Jump to content

Yata

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    5305

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Yata

  1. Yata
    Yes exactly and by the way it's unsure if the Alluminium could be Soul-cutted by a Shardblade
  2. Yata
    Half Shard aren't made of Alluminium. They are just Augmenter Fabrials
  3. Yata
    I have this foolish idea to go at the signing but I have to take a couple of days from work and they will never give to me
  4. Yata
    @Blightsong I think your theory is really cool but I don't see it as likely First of all, if the Radiant-Shadows are bound to Braize, I see no easy way for them to arrive on Roshar. If they are not bound to Braize we will have a bunch or Radiant-Shadow in the Roshar's Shadesmar and Radiant Spren would know this. Secondly the Murders (and therefore this creature's work) started before the return of the Stormlight. This mean this creature did what she did without have a decent source of Investiture. I see hard for a cognitive shadow (but also for a Spren) to interact to that degree without be extremely Invested. Third, I can't see as plausible for a Radiant-Shadow to keep the use of Surges after his bond is released. For now, I am really doubtful about the copy-cat murder's identity. I see a strong connection with the Midnight Essences but it seems still different from them
  5. Yata
    Indeed for now we know only that Innate Investiture could be stored, we don't know if this could be do with Kinetic too (I believe no, or at least the Southern didn't discover this yet). I didn't point too much at this because every metalmind will be a good source of Investiture with enough Hacks....Nicrosil or not-Nicrosil isn't really relevant here
  6. Yata
    I am unsure to follow you. If breaking the Oaths is a Voidbringers' chance to enter. The Recreance is letterally an huge gateway for the Voidbringer not a way to seal it off. But maybe I just misundertood your point.
  7. Yata
    Yeah this is one of the main theory about the Stormstriders also if I never believed too much, having an Unmade around isn't something I see the Stormfather too happy with and Pattern neither say something in that context
  8. Yata
    All the form of Kinetic Investiture are mostly interchangable so in theory nothing prevent this. Much more this kind of stuff is true with every kind of Feruchemist as every attribute is stored as Investiture in the metalmind (and this is also true for every kind of Allomancer) BUT it will not be an automatic change, you will need to hack the magic to allow the Feruchemy-fueled Surgebinding.
  9. Yata
    My bad, I misread your question. Indeed I believe (but here I could be wrong) that Copper doesn't affect the Lifesense at all, Lifesense for the in-world descriptions and Realmatical meaning seems to be Spiritual in nature, as the Breath allows you to be better connected with the sorround and LifeSense gives you simply a way to mesure the amount of Innate Investiture in the living things around you. I will try to see if there are WoB on the topic but I am at work and theoryland is off-limit in this network
  10. Yata
    An Awakener's Breath will be unspottable by Bronze-sense regardless of the Copper, Bronze spots Kinetic Investiture usages and Breath into someone are not. I see no reason to be impossible, you need just skill to detect them as "magical pulses" No idea but if the Proximity work on a Cognitive level, it's possible it does. As far as I know there are not Aon that mimic Bronze or Copper effects, but if there are the right Allomancy would counter it. Of course as the AonDor is fueled by a limitless amount of Investiture. It's possible the "Bronze Aon" will simply pierce whaterver Coppercloud you use or something like that The interactions are at Realmatic level, there is no reason to be restricted to other Aons
  11. Yata
    The Stormfather at the end of WoR. But It's speed isn't indicative of Its power
  12. Yata
    You could but: 1. You can't be sure he really did it until someone else try to bond with the Blade and after days the Blade is still not-bonded 2. Possible but it's still the case "you can't imprison a Shardbearer". He could re-summon the Blade in a couple of seconds and you honestly can't watch him 24/7 (or the Roshar's version 20/5) Of course, it's not impossible to keep prisoner a Shardbearer, but the resource to keep a single prisoner will be ridicolous...much more because lawly speaking a Shardbearer is by default an high class citizen and he has rights to protect him
  13. Yata
    The Gemstones allow the Shardblade's bond and the Bond turns the Eyes lighter (we see it with Moash)...This implicit suggests that Lighteyes are superior from the Cultural PoV
  14. Yata
    Reading the story I understood she grew old in the time she spent to reach the top
  15. Yata
    Did you realize the amount of Bronze she would need ? To pierce a Coppercould she would need tons of Bronze and she would need to flare it....Before Kelsier gave her a vial of metal, Vin always performed Allomancy with some metallic traces she casually eated/drinked. Probably she never reached the point of her regolar burning before Kel
  16. Yata
    There is a WoB about but it's not really detailed, it says something like "Division works at molecular level or it will be too OP, but another book has a division-like ability to atomic level"
  17. Yata
    The fact she didn't hear anything does not give us a proof of something as she will be able to hear allomantic pulse with and without her Spike. Notice also that Vin didn't grow up in the Nobles' circle...what are the chances an allomancer was burning a metal near her just in the little time she was casually burn Bronze ?
  18. Yata
    My point is Jasnah does this kinds of stuff always. She didn't believe there was something wrong in the bread..but She did It regardless. Also as far as we know, She will be uncapable of Soulcasting Bread into other Bread without visible effects. Honestly I find your scenario with Jasnah Who made intentonally Shallan get poisoned a bit unrealistic as she could obtain the exactly same effect (without risk for Shallan) asking to Kasbal to eat First. Jasnah is not a gamber, She is quite the opposite of a gamber. Your whole scenario has too many variables to be' likely for someone like Jasnah
  19. Yata
    Could be' both
  20. Yata
    I was talking about the Bread
  21. Yata
    Actually Amaram could re-summon the Blade at any moment. You can't know for sure he cuts the Bond with the Blade when he leave the Blade to someone else. It's like the King's Blades, you can't really steal them as Elk could summon them again at any moment. The only way to broke a Shardblade's Bond is to kill the Bearer or made the Bearer release the Bond
  22. Yata
    Well Ishar isn't a Radiant either
  23. Yata
    I honestly doubt It was a Story about Shallan... It's a relative famous story
  24. Yata
    I think Jasnah Soulcasts everything before eat it if She isn't 100% sure about the food
  25. Yata
    Well this whole theory was build around the idea of a compatibility between Devotion and Dominion. As I said, I saw them pointed to the same goal with very different methods
×
×
  • Create New...