ostrichofevil he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 For now, I'm going to vote for Antilar Maximus. He didn't give any reasoning for his vote. I will retract this vote if he gives me good reasoning.
Clanky he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 (edited) Well I don't seem to be gaining anything except suspicion with my attempted information gathering from snoopy. Unfortunately Roshar hasn't had the best conversations in it to help guide suspicion. Probably the main reason for this is that Tulir who is the only experienced player there doesn't seem to be contributing very much. Also ostrichofevil has been basically completely absent from the chat altogether. So Tulir do you want to help out on the Roshar PM or do you have a reason not to? EDIT if I am removing my vote from Snoopy do i put it here as well as change the original vote to green? Edited February 6, 2015 by Clanky
Antillar Maximus he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 I voted because of some conversations he had with snoopy. I find him suspicious as of now. Not the best reasoning but it seems like Maw was trying to get attention off of himself.
Sarcomere Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 Sarcomere. Why would you vote for someone who you have absolutely no evidence for being an eliminator? Funny, that. Isn't that what's happening with poke votes? There is no solid evidence for lynching anyone. Everything that we know right now, or suspect right now, is based on what other people have said. I'll admit my reasoning is a bit weak (okay, fine--incredibly weak) but I figured it's better to put thoughts out in the open and see what happens than to keep them secret. If people react strangely, or suspiciously, then it would have been a good move. If not, at least I tried. I found Meta to be derisive of my reasoning, which I can understand. But Meta has always come across to me as level-headed and considerate. There was definitely an amount of sarcasm in Meta's post that I didn't think was very characteristic. Of course, I might be overanalyzing this. And if so, I'll apologize in advance to Meta. I honestly didn't think that my post was such a terrible idea to merit...this. (I do realize this was a joke, but was I the only one who took a second look at Joe's "don't trust meta" tag?) 2
Antillar Maximus he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 (edited) I'm pretty sure that people are just waiting for something to happen. It is probably easier for Odium to score a kill now because of all the dumb votes that are going on. Edited February 6, 2015 by Antillar Maximus
Unodus he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 (Is voting for someone who didn't give good reasoning good reasoning...? o.O) I agree with Winter, there isn't enough evidence yet to start throwing around real votes... 1
dowanx Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 (edited) There isn't enough evidence, but from my experience (as limited as it has been) there is rarely enough evidence to know that you are voting for a spiked 100% of the time. I am going to place my vote on Winter. There has been a couple things that have made me suspicious, but there isn't exactly "proof". Sorry Winter you're just at the top of my suspect list at the moment. Edit - color Edited February 6, 2015 by dowanx 1
Guest Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 Just two comments. 1. Blue isn't being used by everybody. 2. If you change your vote, you have to retract it in green.
Unodus he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 Dowanx, care to share what those suspicions are? In my experience, a lot of people get mislynched early unjustly because of really trivial things. We should make fair reasoning a priority when it comes to voting even if it means missing a few cycles, if we're lacking in suspects- creating them isn't doing anyone any favors. The evidence will come eventually, we just have to wait long enough for the enemy to make that mistake...
dowanx Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 (edited) Winter seems to be publicly trying to find the Shards identities and possibly drawing attention to them. She posts about Snoopy not being Endowment, but she knows what he is. If she knows Snoopy's role why would she want to draw attention to him. I don't see how drawing attention to Snoopy can help. It seemed like Winter is trying to sow confusion which is suspicious to me. Later on she posts that Devotion is potentially an experienced player narrowing down who Devotion is. Then in the same post she says we shouldn't draw attention to them because they have a target on their backs. In my mind this conflicts which is suspicious to me. The spiked want to find our more powerful roles and we shouldn't be revealing or even hinting at them in the public post. Like I said in my previous post it isn't much, but it did move him to the top of my suspect list. Edit - color Edited February 6, 2015 by dowanx 2
Guest Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 (edited) Updated votes list: Metacognition (2)--twelfth, Sarc Sarcomere (2)--Metacognition, vineyarddawg Winter Cloud (2)--Araris Valerian, Dowanx Clanky (1)--Lightsworn Panda Mailliw73 (1)--Antillar Maximus Swalji (1)--Aonar Faileas Antillar Maximus (1)--ostrichofevil Tulir (1)--Clanky I will try to keep on posting this as new votes come in. Edited February 6, 2015 by Snoopy
Antillar Maximus he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 I am pulling out of my vote on Mailliw73.
Metacognition he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 I found Meta to be derisive of my reasoning, which I can understand. But Meta has always come across to me as level-headed and considerate. There was definitely an amount of sarcasm in Meta's post that I didn't think was very characteristic. Of course, I might be overanalyzing this. And if so, I'll apologize in advance to Meta. I honestly didn't think that my post was such a terrible idea to merit...this. My apologies if you thought I was being short with you, Sarc. It's just that I've had almost this exact reasoning leveled at me before as a reason for why I should die. Funnily enough, the person turned out to be an Eliminator, so while similar reasoning doesn't mean that you are too, I'm content to find out! 1
Gamma Fiend he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 Well dang, I can just not make any RP work for this guy! I really am way too young at heart to be RPing an old person! XD I give up and will just spend my time on better efforts, like actual game analysis. Nalthis has been relatively silent, which isn't too surprising since I highly doubt too much information is being shared on the worlds just yet, but I am wary of how much seems to be being shared in PMs and being alluded to here in the thread, because those are just more clues for the eliminators to work from.The activity back and forth with Clanky and Snoopy definitely merits keeping an eye on for right now, because Clanky does seem like they might have been digging for information. Although I'm not sure what Snoopy's hints that he keeps dropping are to accomplish either. But I'm just going to put a vote on Clanky for right now to tie it up between the three of them for now.
Guest Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 (edited) Metacognition (2)--twelfth, Sarc Sarcomere (2)--Metacognition, vineyarddawg Winter Cloud (2)--Araris Valerian, Dowanx Clanky (2)--Lightsworn Panda, Gamma Swalji09 (1)--Aonar Faileas Antillar Maximus (1)--ostrichofevil Tulir (1)--Clanky Four-way tie! @Ash, I'm sorry, but I don't have time to do RP right now. Edited February 6, 2015 by Snoopy
Splinter he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 Memory. Memories always remained. Static, unchanging, they haunted me. Past failures, future concerns. Death, destruction, mayhem, a hundred thousand lifetimes worth, all contained within my mind. It wasn’t long before I realized that it was driving me insane. Copper became my panacea. I filled the metal with the stories of my life, locking them away, and hiding from the pain. --------------------- This cube was different. The copper was etched with multiple words, scratched out and redone, as if the author hadn’t been quite sure what to say. The clearest inscription read: The Beginning of the End Aonar threw the newest letter into the fire. They’d become increasingly urgent, but Aonar couldn’t help, not yet. He knew what would happen if he did, and he still had things to do yet. And first on the list was to call in a favour… --------------- It had taken a long time for Aonar to track him down. It had been almost six years since they’d last met, and he was unfortunately good at hiding. Aonar watched the man step into a narrow alley on the other side of the street. Too easy. He quickened his step and followed. “Hello, TrelVin.” As the kandra started at being recognized so easily, Aonar tapped zinc, pewter and steel, and forced the creature up against the wall of the alley. TrelVin struggled, but his Blessing was no match for Feruchemical pewter. The kandra sighed in resignation. “Would you be willing to let me go?” “You’re not going to run?” Aonar asked, raising his eyebrows. TrelVin thought for a moment. “Touché. What do you want, Aonar?” “You still owe me a favour, I believe.” “A favour? I don’t think so. Pretty sure I’d remember that.” “You and your buddies crushed my skull because you didn’t want me interfering in your work. I could have come back, revealed you to the Set. I didn’t. You owe me.” The kandra looked nervous. “That? That was years ago. I’m surprised you still remember. Best not to bring it up again. Water under the bridge, and all.” Aonar pulled back his sleeve and waved one of his copper bracers in front of the kandra’s face. “I remember everything, TrelVin. Now, you’re going to deliver something for me.” He pulled a notebook from his bag. “This needs to go to my son, when he’s ready for it.” He stepped back from the kandra, and started to walk away. “Hey! One problem, Aonar. Last I checked, you didn’t have a son.” Aonar turned back and grinned at the kandra’s confusion. “Time traveler, remember?” ------------------------------ Alright, people. Not much has happened so far, and the days half over. I know lots of people are working behind-the-scenes, trying to catch Eliminators, (I've gotten far too caught up in this already) but nothing really substitutes honest discussion in the Thread. My usual analysis has suffered this game, (I've got a heavier course-load in school than I was expecting) but let's see what we can do. What do we know? Sart (a smart guy) was pretty quiet in thread. -- Death does not tell us a ton, but dose remove an active player. Disliked the plan proposed on D1. -- Only way this could play in is if they wished to cast suspicion on me, or others who agreed with the plan. (Or if they wished to discredit the plan.) While this seems logical, it tells us unfortunately little. Part of Yolen PM. -- I myself can't inference much from this. Was there anything said in the Yolen PM that could have made Sart appear an attractive target? Hmm... Swalji, you haven't said anything for a bit, if I remember correctly, and you were a part of the Yolen PM. Any opinions? Sorry, but that's all from me for now, folks. It's way to late here for me to be constructively analyzing things. (Sorry for such a long quote. If there is a way to quote just part of a post I don't know how ) The reason I haven't been able to post very often is because I have had school like you, although I could have fit some more posts in. Is the reason that you didn't do very much analyzing because you don't have time or because you don't have enough evidence on me and just need someone to vote on? Will anyone on Yolen defend me?!
Guest Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 @swalji09 You just quote and then delete the parts of the quote that you don't want. Select and backspace.
Clanky he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 The activity back and forth with Clanky and Snoopy definitely merits keeping an eye on for right now, because Clanky does seem like they might have been digging for information. Although I'm not sure what Snoopy's hints that he keeps dropping are to accomplish either. But I'm just going to put a vote on Clanky for right now to tie it up between the three of them for now. Yes I'm not trying to hide the fact that I wanted info from Snoopy. That was what the vote was for. As of right now I don't have much to go on and Snoopy seems to know the most of anyone in the game. I'm not sure what I wanted from him that he could say without helping OCs. I guess I just wanted something to help me figure out what to do. Also I don't really suspect him of being on team Odium but voting for someone is the only way to really pressure someone into giving info.
vineyarddawg Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 Well dang, I can just not make any RP work for this guy! I really am way too young at heart to be RPing an old person! XD I give up and will just spend my time on better efforts, like actual game analysis. Nalthis has been relatively silent, which isn't too surprising since I highly doubt too much information is being shared on the worlds just yet, but I am wary of how much seems to be being shared in PMs and being alluded to here in the thread, because those are just more clues for the eliminators to work from. The activity back and forth with Clanky and Snoopy definitely merits keeping an eye on for right now, because Clanky does seem like they might have been digging for information. Although I'm not sure what Snoopy's hints that he keeps dropping are to accomplish either. But I'm just going to put a vote on Clanky for right now to tie it up between the three of them for now. If you're just "keeping an eye on it," Gamma, then why did you vote for Clanky? Snoopy has no votes. You're not tying Clanky with Snoopy or anything. Both of them are basically equally suspicious in my mind at this point. I'd rather focus on questioning the more experienced players' votes, since I would expect them to actually have a better reason for voting than "I want to eliminate an experienced player." (Obviously, I'm thinking of Sarc with that comment, since my vote is still on him.)
leiftinspace he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 Metacognition (2)--twelfth, Sarc Sarcomere (2)--Metacognition, vineyarddawg Winter Cloud (2)--Araris Valerian, Dowanx Clanky (2)--Lightsworn Panda, Gamma Swalji09 (1)--Aonar Faileas Antillar Maximus (1)--ostrichofevil Tulir (1)--Clanky Four-way tie! Didn't Meta remove his vote on Sarc?
Feligon he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 It looks like a four way tie right now, but we don't know if cultivation has tampered with the vote. Everyone had agreed with the world freeze, for the simple reason that joe had made the distribution of odium and his champions random through the six worlds and no one wanted to risk an Odium-free world getting contaminated. This would not be good for selling weapons, everyone on Roshar had the best weapons they could afford (or a freakin' honorblade). 1
Jo and the Bush all/any Posted February 6, 2015 Author Posted February 6, 2015 (edited) You're a bit off Snoopy. The Current Votes are: Metacognition(2): Twelthrootoftwo, Sarcomere Sarcomere(3): Winter Cloud, Metacognition, Vineyard Winter Cloud(2): Araris Valerian, Dowanx Clanky(2): Lightsworn Panda, GammaFiend Swalji(1): Aonar Faileas Antillar(1): OstrichofEvil Tulir(1): Clanky To Retract your vote you can Put their name in Green in a New Post, or green out the old Post. I prefer the Latter, as it makes it much Easier to find the real Votes. (No I will not be updating this List. Edited February 6, 2015 by The Only Joe
Splinter he/him Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 (edited) ok, thanks! whoops This was meant for Snoopy Edited February 6, 2015 by swalji09
Guest Posted February 6, 2015 Posted February 6, 2015 I promise you, I'm not off. Yours has two problems. 1. You have Clanky listed as one vote, but you have two people. 2. Winter retracted her vote on Sarc in an earlier post, but the coloring didn't work. Winter, could you fix that?
Jo and the Bush all/any Posted February 6, 2015 Author Posted February 6, 2015 Oh right, the Number is off. And I saw Winter's retraction. But I can't count it unless it's actually green.
Recommended Posts