (generally the kind of player I have an extremely hard time reading and will tunnel for half the game). It's just so out of nowhere and not really productive from an elim pov, as in I don't think an elim player is going to speculate on that kind of thing with TMI. So maybe I townlean this slot rn. Later posts make me lean more newbie town than elim struggling to get into thread. This post from mippo is a good poke imo. Also like this post and probably townlean mippo. TJ seems fine, Doc seems ok, coco is ok mostly just for this. Wahr/coco I'm going to lightly unpair off of the last line in that post, it's a little weird of a way to defend an elim partner I think but this is pending later re-eval if it matters later. Will read cycle 2 another time if I'm feeling up to it. I really can't be bothered to figure out how this whole voting thing works, but I'd currently vote to exe in the group of Through the Living Hopper, Through the living Wahr, TwinStorm, Through the Living Ink, Miss Fallen (although giving some grace here for being a newbie on cycle 1, which is all I've read), TUM, and Frozen Mint. Which is pretty much everyone who didn't interest me in any way on cycle 1. Of those, TUM I'd probably give the most leeway to as I was fine with his cycle 1 posts, but I didn't get enough town vibes to move out of my voting pool. Also to note, I'm fairly surprised Qianweilian was exe'd because I had Qian as town off of d1, so I'd be curious as to how that happened. 1
Adonalsium Will Return He/him Posted March 31 Posted March 31 I would love to spectate! I haven’t RPed here yet, and want to observe to see how it works.
Verdance he/him Posted March 31 Posted March 31 15 minutes ago, Aeternum said: Well it appears my lack of reading setups is going to cause me a lot of confusion this game. Unless we have a confirmed number of elims, I'm going to loosely assume 17 players means around 4 elims, so we've got some space to be wrong for at least a day here most likely. I'm getting a little confused by all the similar looking names, but I assume I should recognize at least a couple of you from previous games? There's several I don't recognize though, nice to see some new faces around! Hope you're all enjoying SE This post from Through the Living Grass reads a bit like an elim struggling to find a place to start solving in the thread. And this post right after also isn't great. Gives very awkward elim vibes. This ig I could read as towny but I initially wanted to burn this post with fire so yup. Tbh this could be innocent newbie town (generally the kind of player I have an extremely hard time reading and will tunnel for half the game). It's just so out of nowhere and not really productive from an elim pov, as in I don't think an elim player is going to speculate on that kind of thing with TMI. So maybe I townlean this slot rn. Later posts make me lean more newbie town than elim struggling to get into thread. Also to note, I'm fairly surprised Qianweilian was exe'd because I had Qian as town off of d1, so I'd be curious as to how that happened. Thanks! Yeah, doing my best to channel and convert everything I know from Werewolf and… *shudder* Among Us into strategy for this game specifically. Still working on that. i also would like to know this. Qian was neutral in my book, didn’t pay enough attention to him but it seemed like people trusted him. Why was he executed? -imma edit this section with vote analysis on qian-
Verdance he/him Posted March 31 Posted March 31 9 minutes ago, Adonalsium Will Return said: I would love to spectate! I haven’t RPed here yet, and want to observe to see how it works. little late buddy :3
coco.pudding she/they Posted March 31 Posted March 31 Of the people who voted Qian only Mint has responded. I don’t really want to ping Wahr and Twin again, that feels kinda rude, but I’d love to know what yall were thinking?
Amanuensis he/him Posted March 31 Posted March 31 18 minutes ago, Through The Living Grass said: little late buddy :3 Never too late to spectate! 1
TwinStorm He/Him Posted March 31 Posted March 31 (edited) @coco.pudding what was I thinking? well to start off right off the bat (first message in PM) he voted for himself as prefect, which feels idk very opportunistic, saying hes "the only person hes sure is not a Death Eater" which are just weird vibes for me also his D1 votes seemed kinda weird, between TUM +1 and Aman -3, I also didn't see any justification for these votes in my quick scanning of his posts yesterday, unless I missed smth big D2 Votes Mist Doc12 Grass Qianweilian Coco Aman Araris Aman Araris Unknown Medallion Wahr Hopper Coco Doc12 Grass Mist Doc12 Miss Fallen Coco Araris Aman Coco Qianweilian Aman Doc12 Hopper Araris NONE Hopper NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE Araris TJ Qianweilian Aman Unknown Medallion Wahr Coco Wahr NONE NONE Unknown Medallion Doc12 TwinStorm Araris TwinStorm Doc12 Mist Grass Aman Unknown Medallion Wahr Ink Wahr Frozen Mint Aman Hopper NONE Araris Doc12 Mist Aman TJ Coco Unknown Medallion Hopper Mippo TJ Mist Aman Wahr Ink Hopper Qianweilian Mist Doc12 Unknown Medallion Coco Wahr Aman TJ NONE Mist Mippo Araris Hopper NONE Miss Fallen NONE Doc12 Mist Ink Unknown Medallion NONE Emperor Comatose NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE Unknown Medallion NONE NONE NONE Doc12 Araris Aman Frozen Mint Miss Fallen Mist Doc12 Aman Coco NONE Players 1st (+3) 2nd (+2) 3rd (+1) 3rd (-1) 2nd (-2) 1st (-3) Aman TJ Ink Hopper Miss Fallen Qianweilian Frozen Mint Grass NONE TJ Doc12 Wahr Coco NONE Coco Doc12 Miss Fallen Aman Grass TJ NONE Hopper NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE Wahr NONE Unknown Medallion TJ Coco Qianweilian NONE TwinStorm Doc12 Aman TJ Hopper Qianweilian Unknown Medallion Ink NONE Grass NONE Aman NONE NONE Doc12 TJ Wahr Coco Ink Miss Fallen Frozen Mint Mippo NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE Qianweilian Unknown Medallion Doc12 Emperor Comatose Aman Hopper Grass TJ Mippo Aman Unknown Medallion Frozen Mint Ink Coco Miss Fallen Doc12 Mippo Frozen Mint Grass Coco Aman Emperor Comatose Doc12 Miss Fallen NONE NONE Coco Aman Unknown Medallion NONE NONE NONE Aman NONE Frozen Mint Frozen Mint Aman Coco Ink Doc12 Unknown Medallion Qianweilian based off just the raw data, im not loving TUM rn, tho imma do more research later A none vote from TUM for 4 categories feels almost weak, I don't understand where hes going with them. Why not just put Aman as -2 instead of -1? If you wanted Aman exed, what's the point in that, and if you didn't then why vote -1 them anyway? @The Unknown Medallion id love some responses Edited March 31 by TwinStorm
Mint11 she/her Posted April 1 Posted April 1 3 hours ago, Through The Living Grass said: Ink did claim to be prefect. Idk how reliable that is, Ink is on my suspicion list (not on my exe list, just suspicious), so they could be lying. And if v!Ink is true, then they still could be lying to divert attention. Or they might want the elims to think they are diverting attention. For what it's worth, I can also confirm that Ink is the Gryffindor prefect
Verdance he/him Posted April 1 Posted April 1 Well, that settles that. Mostly. All of Gryffindor says that Ink is prefect, and I do not believe that they are all elim. Maybe Ink is elim, we’ll see. But Ink is almost definitely prefect.
Verdance he/him Posted April 1 Posted April 1 (edited) 1 minute ago, DrakeMarshall said: No, we're actually all elims Elim slip???? Edited April 1 by Through The Living Grass 1
DrakeMarshall he/him Posted April 1 Posted April 1 Just now, Through The Living Grass said: Elim slip???? oh shoot you're right, I meant to say villager disregard please 2
___ He/Him Posted April 1 Posted April 1 2 minutes ago, DrakeMarshall said: oh shoot you're right, I meant to say villager disregard please I'm so glad you got added No offense to whoever he replaced
coco.pudding she/they Posted April 1 Posted April 1 3 minutes ago, DrakeMarshall said: No, we're actually all elims Dang, Drake. Thanks for solving the game for us, very kind of you Anyway Ink is prefect. That was never in question (for me at least). The question is if they’re elim and what they ended up using their spell for
DrakeMarshall he/him Posted April 1 Posted April 1 9 minutes ago, mippo said: I'm so glad you got added No offense to whoever he replaced flatterer Aman's cool though 9 minutes ago, coco.pudding said: The question is if they’re elim and what they ended up using their spell for In the Gryffindor PM, Aman has previously stated Protego is the most useful spell for the village I tend to agree So did Ink, for that matter Do with that what you will. I will be honest, none of these spells strike me as incredibly game-changing, so I will personally be mostly just focusing on the votes. But if a protect goes off successfully, that's cool. Aman village-read Ink and sounded like he was elim-reading Mint at some point. My admittedly very cursory read of the Gryffindor PM made me want to village read Mint and I have no particular Ink read. Anyways, I gather there's been one (1) vote so far and it flipped a villager Not a lot to go off but it's better than zero flips! Hopper and Coco were both tied for second place, only trailing Araris by a little bit, but it doesn't hit quite the same as a normal vote. I'm not sure that we can say it was a 'contested' vote or what. I guess I'll need to backread some for context. I'm a little tempted to vote the people who generally voted last cycle but didn't pick a -3 option, because it offends my sensibilities, but that's probably a me problem
coco.pudding she/they Posted April 1 Posted April 1 Just now, DrakeMarshall said: Anyways, I gather there's been one (1) vote so far and it flipped a villager Two votes. Araris and Qian have both been exed. And flipped village. Araris we mostly knew was coming, he was being sussed pretty hard cycle one. Qian not so much, he was either getting vaguely village read or just not talked about, which is why it was such a surprise
DrakeMarshall he/him Posted April 1 Posted April 1 oh. well, was there vote manip? I should really read about that real quick
___ He/Him Posted April 1 Posted April 1 4 minutes ago, DrakeMarshall said: Aman's cool though Indeed I miss his gambits
Recommended Posts