Jump to content

Yata

Members
  • Posts

    5305
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Everything posted by Yata

  1. The only obstacle Szeth has is believing he could. But I think Nale could Simply tell him...by the way, that WoB Almost extension It's implication to the Heralds too
  2. Odium or every other Shard could craft Splinters of his own Power without diminishing himself as all' the Splinters are still part of himself. I am a bit curious from the Stormfather's words as for what we know, the Investiture used Will return to the Shard After some time. Maybe this means that Rayse as Vessel is keeping be' hurt by this Clash. Odium's Power is at his maximum but his "stamina" is not. It's not too different from what we saw with Preservation. The Vessel could be deadly hurt without affect the Shard too much (I Will remain vague as we are not in Cosmere Theory)
  3. Actually I didn't say that (also if it's possible). I said there were Humans on Roshar before H&C arrived (and at the Shattering's time), there is a WoB about (I believe it was an @Argent one by Reddit) that surprised us all on the topic. So before H&C there were already Humans on Roshar but they could be or not native of the planet
  4. Interesting Idea. I could not really believe It as my First choice but It's really an interesting point...I didn't considerate this
  5. Well, every Allomantic Power Will be good to fuel Nightblood. Of course this requires a crossover that Brandon Will never allow in SA. By the way Feruchemy Will be good too for this (and extremely unlikely as answer for the SA's standalone status
  6. You could see how Odium's color is red too, this could only strenght the point of "there is not a correlation one to one from color to shard" (avoiding all the "faking another shard" argument) PS: Also if I believe to the correlation between Trell and Authonomy as the more likely, we don't know this for sure yet
  7. The colors are not unique, for example also Devotion is white. Many Shardworlds with two Shards with a polarized Mandate end to have a black-white theme for who those Shards see themself in the regard of the other PS: Probably you mistyped but I assume you mean "Odium - Red"
  8. @The One Who Connects @Calderis I believe the same, SF inherited knowledge and Connectionts from Tanavast. SF now is more freely to act rather than before. I am just curious about how his old Knights had to live
  9. @The One Who Connects check my First reply to this topic...you understimate my Power
  10. To be' honest I don't see the risk with Atium in Era2. I know the unbalanced Harmonium theory and I like it a lot. But the Atium will be mainly useless in Era2. What makes Atium so priceless was his Allomantic effect, without Mistborn to burn It, It Will Lost 90% of his appeal. Sure It's possible but to me unlikely there are Seer among the popolation but again, with the modern weaponery and alluminium...a Seer is really Short lived being. Of course there is the Atium's Hemalurgical use but again, It does nothing you could not performe with another metal, and in Era2 the Scadrialian have all' the 16 Metals. I believe the Atium will not be broken in Era2 as most people believe. PS: I ignored the Feruchemical effect because It's not really relevant at all
  11. There are worldhoppers almost in every shardworld. It's not too hard to arrive on Roshar with the standard Cognitive Travel. The Worldhopper comunity is able to send people almost everywhere in every major Shardworld with some variable amount of effort, every planet with a Shard is almost an automatic destination for a Worldhopper unless some weirdness happens to the planet itself (for example Taldain was isolated by Authonomy and reach Sel is dangerous for the ravaging Dor)
  12. This is interesting, thank you
  13. That is the Lift's Boon recived by the Nightwatcher. Lift isn't 10 from 3 years, She actually had grown, Simply they still consider herself ad 10 years old. Lift asked what you said but the Nightwatcher can't do that and replied to something strange. Someone proposed that Lift is unable to mentally change but for now this is only a speculation. Thepoint is, Lift is growing...She had her period for the First time in Edgedancer and this make her freaking out.
  14. We don't know for sure what "the lost metal" will be. As you said in the Era2 Atium is called "the lost metal" but we don't know if the title is a reference to Atium or something else. I believe it's the atium but honestly my idea is good as someonelse's idea
  15. Mistborn's Era2 happens in the late half of Stormlight Archive. But I see nothing that could connect the two stories at the point of Honor or Cultivation as Trellium's senders (by the way, Honor is gone so He could not send anything offworld). On a last note, you seem to think that the "lost metal" and trellium are the same stuff, but we don't know it for sure.
  16. Well....I agree with the Spiritual Wound be healed indipendent by Hobber's mind but, if he see himself as a cripple man, it's possible the Healing will (physical) cripple him
  17. It's not an option but is in the same Tier, so I say Feruchemist. I strongly disagree with this for what we saw about the Surges, but I can not prove anything
  18. Yeah Shalash is confirmed By the way @Steeldancer, the male Heralds are over. Vev like all the others is female
  19. Funny I see that guy as Ishar and I am strongly for Jezrien as the drunk man in tWoK's prelude
  20. F-Gold could heal Spiritual wounds.
  21. And @WordsOfStormBlessed I hope for him to be able to recover his legs but it's not sure, It will depend on how he saw himself now...If he see himself as a cripple man, Stormlight will not heal his Soul. By the way we don't even know if the level of Squires' Stormlight usage is enough to heal the Spiritual Wound.
  22. A Spren in a Fabrial is fine, the not sapient Spren are not aware enough to judge their new position. Yeah they are in a gemstone but it's not unpleasant or something like that...it's just a change for them
  23. Yeah the book seems to imply Venli is already attuned to Odium-ish attitude. This is a weird as also if it's possible Venli already tested the Stormform before proposing the "test" to Eshonai, she lefted that form to return to the Workform....But she retains her Odium-aligned attitude, while we see Eshonai be trapped inside herself. The only way I could think the events went. It's Venli as already natural Odium-aligned and therefore the change to the Forms of Power left her almost herself (changed but free). We don't know, it have to be a really ancient time as the Parshmen are deeply radicated into Roshar's culture. At least Recreance's time if not still ancier. Probably the Unmade simply explained to them and they recorded in Songs to remember the istructions.
  24. Yeah but as far as we know, Ashlyn could be the former TH, Braize could bt the former TH or something external at all to Great Roshar System. IF also Ashlyn is the TH (and by the way, the are people living there also in modern days) this give us nothing to say on the topic you try to push into. Surgebinding as magic could not exist at all without H&C's Investment into Roshar and the Honorblades are only tool to access an already present magic system (they are not too different from Overholming Invested Surge-Fabrials). The simple existence of Surgebinding is a proof of Honor's Investiment into Roshar. We KNOW also that H&C arrived on Roshar together: And when they arrived there well already Humans and Listeners on Roshar (it's a bit harder to find that WoB but was an @Argent one). We know also they didn't edited humans to allow them Nahel Bond for multiple reasons: - Honor was surprised by the first Nahel Bonds, so it's not something of their designed. - People not native of Roshar could gain a Nahel Bond too, for the example the Irali are confirmed as not Roshar's native. About Odium's prison your idea could be good as others, it's interesting indeed but for the little we know I find it unlikely. The only words we had on the topic seems to indicate that Odium's inability to move was a side effect of something Tanavast did (from Frost's letter) but it's not enough to remove a possibility.
×
×
  • Create New...