Macen

I think removing a win condition for the 17s would make it perfect. They know of each other, can't reveal each other, and can't win together. It adds an extra layer of subterfuge in behind the scenes. Also, I thought the dead tweet was a great idea - it kept the game interesting for the dead. We may consider restricting what the dead can say to be more cryptic. Maybe the GB sets a certain code type each night that they have to relay the information in - and restrict what they can reveal. Would add more talk about what we can say. All around though, great game! I liked the idea of multiple factions. I just think that the 17s had too going for them. They had access to all of the conversations, and little reason to ally with their normal factions over the 17s. The normal factions still had a shot though, so it wasn't too bad. *EDIT* Also, what is a Forescout?

Meta, the only complaint I have is for someone trying to think of a game and what setting they want it in. I don't want to make a game that is exactly like a game someone else is wanting to make, so I would want to review the games people have already posted and try to make sure it doesn't copy them. But, this table of contents works perfectly!

Gamma, Meta, Wilson. Is there any chance we could make "The Art of Creating a Role" a subforrum? I think it would be easier for organization of the different ideas and making sure we keep them separated.

I really want to ask a boon in the QF2 to ask for my MAce. But, I doubt I would get it, and I'm scared of the curse. Also, everyone would know who had it when it was used.

The Trick to this is using the [*color=blue][/color] tags (Minus the *). I used to have the same problem. *EDIT* Wilson, I'm trying to send in my commands, but I can't find a list of the players anywhere. Can we get a list on the main post of the main thread? That way I don't spell people's Character names wrong.

It was an amazing game. If not for Wurum and Meta (along with many others) we were doomed. I made some bad calls and nearly dragged us under (especially my accusation of meta, but thankfully Cara still trusted him, or we probably would have lost). This was my first game having as much information as I did and I think I learned a lot. Hopefully I can be a little smarter about my decisions in the future. Thanks to Meta for trusting me, even when you had no reason to - sorry for backstabbing you (I was SO sure). Also, thanks Wurum for trusting me, and helping sort out some of the details - I wish you all could see our PM conversation, over 200 pm's in less than 6 days. Also, every one of my other highprinces/ses thanks for trusting me when you did. I also would like to apologize for those I lead the charge in lynching. Anyways - this game was AMAZING, it nearly completely consumed my free time for the last month. Thank you for putting it together Mail, and thanks for putting up with all of my questions. See you guys in the next game.

Ace stood over a pile of chull droppings... He knew they were around here, how else to explain this riot that had come out of nowhere? He wondered how he hadn't noticed one of them lurking about, they must have some sort ability to blend in. Could they possibly be able to make themselves look like us!? This was quite a revelation. If the chulls could make themselves look like us, then the source of the desolation could be hiding among those who were now running about the city. How was he supposed to find a chull to interrogate them, if he didn't even know w hat they looked like!? I have been hearing rumors of people going to the Nightwatcher more lately, due to the riots. Perhaps I will consider doing this myself one of these nights. First though, he was going to go find that Panda Man who he had seen jumping around on the rooftops, he seemed to have a keen affinity for animals. Perhaps he was a hidden chull-agent. If not, then perhaps Ace could convince him to help him in his hunt. Sorry for song long between RP. Ace, the Animal Detective, is going to track down the source of these riots, and hopefully the desolation itself! If you haven't caught on... a nefarious group of Chulls are behind it all.

Definitely not gloating, Awes was a step ahead of me the entire game, so I don't have much to gloat about, even if I wanted to. I just hadn't done any RP for this character yet, and I felt that was a good bit to add in (Wurum and I had talked about leaving him for last since he was the one who had announced himself to get us to lynch him).

Rubix, Any chance we can get a player listing? At least at the beginning of the main post, also possibly each day post (I know that's a lot harder to do). Also, if we have questions that are more Role-specific, can we ask those via PM, and have you post the question/answer in thread? A lot of questions might be more specific on how a role works and might reveal what role you are.

Ace leaned over Awes before he walked away. "We thought it would be fitting. You being the one who tricked me so many times. You get to die last, and alone." With these words, Ace walked to Wurum and his meeting place with a smug look on his face. I am a little curious as to who you made your heir. I also forgot that the Shardblade blocks a pain knife. Doh.

I agree with Meta, you guys did an amazing job of this. I knew someone I was in contact with for a while was GB. It looks like our party of 3 suspecting Awes (which we did early) was for a good reason. You did do a perfect job of making us think that one of us was the bad guy. Mostly due to the spanreed deal. I honestly don't know if we would be where we are right now if the Soul-Caster hadn't hit Khas's Shardblade action, so this is almost completely based on chance. Also, me getting the Shardhammer made a huge difference as well, which is more or less luck as well - anyone could have figured it out before I did (Mine was also an educated guess, at best). The answers were "Bridge Four" and "The Lopen" in case anyone was wondering.

I'm pretty sure the pain knife you stole earlier counts. I don't think you need to hold one of each, I think you just need to have one of each at some point in the game.

Ugh. I personally think that was the single most important decision of the game. You got 3 people lynched because of it. Stroke of genius.

So you guys didn't have a spanreed either? Or did you just never use it to confuse us? *EDIT* Well, the combination of you guys protecting someone who had plate on with a painrial, attacking our grandbow holder, and you having shardplate - had me convinced Tion had given you the plate, and that he had told you guys the plan. Sorry Meta - Awes had me so twisted around I was pointing at shadows.

Now that I think about it, Wurum decided to have us aim Khaz at you instead of himself because of how we read something in writeup. If we would have read that a little better (I think we were both pretty tired), we would have realized that the reason we were having him aim you instead of himself should have been telling us to have Alv aim at you, and Wurum aim at Khaz. Oh well. *EDIT* - I went back and Looked. Wurum told me to have the Soul-Caster aim Alv at Awes, I just misread it. if that would have worked, Awes would be dead and Saritu would be alive. Then Khaz would have done whatever he was trying to do - hopefully attacking myself, or Wurum. :/

I would also like to plate my vote, for Khas. Question awes, how did you know Wurum has the bow and that we were attacking you? That convinced me that Tion was a GB. *EDIT* Changed Khaz to Khas.

Good game sir. I wish I would have thought of the challenge before you... Doh.

Unless there were 5 intial GB (which is possible). We have a 7v3 vote going today. It could also be 6v4 if they had 5 to start with. I personally think we should vote Awes or Alv, they both have no protection left and we know where the shardblade is now. *EDIT* If we vote Khaz, we don't know where the shardblade will go - we should just Pain-Knife him.

BOOM! Khaz has the shardblade and Alv is the other GB. Also... My MAce is nice and shiny, isn't it? EDIT - I really wish we would have stuck to the plan to have Khaz target himself. Would have been hilarious. Also, sorry - I got REALLY excited, I wasn't sure how this would play out.

So.. Many... upvotes required.... I don't have enough to give around, but give I did. Well done my friends, well done.

Brandon Sanderson is secretly on our side... what more could you ask for? *EDIT* We have a reverser as well. So, unless you have 3, which I seriously doubt, then we are at a stalemate. Also, why would the thief pick your side, and get his secondary objective, when he could pick our side and get his Primary AND Secondary roll by staying with us. I see the angle you're trying to work here, and I can't blame you for trying. But, it seems a little desperate. I never called for his death, neither did Wurm. As far as I know - those are the only 100% certain Nobles... How is he supposed to know you guys didn't call for his death?

Mr Thief, I can also help you get pretty much every item you want, and Awes has less of a chance than he thinks he does. It's currently 7v4 or 8v3. Even if they manage to kill 2 people tonight (I don't think it's very likely), we still have a strong number advantage and a lot more power than he thinks we do. Ultimately, it's your choice. But - I'd much prefer it if you assist us instead of the ghostblood scum who killed our king and manipulated me into ousting my own friends.

So. I've been thinking about it, and whoever recommended that we vote for awes today was probably right (it worked out great for us) if we attack him tonight, and vote him tomorrow - we won't get any of his items. At the moment I'm thinking we will pick a different target and just shut him down, but I haven't decided. If anyone has any better idea's send them my way and I'll take them into consideration. I probably won't be on any more tonight, so have a great night guys.

Well rust, I hope a noble got it. Mail, were more than one final item given away? You said to "those". *edit* I know it's not relevant to the game, but I just realized I forgot to post a picture of my sunburn like I promised. This is my arm from just a few minutes ago, over 3 days after the burn. This is one of the least burned parts of my upper body :/ P.S. I don't know how to make the image smaller, sorry guys.

Alv voted Tion.