Anniversary Game 3: The Curse of the Koloss

[Conquestor he/him]

Orlock, I hope you get better

28 minutes ago, Magestar said:

I'll vote for STINK as well.   I have reasons I'll explain later, when I have time.

Every time I look at this game, I keep getting surprised I'm alive.   I usually don't survive games this long.

-sigh-  I suppose this means the Elims don't see me as a threat.

And there goes my ego.

Those small little slips are the things we really need to look out for, so, I propose that we should feast on lynch Magestar!

 

"Hey, look blood!" someone says. Everyone stops for a moment then starts chasing after the person that accidently cut himself. "I guess even the regular people are working for Ruin," Mr. Hoid said.

[Jondesu he/him]

12 minutes ago, A Joe in the Bush said:

Lol, i was about to say that

EDIT: @Metacognition If a mistborn with pewter gets attacked, can they draw Pewter again?

He said before that he rolls again if he rolls a power they had before, but whatever comes up the second time he sticks with.  So if they can roll Pewter twice (which that would confirm they can), then I expect they would be protected each time they roll it.  It's just less likely than the metals they haven't used yet.

[Jo and the Bush all/any]

I meant once the powers refresh. Or is pewter forever taken out of their power pool? Or worse, do they roll it, but not have the extra life.

[Conquestor he/him]

Magestar! (Because I forgot to red my vote)

[Jondesu he/him]

9 minutes ago, A Joe in the Bush said:

I meant once the powers refresh. Or is pewter forever taken out of their power pool? Or worse, do they roll it, but not have the extra life.

I was thinking that the power they roll is basically what they get a vial of. That means they get a vial of pewter: it can save their life that round. I could be wrong, but the way it's been worded implied to me that the one-time save thing was for Thugs specifically, not Mistborn.

[Magestar he/him]

Ya know, I seriously considered not saying that.

But I felt I needed to.

Ah well.  

[Sart he/him]

11 hours ago, Herowannabe said:

Oh wow, and I thought I was pushing myself with averaging 5-6 hours of sleep. Yes, by all means take a break from SE and take good care of yourself. The game is fun but not worth endangering your health over. 

We'll see you when such a time comes that you can make room in your schedule for SE and get plenty of sleep.  

 

Anyway, I just woke up and I'm on mobile so I'm going to keep this short.  I still suspect Sart.

Sart you asked me about inconsistencies in your brief analysis and suspicion list. I don't have time to go through the whole thing but as one example you claim I defended Nyali. I admit that I never actually cast a vote for her, but not for lack of willingness to. The day she was lynched I was fully planning on coming back to change my vote to her but I got my days mixed up and the cycle ended before I could. I didn't vote for her before that because at the time I had other people I suspected more. So to say I "defended" Nyali is a distortion of facts, or at least a very selective choosing of which facts to address and which to ignore. 

There were other, similar such distortions / selective choosings for other players on your list, but I don't remember them off the top of my head and I don't have time to look it up now anyway.

"Wasing the being of voting. Ising the being of defending of not." Sart had mostly based his analysis on voting patterns. He had seen Herwynbe's vote on Rae as a tacit defense of Nyal. He understood that analyzing posts were important, but he had been more concerned with getting his analysis out on time. If that lead to misconceptions, then he supposed he was sorry for them.

[Seonid he/him]

I think that I'll go with Elbereth. This is normal behavior for Stink, at least from my recollection. Hardly says anything in-thread, and is mostly active in PMs. We haven't had PMs hardly at all, so...mostly inactive.

[Metacognition he/him]

4 hours ago, A Joe in the Bush said:

EDIT: @Metacognition If a mistborn with pewter gets attacked, can they draw Pewter again?

 

4 hours ago, A Joe in the Bush said:

I meant once the powers refresh. Or is pewter forever taken out of their power pool? Or worse, do they roll it, but not have the extra life.

Jondesu has the right of it, but I'll make it official. Mistborn can draw Pewter again and, when drawn, they will have an extra life; even if they had drawn Pewter before and were attacked/lynched. One special note- If a Mistborn draws Pewter twice in a row, the extra lives do not stack. The first instance of Pewter will wear off at the end of the Day turn and they will get a new set of Pewter at the beginning of a Night turn. So they'll only be able to have one extra life at a time, but if they get lucky, they could draw it multiple turns.  

This is due to the fact that they only have Pewter for a limited amount of time and that they cannot plan on when they will draw Pewter. 

[Araris Valerian he/him]

Aralis was tired. He was tired of fake Koloss, and of hitting people on the head, and he was tired of being old. He would probably retire after this nonsense blew over, at least for a while. You never can tell when a town will need an old cynic to keep things in check. But for now, he figured that Senn was up to something. Aralis had gone to all that work, practically breaking his staff in half, to get people to stay involved in the discussion until there was a consensus that it was over. And now that some people had listened, Senn was trying to kill one of them. Seemed like a great way to make sure that the rest came back to help... Not only that, but he didn't even give any reasoning behind why he thought El should die.

[Seonid he/him]

33 minutes ago, Araris Valerian said:

Aralis was tired. He was tired of fake Koloss, and of hitting people on the head, and he was tired of being old. He would probably retire after this nonsense blew over, at least for a while. You never can tell when a town will need an old cynic to keep things in check. But for now, he figured that Senn was up to something. Aralis had gone to all that work, practically breaking his staff in half, to get people to stay involved in the discussion until there was a consensus that it was over. And now that some people had listened, Senn was trying to kill one of them. Seemed like a great way to make sure that the rest came back to help... Not only that, but he didn't even give any reasoning behind why he thought El should die.

Mostly because Stink's comment sounds like he has access to privileged knowledge.

[Herowannabe he/him]

Well, I officially started my business today. Avalon Woodcraft, LLC- specializing in custom cabinets and fine woodworking. Bought myself a CNC router and everything. Just thought I'd share. 

And now I'm going to bed. I'm beat. 

[Araris Valerian he/him]

How does STINK having special knowledge make lynching Elbereth a good idea? For starters, he said basically the same things about Assassin. Also, I'm pretty sure the only players with special knowledge are Joe from his PMs, and the eliminators.

[STINK he/him]

Mrw people lynch you even after Mage just keeps saying that he is basically agreeing with what I say.

[Magestar he/him]

2 hours ago, STINK said:

Mrw people lynch you even after Mage just keeps saying that he is basically agreeing with what I say.

With your posts being about a sentence long each, it's not hard to agree with them.

[STINK he/him]

"Hey guys, you think the evil might have been somewhat inactive?" Applies to me and Mage.

Both of us lynched assassin.

'Cept I'm not the one hiding behind the other one.

#LynchMageToday

Oh and btw, my vote on Assassin was me trying to figure out who was willing to bandwagon what, and seeing as Mage didn't really have any reasoning, I was sus of him already

 

 

[Stick. she/her]

17 hours ago, Magestar said:

I'll vote for STINK as well.   I have reasons I'll explain later, when I have time.

Do you have time now?

edit: I'd be suspicious of you, but this sounds genuine...idk

Quote

You know, I'm going to just go sit in a corner and cry.  

-sigh-

You can interpret that as either Carmichael or me;  It's pretty accurate either way.  Sorry, Assassin.

 

 

Edited February 14, 2017 by _Stick_

[Magestar he/him]

47 minutes ago, _Stick_ said:

Do you have time now?

Sort of.  I'm not loving the way STINK is acting, but now, having looked back over it, I'm not sure if it's a lot different than he acts normally.  I have a couple ideas about who else might be an Elim if STINK is, but I'm not sure if that's a good reason to lynch him.  So I'm actually going to take my vote off of him.  STINK.  El.

My reasons for voting on her are the same as before, plus, I this would be the second game in a row that El went somewhat inactive as an Elim.

Like I said earlier, if you guys want to lynch me, that's fine.  I'm not going to defend myself, since I don't think I've been as helpful as I could have been, and I doubt if my death will effect the outcome of the game.

[Stick. she/her]

STINK. I don't think I have a solid reason to be suspicious of El.

[STINK he/him]

Alright, rip me.

[little wilson she/her]

I cannot see where the suspicion on stink is coming from. He's literally acting exactly as he has in every other game.... games where he's been village. Oh, he defended Dalinar, sure, but his tone in every post while "defending" Dalinar was clear irritation with the entire situation as opposed to scrambling to protect a teammate from getting lynched. And he has higher knowledge? Have you missed the past bunch of games when Stink says, in seemingly utter certainty, that another player is evil? That's just what Stink does when he's either trying to see who follows along (so baiting) or he's just truly very suspicious of that person. And it's not like that's something new to this game. It's just Stink.

Mage. This is in part due to my prior suspicions of you and also due to buddying up with Stink. Your willingness to die is about the only thing that I see that speaks in your favor, but at the same time, it could be an IKYK. People will be less likely to kill you because you're saying that you're so willing to die and because a spiked wouldn't be so willing to die so you must be village... Unless you're a spiked who knows how the village will react to seeing how willing you are to die, and therefore says that to make it less likely that you will die.

I have no idea what the vote count is right now and I won't be on again until after rollover so I apologize if this ties something up. Well, not really, since I'm fairly convinced that stink is village and I'd rather he not die. Also, I'm getting ready to move this weekend, so will be less active. I should be able to maintain a post a cycle, but we'll see.

Oh, and sorry for any typos in this post. Posting via phone and haven't really proofread it. >>

 

[Jondesu he/him]

Vote Tally:

Sart (1): Herowannabe
STINK (4): Jondesu, Wyrmhero, A Joe in the Bush, Magestar, Stick
Magestar (2): Conquestor, little wilson
Elbereth (2): Seonid, Magestar
Seonid (1): Araris Valerian

You didn't tie up the lead, wilson, but you did give us a tie for second place.  Even if Stink's behavior seems normal, I'm really feeling like it's time for him to go.  I'd prefer we keep enough of a gap to avoid any vote shenanigans.

[STINK he/him]

Mage

Gotta get that official vote in peeps, also appreciate the support Jondesu, you think I'd really do shenanigans for shenanigans sake? Ha, that'd be great, if I wasn't trying to finish the game. Oh well, at least in the dead doc I can be all 'I told you so'

[Sart he/him]

Sart ran to the gallows. "Hasing the being of doubt of both. Being the ising of Mage. Being the ising of being. Hasing the being of willing." The village needed more time to discuss this lynch. They were running out of people, and they couldn't afford another mislynch. In addition, the person being lynched was being voted on by his two main suspicions, while the Terris steward lurked in the shadows. Therefore, Sart had decided to tie up the lynch. It might have been foolhardy, but it was the only action he could live with.

[Jo and the Bush all/any]

Gah, in a hurry. Stink mage