MonsterMetroid

SO due to real life I dont have the time I would like to dedicate to this so I'm going to have to back out of this... but I would love a spec doc

Good game, its too bad I didnt get to screech on a chalkboard another cycle and try to convinve people you must have used the acid jo oh well. I look forward to a game when I can be an elim and not have item tracking undo my existence

But sart I was going to have them guess if jon used acid on devotary!

I just kickstarted the project on the epic tier and I'm not gonna lie I'm super excited for this game! Anyone else kickstart today? Here is the link to the page if you don't know what I'm talking about https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/nauvoogames/the-reckoners?ref=nav_search&result=project&term=reckon

Both!!!! shardic body swapping Oh man on a more realistic note though... I guess shards. But wouldn't that limit the player count rather low? or do you have a plan around that?

I will play. Sign me up as "The Eternally Puissant Ethelbert Hugh Broadbottom the Mighty" Edit: Longer Days please

Nb'Nub was dead. Or rather he was as good as dead. Despite his best efforts to blend in as just another soldier he had exposed himself to the group for what he really was. Looking back he knew he made a mistake, trying to give Aiden over to the brass for execution last minute seemed like a good idea at the time. It must have been the idea of freedom talking. Freedom, it had seemed so close at one point the ability to leave this accursed place that the humans called Nebrask. Nb'Nub did want to see what the outside world was like and find a way to release his brethren. But that dream was dead, just as he was soon to be. Nb'Nub found a space space to sit down and relax. "Poor Steelchalk" he thought as he took out a chalk board and some normal chalk. It appeared he was the the one that was going to be taken to leadership for "dismissal". Steelchalk and he didn't really know each other from the tower and only got to know each other after they bound themselves to these human bodies and were tasked to find a way out. But yeah the arguments were short and terse with people voting for Steelchalk and he was definately going to die today. " I don't know guys Devotary grabbing the gun seems awfully suspicious" Nb'Nub said weakly not sure himself why he even tried. The one good thing about this is that finally Nb'Nub could be himself. Nb'Nub began to drag the chalk across the board in just the right way so that it made the delightful SCREEEEEEEEEEEEEEE noise. Yes Nb'Nub could finally stop being someone he wasn't. SCREEEEE SCREE SCREE SCREEEEEEEET Nb'Nub could feel the tension leave his body as he could hear the sound of creation itself take shape. He could see the beauty of the landscape around him and gained a new appreciation for it. Yes Nb'Nub knew that the gun Devotary grabbed was meant for one person and that was for him. At least he got to see a little outside the tower even if it wasn't as much as he wanted. Yes there was worse ways to go. SCREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEETTTT T T T.

I guess I'm blind haha. Also sorry for putting you through all of that I kind of felt bad at teh end but I wanted to win!! haha Now noone will ever trust me in these games again.

so was it elen with the acid or you @BrightnessRadiant?

Probably should just call it honestly at least I can't see a way for us to win now though did I get acided and thats why i didn t get an item?

Welp rip I didnt see BR's edited post with a vote for caesura kind of a dumb way to lose but oh well

Eternum

no I'm saying that this post here Was a direct result from my bribe and would not have happened unless I traded a bribe with orlok I did trade with orlok cycle 3

Gosh... I kind of hate this because reading the tone of Caesura's posts it really does feel like they are just a new player not sure of what they are doing. But Elen has revealed some concerning things to me in my PM with him as such I have to vote for Caesura at least until @Caesura defends themselves. Also @Devotary of Spontaneity and @Steeldancer where are you guys?

OK this looks interesting but I do have a couple of questions. 1. can you trade atium to other players in return for say an action or something? 2. so you are competing against members of you r own house and multiple houses can have someone that wins then? 3. this one is less of a question and more of a complaint I guess the kandra ability doesn't feel particularly useful. It feels like with the alterante win condition taht there is much reason for them to protect the person who spent the atium on them. I suggest that if their master dies the only way they can win is by getting a new master and the only way that can happen is if someone spends atium on them. This will make them much more likely to protect their master as they are not guaranteed to get another one if they die. Just a suggestion though.

hahahaha man thats what I get for typing on a phone stupid predictive text. looking over the assumptions I definitely agree with most of them the only one that I question is this one. I need to go back andf read both of their posts because I didn t pay attention to either of them as much as I should have but I feel like DoS was never in danger so it could be that both of them could be elims, or neither if their is only 3 elims. we have to remember we don't know how many elims their are (though the gut agrees with your assumption of 4 total but it is a dangerous assumption.) I will also read over @Caesura (great name by the way, from kingkiller chronicles right?) posts I remember just getting the impression that they were a newer player. The other thing That I worry about is if Caesura is elim then we are great but what would we learn if Caesura is village? Call me paranoid but I just want to make sure we dont make a mistake that could cost us the game.

Ok I'm finally back sorry I had to write an attack for my church and I was stressed out about it. Sorry with life so busy I will actually start playing now. Though man looking at this list makes me tired... Also now that Orlok is dead I will reveal one more thing. I traded a bribe with orlok in exchange for him confirming that eternum did in fact message him about the scan, this is why orlok had three bribes. Before the traded bribe he would not admit that. Without that information we would be having a three way discussion about who to lynch which is not favorable to the elim hiding among us (unless eternum is a second elim, but I don't think that's the case). I'm guessing the third bribe must have come from BR in exchange for not shooting her after supposedly suggesting that Orlok shoot her in the first place. @ElenionI am sorry for assuming you were an elim I thought that someone was manipulating us to target the 6 which (if we assume their is only 1) had worse odds than someone outside the group. Then after we discuss that fact somehow budgie, who was in the group, gets lynched despite the math I shared. If you still think I'm suspicious I can understand, I think it is flattering that you think I could trick you in only my second game but I am a villager and I don't know what else I can do to prove it. I will say this though, with a quick elim dead I think that whoever is quick should go for the guns. I can't imagine there being three quick villagers and if there is another quick elim that will give them pause to go for it. DO NOT claim though!!!! We cant have the elims targeting you like I assume they targeted joe because he said he was going after the map. That way we will stand a better chance and you can actually kill BR even if you do kill me.

Ok guys I'm really sorry I didnt participate as much last cycle I had some RL things come up basically right after I put up the pictures. If someone could catch me up on what happened last cycle that would be great. We got one! Heck ya we can do this now guys it kind of sucks that we lost orlok but it looks like he used the map instead of shooting brightness.

OK guys sorry I haven't been on as much this cycle I was watching the Olympics and showing off my puppy last night to some friends which reminds me that some people have pmed me requesting some more pictures so here are some. Let me catch up on what I have missed and I will make a post

Wait I'm confused on what part of the reasoning Kynedath is lying about the post you linked to makes sense to me... I mean alvron couldnt use it until the next cycle right? Edit: I thought I posted this 30 mins ago but the works internet has turned into crap all of a sudden @BrightnessRadiantIf I was an elim I wouldn't want you to get shot because it would expose me and I would be guaranteed to be lynched next round. As such It really only makes sense to get lynch another elim right now get two for one cycle and if you did turn up innocent then the rest of the village would lynch me.

@BrightnessRadiant you do have some good points. I mean with eternum having an alibi of the night of the first kill it has to be either you or me that did it. You are right that I did come up with the analysis of who didn't grab things the first day and knowing that one of them must be an elim, and saying that this doesn't prove my innocence. But I can say I have tried to help the village the best I can, I asked orlok to reveal whether eternum actually had scanned him or not to everyone. Without that knowledge we would still be having a three way debate on who to lynch instead of two. If I was an elim that would have been a stupid thing to do! The only other thing I can say is that Orlok trusts me and at one point elenion did but maybe this whole accusing him of being an elim thing hasn't helped that (nothing personal @Elenion ). The only other thing I can say is that if I get lynched and brightness radiant gets shot the best we can hope for is 1 dead villager and 1 dead elim and thats before the elim kill. At this point in the game we can't afford to make a mistake especially an avoidable one. We can still win this but we need a big play this turn. Edit: also I wanted to point out that Budgie had the same excuse as me not the other way around also I had/have puppers which big sidenote has grown a ton since this game has started!!

@Orlok Tsubodai Ok that does make things a bit more interesting! Are you sure you don't... you know want to steal a bribe from someone? Well the analysis from yesterday that I have still stands as far as I see it that we are more likely to catch an elim outside of the 1st night group than in. here are my updated calculations 11 total 1 elim in group 2 in group in group 25% 50% out of the group 3 total elims 28.50% 14.29% out of group 4 total 42.85% 28.50% out of group 5 total 57.14% 42.85% you will notice the percentages are similiar outside the group and thats because... I made a mistake with my calculations yesterday I divided them by 7 instead of 8 like I should have yesterday so that was my bad @Eternum I do not in fact have the map... I do know who does, but they have asked me not to reveal that they have it. But remember someone didn't take the map alvron gave the map to someone. Edit: dang ninjad by devotary Now the thing that came to my mind while thinking about Brightness radiants arguements... I believe Orlok is the thief, but like alvron said a few days ago. Eternum could still be an elim even if he did scan orlok... Heck Eternum could have put in the kill and BR could have scanned orlok and gave him the info from the doc as an alibi but thats a lot of conjecture. Overall it seems like it would be bad strategy, but now it is something I just can't shake out of my head now that I remember it and it would only be a bad strategy if we didn't consider it... my head hurts That being said I am still suspicious of elenion as well so I would be interested in hearing what others opinions are especially people like @manukos that we haven't heard from in a while.

Thanks sart for helping me not double post again :) Current vote counts by my count: BR(1) Elenion Elenion(4) Orlok, MonsterMetroid, Kynedath, BR Devotary(1) Steeldancer If i messed up somewhere let me know

You are right about this but you brought up this logic on day 2, a villager couldn't have possibly used the map on day 2 because he only got it on day 1 so whether it was an elim or villager we wouldn't have known whether they would have used it or not until today, after we already took really crappy odds lynching a villager who just so happened to have had the map. And I will admit I should have done these calculations myself earlier rather than just assuming that there was two elims but it feels like you wanted us to think there was two.

Elenion for the reasons I listed above and that even IF he turns up village it will give us a better read on an actual elim so we will get information from his lynch either way.