Amanuensis he/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 (edited) 16 minutes ago, Qianweilian said: What's the point of this? Aren’t the only votes the +3/+2/+1/-1/-2/-3 in the gm pm and the prefect votes in the houses? Or am I misunderstanding something critical? I established earlier that I am using public red votes to represent my -3 vote. I am trying to get some kind of discussion going around voting as I personally develop my best reads by social interaction, and the most telling usually comes from fear of death. I also feel we will suffer in the late game if we neglect discussing our suspicions and trusts publicly, to some degree. I think it's safer to be more open about things early on than when the numbers are closer to exlo I also established earlier that my public votes are not necessarily the ones I have submitted. Some can be real and some fake. Basically mixing genuine suspicions with ML bait to see if the elims will overextend themselves to protect one of their own. Edited March 27 by Amanuensis
Qianweilian He/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 1 minute ago, Amanuensis said: I established earlier that I am using public red votes to represent my -3 vote. Oh, sorry. I missed that.
Amanuensis he/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 (edited) 8 minutes ago, Qianweilian said: Oh, sorry. I missed that. No worries it was several pages ago 16 hours ago, Amanuensis said: Oh so are we doing our 6 votes starting today too? If so I would propose we still vote in thread for at least the player we submit -3 for @Araris Valerian Araris I saw you reading earlier. What're your thoughts so far Edited March 27 by Amanuensis
Doc12 Posted March 27 Posted March 27 Given time has passed, willing to put my negatives on TUM, Araris, TJ, Worldhopper. TUM and Araris I know have been active in the Slytherin PM , and I really want TUM to commit to a read and to see who Araris suspects. @|TJ| how've you been? I expected more activity since you were so aggressive last game. @Miss FallenoHow's your first game going? Can't@ Worldhopper but also where are you?
Qianweilian He/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 6 minutes ago, Doc12 said: Can't@ Worldhopper but also where are you? He joined in on the “through the lives cult.” His username is @Through the Living Hopper
___ He/Him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 (edited) 11 hours ago, Through the Living Mist said: So. Mippo, I am a bit concerned on the lack of Ravenclaw right now. Using a bit of profile stalking, all of them have been on today. Most in the last hour. Which means there’s a least some talk going on in the Ravenclaw PM. But you’re the only one that’s posted in thread so far. Sorry, was asleep Yeah there has been some talk. All it's been so far is figuring out who will be prefect, and everyone's only posted I think twice. Idk why they haven't posted here. 3 hours ago, Amanuensis said: I did indeed! Think I saw you reading a thread at one point. I guess I'll just ask you straight up. Earlier you commented on my (now proven based on a false premise) analysis, but not on the analysis itself. I found that odd as you didn't provide your perspective on things. Can you tell us about the Ravenclaw PM activity levels? Have you developed any suspicions within your group or, more importantly to me, within thread? If not, why not? How can we help? Awesome! This is my third? Fourth? Game, and you can ask anyone who's played with me here, but I'm not an analysis kind of guy. Although to be fair I do generally comment on them The reason why I was impressed with your analysis was because it was the beginning of the game, and so how you had that much data so early blew my mind Anyway, of the people in my own house, I'm slightly sus of @Miss Fallen. She started the conversation, yet as you have pointed out, none of them have posted in here. Although we've barely even messaged in there. Edit: I also noticed that Fallen has been really pushing to get a prefect selected. I don't know if this matters as I can't see why an elim would do that, but it seems like it's worth mentioning. Edited March 27 by mippo
Myst He/Him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 So, based on everything said so far. Slytherin got all the active people, and so I expect that one to have the best problem solving. However, I’m upping my theory of how many Elims are in Slytherin to two, as Elim teams kind of need to be active(either in PM or in thread). Hufflepuff, me and Ver have been chatting. But Ravenclaw and Gryffindor is going slowly. Which checks out with what I know of the players involved. Right now though. I’m not sure if the activity can help us solve. But it is still something we should keep an eye on. I personally am leaning on mint being the non-Slytherin Elim. That’s just because she’s only been commenting on other people’s analysis, and has said she doesn't want to appear inactive early game. Mippo has been the same. But she has played similarly in other games. For the people who’ve played with Mint, is this normal?
Ink and Embers Any pronouns Posted March 27 Posted March 27 4 minutes ago, Through the Living Mist said: So, based on everything said so far. Slytherin got all the active people, and so I expect that one to have the best problem solving. However, I’m upping my theory of how many Elims are in Slytherin to two, as Elim teams kind of need to be active(either in PM or in thread). Hufflepuff, me and Ver have been chatting. But Ravenclaw and Gryffindor is going slowly. Which checks out with what I know of the players involved. Right now though. I’m not sure if the activity can help us solve. But it is still something we should keep an eye on. I personally am leaning on mint being the non-Slytherin Elim. That’s just because she’s only been commenting on other people’s analysis, and has said she doesn't want to appear inactive early game. Mippo has been the same. But she has played similarly in other games. For the people who’ve played with Mint, is this normal? Mint has mentioned in the house PMs that she is in and out of activity; not doing her own analysis may be more due to lack of time than other factors (at least at this point in the game)
___ He/Him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 @Through the Living Ink, is this your first game? I can't remember if I've played with you before.
Amanuensis he/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 24 minutes ago, Through the Living Mist said: For the people who’ve played with Mint, is this normal? Mint is returning after a few years of absence (I think), so I'm not sure if many veteran players remember her playstyle (I don't), and people change a lot between gaps so it may not be much relevant. Could be wrong if she's played games during my own hiatus, but that's my two cents
Verdance he/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 So just to be clear, there is no seer type in this game, so all information is going to come from interactions and voting?
Amanuensis he/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 5 minutes ago, Through The Living Grass said: So just to be clear, there is no seer type in this game, so all information is going to come from interactions and voting? Yeah, I believe there is only adjacent info learned from Protego stopping a NK and who loses votes
Araris Valerian he/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 2 hours ago, Doc12 said: Given time has passed, willing to put my negatives on TUM, Araris, TJ, Worldhopper. TUM and Araris I know have been active in the Slytherin PM , and I really want TUM to commit to a read and to see who Araris suspects. @|TJ| how've you been? I expected more activity since you were so aggressive last game. @Miss FallenoHow's your first game going? Can't@ Worldhopper but also where are you? For some reason I thought I said this already, but I’m going to be voting against coco, Wahr, and TUM, though possibly not in that order.
TwinStorm He/Him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 (edited) 5 hours ago, Amanuensis said: I'll try to finish the scene I began last night after maths / before work and then I can probably leave an RP opening for you to speak with Amara o7 Ah, right. I forgot in order to be hard cleared village in LG110 you had to die very early on Alright Wahr, I'll give you this cycle and the first 24 hours of the next to prove yourself village to me, else I might assume your survival interest may be increased by a red roll Hm. Twin. Can you please try to articulate said "vibes" for -3 Wahr, -2 TUM, -1 coco, and +3 doc? I did indeed! Think I saw you reading a thread at one point. I guess I'll just ask you straight up. Earlier you commented on my (now proven based on a false premise) analysis, but not on the analysis itself. I found that odd as you didn't provide your perspective on things. Can you tell us about the Ravenclaw PM activity levels? Have you developed any suspicions within your group or, more importantly to me, within thread? If not, why not? How can we help? ED1T: (-3) Twin: Aman (-3), (-3) TUM: Aman (-1), Twin (-2), (-3) Wahr: Twin (-3), (-2) mippo: Aman (-2), (-2) Araris: Vergrass (-2), (-1) Aman: Vergrass (-1), (-1) coco: Twin (-1), (+8) Mist: Aman (+3), Vergrass (+3), Twin (+2), (+3) Vergrass: Aman (+2), Twin (+1), (+3) Doc: Twin (+3), (+1) Ink: Aman (+1), I believe this is accurate to current public votes ED2T: @Araris Valerian I don't necessarily trust you atm, though I'd like to. Assuming v!you I do trust your judgment (caveat, I may not agree with the conclusions). Can you expand upon your decision to not vote for Doc or Twin today? I'm pressuring Twin now but I'd like to hear a bit more perspective on those slots from a Slytherin. articulate said vibes? its C1, nobody knows anything, all we have our vibes so no I can't unfortunately give anything concrete but if theres two elims in Slytherin, I don't think voting for Slytherins is a bad idea (yeah ik no house loyalty lol) each of them sees slightly off, Coco seems to eager to be a prefect while not rly standing out like a leader to me, Wahr and TUM both are just giving off rly strange vibes well +3 doc is simple, 1) I like Doc's vibes, which to be fair is pretty simple, and as well as their RP and seeing as we have no concrete info, why not? im liking Mists vibes this game and verdance as well so there we go vibes articulated in a thoroughly unhelpful way Edited March 27 by TwinStorm emoji
TwinStorm He/Him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 Raese headed up the stairs, taking each step to the dormitories slowly and methodically. Hogwarts was a strange place. He felt so at home here and so . . . alone. Separate. Slytherin was his house, but he did not belong. Not yet. He reached the dormitory, turning the heavy oak latch and entering the room. It was smaller than the Common Room, circular with a dozen or so beds, with green curtains draped across the windows. He walked towards the nearest bed, frowning when he saw his trunks piled at the foot of the bed. He frowned. He had only brought a singular suitcase, but another case stood there. One he knew. His guitar case. Confused, Raese flicked open the latches. There it was, his guitar. The old battered instrument that his grandfather had brought from Ireland, and had given to him. He'd forgotten it at home, but here it was. He picked it up, and strummed the strings softly. It rang out cleanly, the strings vibrating and echoing across the room. He smiled, glancing across the room at the door. He slung the guitar over his back, opened the door softly and set off down the stairs. Not to the common room, but to a storage closet he had noticed earlier. There, among the brooms, mops, and salamanders, he began to play. 1
Mint11 she/her Posted March 27 Posted March 27 (edited) 1 hour ago, Through the Living Mist said: has said she doesn't want to appear inactive early game. wait did I say that? I wouldn't say thats true and it looks like the guests that I thought were leaving today are leaving at an undetermined date so yeah, between that and work, I'm in and out I do want to post reads because those contributions give everyone important info as we sus each other out. but establishing opinions on other players is hard for me. I'll do my best but irl stuff will probably limit my headspace Edited March 27 by Frozen Mint typo
Myst He/Him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 2 minutes ago, Frozen Mint said: wait did I say that? I wouldn't say thats true and it looks like the guests that I thought were leaving today are leaving at an undetermined date so yeah, between that and work, I'm in and out I do want to post reads because those contributions give everyone important info as we sus each other out. but establishing opinions on other players is hard for me. I'll do my best but irl stuff will probably limit my headspace If it’s irl stuff then nevermind. Even if you’re Elim, I’ll give you a bit before coming back to this.
Through the living Wahr He/Him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 (edited) Am I cursed or Something? Because this is the third Game were multiple people think I am evil C1, with no apparent reason. I do not understand why. Edited March 27 by Through the living Wahr
The Unknown Medallion he/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 3 minutes ago, Through the living Wahr said: Am I cursed or Something? Because this is the third Game were multiple people think I am evil C1, with no apparent reason. I do not understand why. You get used to it 7 hours ago, Doc12 said: Azalea smiles. "A well stoked fire can warm a home in deepest winter, or burn it down. People always say He who must not he Named was from Slytherin and that's the big black mark against our House. Well. Our House made a monster, but it's just as capable of producing heroes as well..." She shrugs, languidly. "Choice. That's part of why people fear us. Because we make ourselves strong, and we grasp that choice in our hands to be a hero or a monster. That choice is still yours." Azalea smiles again. "Raese. Everyone needs two kind of people to draw strength from. Those who you want to prove right, and those who you want to prove wrong. Your father... He's proud of you. You want to prove him right, don't you? And for everyone who gives you a dirty look, or whispers something nasty, or thinks any lesser of you for the colors you wear... You want to prove them wrong, don't you?" She sees Raese smile. She softens again, gives him a curt nod. "Bedtime. It's been a big day for you." @The Unknown MedallionAs well Azalea turned to Siannain. "I didn't really see much, Vera and I were hurrying the first years away, but I've heard. Something about the Gryffindor ghost acting weird ... Snake coming out of its mouth and attacking McGonagall... Someone in the sorting chair that disappeared..." She shakes her head. "it's. A lot. We don't know for sure it was a ghost, or that it was killed. Just someone thst screamed and disappeared." "... We should ask the ghosts what they know, though. The snake coming out of Nick's mouth..." she looked at the other two students, seeing the same understanding on their faces. "Goes without saying, not a word to the First Years. But yes. Research. And we should also check with the ghosts. See if they know anything about what happened to Nick, or if there's a ghost that's missing, or acting odd. Siannain, think you can try the Baron?" she rolled her eyes. "He respects men more. Vera, let me know what you find in your research. I'll join you, but first I'm... I'm going to talk to Amara." @Amanuensis Siannain smiles. "I like Baron. I'll see if I can find him, I know a few places." 5 hours ago, Frozen Mint said: this is so rad I don't want to look at inactivity too early in the game, but I'm also wary of how little we've seen of Ravenclaw so far. Posting votes does give elims more of an edge than villagers IMO. I'm interested in thoughts around sharing votes in the house PM, instead of in thread, to help deduce which houses the elims are in. The downside of course is that if elims have access to all the house PMs, then this will give them an edge over village. I'll share reads later when I can get on a computer/have some more energy. There's been a couple posts saying this, but I disagree. Having votes in thread benefits the village much more than elims. If we don't hold people accountable to posting their opinions, they can vote whoever and make their reasonings up retroactively. It makes it harder for elims to defend teammates and push misexes This is also why Aman's hedging about fake reads is rubbing me the wrong way. It gives him an excuse to make whatever vote he wants without having to justify it today Current minuses are Aman, Araris, Doc, though I don't know the order yet.
___ He/Him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 8 minutes ago, Through the living Wahr said: Am I cursed or Something? Because this is the third Game were multiple people think I am evil C1, with no apparent reason. I do not understand why. At this point your last two posts have been saying the same thing, yet you're in the same position Do you have any analysis to give? 1
Verdance he/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 10 minutes ago, Through the living Wahr said: Am I cursed or Something? Because this is the third Game were multiple people think I am evil C1, with no apparent reason. I do not understand why. Im not sure why either. You’re neutral imhop, but i know n o t h i n g
|TJ| he/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 This game gives me major LG104 vibes, which is why I wouldn't put it out of the realm of possibility that Archer would have done a TJ and put all evil players in one group :P. On 3/26/2026 at 4:29 PM, Amanuensis said: Working off Mist's claim of requesting Huffle: At least 1 picked Huffle (Mist) Maybe 1 picked Gryffin (not Aman, another claimed "any but Ravenclaw, surprise me", leaving the third as the only logical intentional picker) If 4 "put me somewhere smol", Gryfin + 1, 50/50 Gryffin/Huffle + 1, the other +1, then 50/50 Gryffin/Huffle (favoring Gryffin) Or if 3 and a picked Gryffin, 50/50 Gryffin/Huffle +1, the other +1, then 50/50 Gryffin/Huffle (favoring Gryffin) I have no idea what any of this means... On 3/26/2026 at 4:37 PM, Frozen Mint said: If everyone is bunched together, I think its fair to assume the only house that would happen in is Slytherin. The thing with baddies being bunched in a small house is one, I assume Archer would take pity on a lone villager in a house full of elims (maybe a dangerous assumption lol), and two, it seems less fun not to spread the elims around at least a little. Less potential for plotting and backstabbing. Ehhh, I disagree, because assuming Archer would have pity is dangerous by itself. Bunching up elims does end up nerfing them in terms of information as they have access to lesser number of Houses but I adjusted that by adding an extra elim, so it was 5 elims in an 18 player game. granted 5 elims in a 17 player game WITH the rule about parity wincon is highly unlikely but just putting this out there anyway. Besides, trying to outguess GMs is always a bad idea and delving into elim number combination within groups is also a dangerous game, so I'll just call it as I see it in-thread. On 3/26/2026 at 6:48 PM, Amanuensis said: What do you mean by the numbers not making sense? Everyone received their alignments before picking houses, no? In the pregame I told Doc I was picking Slytherin. Then D0 began and I was told my alignment. Then multiple people indicated they'd go to Slytherin and I decided to go elsewhere. Gahh, I hate derpclears so muchh smh >> But I think the fact the Aman immediately turned it around and treated it as a reaction test comes from a villager-y mindset. Village-lean. 19 hours ago, Araris Valerian said: Nobody has really stood out in the PM itself, though I’d say I have a base reluctance to exe Doc and TwinStorm, and a village read on Qian. I think Araris having a base reluctance to exe anyone in itself is weird, but considering it's 2 players who are neither new nor returning, I think it deserves mentioning. Elim lean. 16 hours ago, TwinStorm said: there was one wot LG last year when the entire Brown Ajah was elim Ah, I see I'm not the only one in flashbacks. 3 hours ago, Doc12 said: @|TJ| how've you been? I expected more activity since you were so aggressive last game. You seem to have forgotten that I was MIA for basically 1.5 Loops :P. Apparently, Slow Start is my MO. Regarding Ravenclaw, Hopper does seem to be overeager to get the Prefect role. I was just pondering whether just voting Ms. Fallen for Prefect was the best idea here as I was again drawing parallel to LG104 where Drake elected a new player (sorry, I'm not able to recall the name as a Sitter and then they won the Amyrlin Seat election and basically won the game for the village. This is also based statistically off the fact the debut players tend to rarely get elim-randed. I do admit to have a blindspot when it comes to new players, so I'm not really sure who to vote for Prefect, which is why Ms. Fallen seems like a better option of the 3. Other stuff - agreed with the village on Mistfallen and Qian. Not sure what the TUM case was, so let me just re-read. 1
Verdance he/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 8 minutes ago, The Unknown Medallion said: You get used to it Siannain smiles. "I like Baron. I'll see if I can find him, I know a few places." There's been a couple posts saying this, but I disagree. Having votes in thread benefits the village much more than elims. If we don't hold people accountable to posting their opinions, they can vote whoever and make their reasonings up retroactively. It makes it harder for elims to defend teammates and push misexes This is also why Aman's hedging about fake reads is rubbing me the wrong way. It gives him an excuse to make whatever vote he wants without having to justify it today Current minuses are Aman, Araris, Doc, though I don't know the order yet. Counterpoint- village hysteria when someone is misexecuted because an innocent or newbie was manipulated by an elim and voted against another innocent
|TJ| he/him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 Ah, forgot to mention one thing. Aman-Wahr interaction is not e/e I feel. I agree with Aman's observation regarding Wahr's behaviour change but I also agree that Wahr's defence is a valid one. Having been involved in the L1D1 vote of Wahr in the last game, I understand their cautiousness could equally be from village or evil and needs future scrutiny. Also, what's with the Doc village-reads smh >> He says no one is going to trust him after his evil games and then reels everyone in with his RP anyway :P. Sidenote, but I just realised there is an incredible similarity to how (either) I read (or their playstyles itself of) Doc and Fifth, and I mean that extremely complementarily. It's their most village-seeming games that they are actually evil :P. 2
Through the living Wahr He/Him Posted March 27 Posted March 27 2 minutes ago, mippo said: At this point your last two posts have been saying the same thing, yet you're in the same position Do you have any analysis to give? As I said before, I am not good with social reads, so I will be able to give more Analysis once there are mechanical Informations for me to Analyse. I do not like that we only know who each Player voted for, once the Day is over, so anything that is said in thread regarding Votes is unreliable. Though I do agree with TUM that having acountability would probably be usefull for the village. My curent Minuses, are Twin and Araris (I do not understand their suspicion of me) a well as Doc (experience shows that he is not to be trusted 100% of Games, not ounting this one, has had him as an elim who took advatage of my trusting nature) For my Pluses I am thinking TUM (because I like the idea of acountability) the other Pluses I am not sure about yet. Still need to figure out in what order I would place them
Recommended Posts