Jump to content

Yata

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    5305

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Yata

  1. Yata
    Mostly, as I said Brandon (on the last update I remember) was still working with the timeline (remember that Era2 wasn't supposed to exist, It was Just a luckly incident)
  2. Yata
    If Vivenna is Evi and Dalinar was in someway responsable for her Death or her missing protection. Do you really expect an intimate friend of her to stay calm and remains at his service. ? He is not really a patient guy. Much more, all of this happened when Dalinar was quite a monster...I find It really unlikely. Without considerate the Realmatic ramifications to have Adolin and Renarin as hybrids
  3. Yata
    Like other said reviving a Deadblade is something possible in theory but extremely difficoult unless you are the One who killed It. The Spren's soul is merged with the Knight's One and when the Knight broke his Oaths, part of the Spren is trapped into the Knight...this leave the Spren mostly "Brain Dead". The original Knight could provide back to the Spren what he Lost quite easly. But others can't...I believe that a revived Spren (not by his original Knight) will be no more the same, live enough to think but not fully Sapient as a normal Radiant's Spren.
  4. Yata
    Era2 is After Stormlight Arc1's end but before Arc2's end. So the whole Era 2 take Place between books 5-6 or 6-7 (the timeline isn't already fixed)
  5. Yata

    Nicrosil

    Yata replied to Farnsworth's question in Cosmere Q&A

    Really unlikely, First of all he Sovreign arrived to South already with his Medallion tech and the North remembers (whops crossover)....the North has not Harmonium. Secondly someone on the Ship Need Allomancy to made the whole stuff fly and as we don't see Allik or his crewmate be so workship for someone of their own. I believe there were no Misting in the Ship...so the Allomancy have to come from Medallions too. Third we know messing with Connections is One of the missing parts into Unsealing a Metalmind and that this process is fair complex to do (by WoB)
  6. Yata
    The godmetal's Power aren't chosen by the Vessels. They are Simply the result of the Shardic's mandate Upon the filter of the Metallic Arts. To be' more specific you could see how Atium turns peoples into killing machines in Allomancy, It allows you to operate Upon your body's entropy in Feruchemy and It's the most efficient Spike into Hemalurgy. Similary the Lerasium gives you the ability to preserve yourself using external sources of Power. In a WoB Brandon said that an Atium-Lerasium Alloy would have a real deterministic and prevedible effect for Who has Realmatic knowledge.
  7. Yata
    Without any kind of reference? This is Just semantic, a trap is a weapon and much more you could see how the seeds Preservation planted, lead After thousands of years to the end of Ruin. Remind also that Fuzz didn't remember his own Plan's details (for example he didn't know of Sazed's Ascension)...so use his semantic as proof of something is a sterile argument. Vin+Atium+Seers (tangential) were together a weapon to kill Ruin. I am not sure to follow you here. Preservation choose a Sign that would ne Beyond the men's ability to change. The 16 arose naturally in the Metallic Arts... He made some trick to integrate his Need into the existing Framework (replacing unobtainable metals with Atium and Malatium). But the 16 based Magic was still there before. For people with a decent amount of Information, the 16% Hidden in the Mists Will be a Red earring. You Will link It fast to the Metallic Arts (something Elend did ad Soon his provided with the Yomen's knowledge) and a single Person to make this kind of link in the world is enough...or One of the Mist-affected that show Allomancy's talent is the same. Notice that while Preservation anticipated also TLR's reign and his censure job, he also influenced TLR into adopting the 16 into his religion(see again Yomen's doctrine). For Fuzz's prospective TLR'S actions were an incident but he already setted the whole stuff in motion thousand of years ago and he was no more able to undo this (also his strong Faith in Preservation's Plan stopped him from messing around).
  8. Yata
    I believe the amount of Investiture to balanced Harmony will be too much for Kelsier to have It and be' able to leave Scadrial. Many people (me included) think that Harmony repeated the old schemes and crafted Harmonium with more Ruin than Preservation in it to balance himself
  9. Yata
    Wayne is still not Born in SA arc1's timeline or if he is already Born...he would be a Little child
  10. Yata
    The Bond could be released willing by the parts without harm them, sure the Spren will lose his sapience in the PR but it's not too bad and the Bond is released without tragic feedback if the Knight dies. As you said The Spren is killed by the OathBreak....while the Oaths are fine, the Bond could be released without troubles, there were also cases in the past were KR passed their Spren to someone else. Surgebinding is not for life, it is a pact between two parts.
  11. Yata
    Jasnah is surprised because from the Spren's reports the Listeners-> Voidbringer didn't happen in that way and there were no Everstorms in the previous Desolations. She spent time to recover informations and they could be all' useless (probably not all', but the Everstorm indicates a variability the previous Desolations had not)
  12. Yata
    If Eshonai is so free willed to ask a Bondsmith to remove the Voidspren, I assume the Bondsmith could sever the Bond without damage her Soul. Much more if also She will end in Slaveform, the Radiants has way to heal her without using the Everstorm (I will avoid to expose/connect people with Odium) and possible in the meanwhile gain some connection to her...this would help her to be' choosen by a Spren
  13. Yata
    As far as we know there is a single Listener species. The Parshmen were Simply spiritual wounded Listeners, not a different species...in the same way a guy with a heavy mental deficit is still a common human
  14. Yata
    I believe the Everstorm could not turn Parshmen into Form of Power directly. So if a Parshmen is exposed to the Everstorm, he would be healed. Now that his Spiritweb is restored, the Everstorm could turn them into Forms of Power. The only issue is now, the Healed-Parshman could resist Better to external influence (like someone from the Last Legion) so many will not turn, except if the Healing connected them a bit more to Odium
  15. Yata
    Yeah, I am still about "Foreign Controlled Investiture appears redish" so Odium-related stuff glows Red on Roshar because Odium is Invested in Braize and Trell-related's Investiture is reddish because he/she is not invested on Scadrial and intead simply emanates his influence from somewhere else. In theory with this Interpretation, Wyndle will appear reddish on Nalthis or Braize
  16. Yata
    Maybe Hoid didn't take part to the Shattering but it was still there and for some reason one of the Vessel thought he would merit one of the Shards more than himself. It could be one of the Vessel who don't want actually the power but only to remove Adonalsium, we don't know WHY they killed Adonalsium and what outcome they hoped
  17. Yata
    I believe there is not another meaningfully landmass on Roshar. I have to check the AU's essay but if there was another landmass..The Worldhoppers would know it
  18. Yata
    Why is a magical explaination unlikely? Anyway, I believe you forget the Realmatic side of the topic. Everything in the Cosmere has three aspects. If the Alluminium's properties are caused by something in its Spiritual Aspect...Will you call It "natural" or "magical" ? To me, this distinction loses completely sense. For example (but others'ideas Will be fine too) I believe the Alluminium is affected by a Spiritual Emptyness. Without going into details, It's mainly an anti magic stuff because Its Soul can't offer a target to most magics.
  19. Yata
    Just to clarity. I believe they could use the ettmetal bomb to try to trigger a CS's birth but It was mainly an attempt of them as I find extremely unlikely this kind of stuff could work except for luck. In my eyes that Fakeless Immortal tried something that could have the right principale behind...but a failure in application
  20. Yata
    Actually also if the connection between Steel/Iron Allomancy and magnetism is intuitive. The two things are not even related, Allomancy didn't use any kind of magnetic force to work
  21. Yata
    Also the clashing of Storms will be safetier I assume. The Stormfather could regularry the Highstorms to meet the Everstorm only in places where they could not cause too much trouble. Anyway for now, all' Roshar experienced the Everstorm at least One time
  22. Yata
    What old man? The phylosopher?
  23. Yata
    SH in theory has to be read after 3/4 of the Era 2 Books as it spoils something from future events
  24. Yata
    Snapping was and is caused by extreme conditions, it could happen when your Soul is cracked. This happen mostly after a trauma because it is more likely but you could Snap after feeling a great happiness or similar situations that still crack the souls. The only thing Harmony did is to lower the threeshold need to Snap, so now it's more easy to reach (how he performed this is unknown)
  25. Yata
    I think it's only a belief/hope I can't see Trell as Invested on Scadrial enough to turn someone into a Cognitive Shadow without Harmony notice it. They probably try to turn him into a CS exposing Suit to a short but intense amount of Harmony's Investiture...But this also is a risky way as this CS will be always under Harmony's eyes and be almost useless as spy or stealth assignments in the best scenario, short lived in the worst
×
×
  • Create New...