Jump to content

mathiau

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    2363

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

 Content Type 

Everything posted by mathiau

  1. mathiau
    After checking the wiki, the Dor is indeed not a spren. No confirmation for the Evil. I don't remember seeing any clear gazeous investiture on Threnody, I think the wood where misty so maybe some mists of Ambition By different I meant if Harmony went to Roshar he'd probably start creating harmonylight which would behave in a way far more similar to stormlight. I find unlikely that gazeous investiture would work nearly the same way for Odium, Honour and Cultivation but very differently with Preservation and Harmony. Another thing that makes me thing each shard can have more than one gaseous investiture is the colour issue. Preservation and Ruin are not actually white and black, they only seemed to be that way on Scadrial after a time , their real colour is RAFO. So that imply their mists didn't start white or could have been of on other colour in an other situation. The Dor is a mass of investiture looked into the Cognitive realm, it don't physically appears in the book. And it looks like plasma in Shadesmar
  2. mathiau
    And she and access to ferruchemical gold, of course she'd have access to ferruchemical gold. "Why switch one? Couldn't you just add it? And does the Soverain often make people as strong as you or are you an exception?"
  3. mathiau
    Adiline was still tapping her connexion with Raven when she arrived to Drae and Eryn "I see you've already freed him. Does any of his spikes look like they can be safely removed?" @Kingsdaughter613@Lecky Twig
  4. mathiau
    I personally find Mists, Breaths and Lights too fundamentally different, with the first two being stable in the human body, Mists being quite stable in the atmosphere and and Breaths being stable in every solids. These are sprens, not lights
  5. mathiau
    If you compare the surgebinding chart with the voidbinding one, the orders are linked to the same surges with an additional weirdness for Truthwatchers and Boundsmiths (and no, Brandon didn't confirmed there where no voidbindind Boundsmiths, he confirmed there was no fused Boundsmiths and they're surgebinders). So Warbinders like Rlain will probably have the same surges used in a different way.
  6. mathiau
  7. mathiau
    You posted these two And no one posted in between
  8. mathiau
    Errrr double post
  9. mathiau
  10. mathiau
    It's surprising Odium is even able to do that. I assume it means the other fused don't have access to Honour's rhythms otherwise he'd still have them
  11. mathiau
  12. mathiau
    I don't understand. I'm still laughing
  13. mathiau
  14. mathiau
    "I agree, go stop them" Marie was still under the previous order of not killing people so there would probably be something left to interrogate afterward "I'll help the other with Raven" With Drae's help it was possible she would just need to tap and not to compound @Lecky Twig@Kingsdaughter613
  15. mathiau
    It's only supposed to work on lifeless since their breath are no longer keyed to anyone
  16. mathiau
    It'll actually be sound memory of your inner voice reading the book. And as I say in my first post it's possible to do test that test if you're able use your knowledge and not just if you have that knowledge, coppermind won't help you for that. Actually I meant you were right to say learning =/= knowing even if the dictionary seemed to say the opposite. "Knows how to" and "has learned how to" is essentially the only case where they're the same
  17. mathiau
    That was not my point. Also without actually what? In this case that dictionary as exact
  18. mathiau
    At least in the village, copper ferrings would probably have a different education than most other child since memorizing thing would not be needed for them, at least they'd have different tests that do not focus an memorising thing but proving you can do, like these tests were you have access to your course notes. And the existence of archivists mean Jeopardy-like games have basically no chance to take of on Scadrial (and if Jeopardy itself allowed an AI to participate, they'd have allowed a ferring) It's like Shallan's photographic memory A negligible time and effort, and negligibe degradation for other things than images
  19. mathiau
    It would make no sense for the combination not to have an anti-side, with the knowledge Navani have at the end of RoW she'll probably make anti-war with the next everstorm.
  20. mathiau
    They've been showed to be innocent of crimes the characters think they committed once and guilty one (and they arguably did order Ialai's murder). A good reason not to have shown the carriage being burn is it was not necessary and the book was already big enough. So easily traced back to them Shallan couldn't bring anyone to justice. If you meant "Shallan knew it was them in a second", it was a warning, her knowing was the rusting point. Once again, we only know three people of the ghostblood, we can't assume all of them are as subtle. And Kelsier was not always subtle. She still died because the GB wanted it, Radiant only killed her so Shallan wouldn't have too. And unless I'm mistaken, in world they couldn't trace it to them. Now the 17th shard/Harmony belive they were one of the numerous victims of the attack and not one of Mraize.
  21. mathiau
    We literally know three GBs and two are in the same team, we can't assume none of the other would do a warning kill after being told they can. And Mraize finished his report on Ishnah by you can kill her if you want which implies GBs murder without GB reason relatively often Mraize didn't see things that way It's not how guilt works, they're just the most obvious suspect and are blamed when they're innocent but that don't make them always innocent.
  22. mathiau
    Twelve more since storm+anti-void is not the same as void+anti-storm. If we can use all sixteen shard it become just dumb, 131 070 lights without storm+anti-void and 86 093 440 with it
  23. mathiau
    It's possible they consider it a special subset of Surgebinding, or that it's just to weird so they gave it another name
  24. mathiau
    It works for fused so of course it'd work for an herald, and a herald on Braize before the Everstorm would have messed up everything, Odium wouldn't have needed the Everstorm anymore. How would you know how a half-bounded shardblade look like to the one who killed it? Especially one with access to illusion? I mean, Shallan still had some access to her powers between her mother's death and her bounding Patern.
  25. mathiau
    That hydra one was sooo on the nose
×
×
  • Create New...