Macen
-
Posts
475 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Macen
-
Long Game 43: Under the Banner of Adonalsium
Macen replied to Seonid's topic in Sanderson Elimination
I'm seriously thinking about making a return for this game, but I'm on the fence if I can invest the time. I also barely recognize anyone anymore! I guess t hat's what happens when i haven't played in almost 2 years... Don't count me in yet, but let me see. -
So... my painknife can be blocked by a shardplate? Weird.
-
So, there is almost no way for Wilson to be the GB. I'm assuming she was attack by Nyali, and I pain knifed her. So, She couldn't have used her shardblade to kill twei, blocked with her armor, AND used the GB kill. I would have blocked one of the three actions. I could be miscounting here though.
-
I retract my vote on Zas. And will also vote Wilson. Sorry K-dawg.
-
At this point, it's more likely to get me killed than saved. I also have a half shard that I've had since the beginning of the game (I have told no one about it). I haven't told anyone because, what's the point of having something that will only stop 1 type of attack if the enemy knows you have it and can just use the other type of attack? I don't see how having it could make me look bad, and not telling about it and having Twei scan me WOULD look bad. I started with a Pain Knife and a Half-Shard. I found another pain knife at some point, which was destroyed since I already had one. That is 100% accounting for what items I've had.
-
I was told that I pain knifed Zas. Zas has confirmed this. So, that leaves two people saying I used my action (it was my only action) on Zas. That makes me suspicious of you Twei.
-
damnation. That is the only way he could have been ok...
-
So, if Twei got notified that Zas targetted her with a Painrial, or if emotion bracelet-ed it (which means the action went through), then he lied about me blocking it. So, that means I blocked another action of his. This makes me thinks more that he is a GB.
-
Twei, how do you know he had a painrial? Mail: Will someone still be alerted that they were targeted for an action, even if the person using the action on them gets Pain Knifed? I'm curious if we caught Zas in a lie or not.
-
I'm going to vote for Zas because of this. For two reasons. One, I already said that I used my pain knife last night. Two, I pain knifed him, so he would have gotten a notification stating that someone pain knifed one of his actions.
-
I pain knifed Zas. At this point, I I don't know what's going on. It's possible that the GB attack was stopped, or it's possible that the GB has a SB and isn't attacking with both the GB attack and the SB attack? No idea.
-
haha, yeah - I didn't think about that. I think we are going to frame it in my "Man cave". haha
-
I'm guessing 5 is probably the number as well - it's possibly 6 though. very very much doubt it's 7.
-
Hard but not impossible. We have like 30 hours, figured it's worth an analysis if someone has time.
-
Does anyone have time to go through the GB kills and the items the GB had when they died and see if that adds up? If we are missing an item (and stink is telling the truth - which is probably likely), then it might eliminate Kyne as a suspect.
-
I think Kyne is as safe a vote as anyone else. I think the numbers are strongly in our favor now - which is good.
-
Well done. I was originally going to pain knife Stink. Then I switched to you, then Wilson, then finally settled on Alv. I couldn't make up my mind - but he was "active" and not posting - so it made me suspicious. *EDIT* Fixed crappy grammar/wording. Don't worry, I know it's still somewhat crappy.
-
Mail: DId you think it would be funny to make everyone who was an eliminator in LG5 an eliminator in this game? lol. Kas and Alv both.
-
I pain knifed alv. So, that is a possible reason there is no GB kill? I can't prove that I did - but that's what I did. *EDIT* Also, alv was active RIGHT after the night ended, so I'm guessing he was also active before (time doesn't show history). So, he probably put in an action. Might have only been a soulcaster or painrial though.
-
Well, if they were planning on NOT killing anyone and using the lynches, they might risk it to get a kill, and get me lynched wasting a lynch kill. 2 for the risk is much better than 1. *EDIT* On a side note - I'm fairly certain that Stink is going to kill me tonight - and I'm not pain knifing him (I'll state who I pain knifed in my deathcry). I probably won't be able to post any more tonight. Have a lot planned this evening and a busy afternoon at work.
-
You stating this means they will most likely use an action now to make me look suspicious. This could work in our favor though, since there is a good chance of an alerter or emotion bracelet catching someone. I already have my action in this time btw - so no chance of getting too busy after leaving work.
-
I did mean Lopen - thank you. The main point I'm making is: Why would I admit that if I was a GB? It makes zero sense. This is you taking your opinion and stating it as fact. There are many other options that could have happened here. The most obvious option is that they didn't submit their orders, but there are quite a few other options (one of which I listed above).
-
Sorry for the double post - was going to do an edit, but it contains more than the last post: If I was a GB, I would have just claimed I Pain Knifed someone else and got them killed. This path of logic you're going down requires that the person in question (me) be oblivious to how things would be perceived. I'll admit - I did forget about your protecting stink - but that doesn't make me any less suspicious of him. WGG is a silly strategy, but I've seen it used multiple times before. I would like to point out that I was the FIRST person to call Kas out as GB (before he went inactive, when he was still being pretty active). It's POSSIBLE that he told me "Yo, call me out - i'm going to be inactive", but you have to decide for yourself how likely that is. I have been vocally suspicious of Kas, DC, Stink, and Sheep. 2 of them tuned out to be good (Sheep and DC), and one turned out to be evil. So, I'm batting .250 - what are your numbers? Next, if you are willing to believe that Kas told me to call him out and that's why I'm evil - what is to say that the same didn't go with your an Orlok? Especially since Orlok just "gave up" and admitted to being evil with a ton of time left int he cycle. No, your logic isn't adding up for me - even if I look at everything from an outside looking in perspective - it doesn't add up. *EDIT* Also, another reason for not putting in a GB kill is the number of alerters floating around. With the death cry, it gives away who did the GB kill - if someone had enough control of how the votes were going to go, they could just use the votes and Stink Vig killing people to whittle us down without risking the only 100% way for us to know they are GB. *EDIT 2* This makes me think Stink and Nyali could very easily be in cahoots.
-
If you think I would have admitted that if I was a GB, then you must not think very highly of my intelligence. (I don't mean that literally, but I'm not one to make that kind of mistake).
-
I'm not sure how Stink got cleared on this one? He has admitted to killing two villagers that almost EVERYONE thought were good. I understand the suspicion of Kyne, Alvron, and myself - I Just don't understand the lack of suspicion of Stink. *EDIT* I would like to point out that Mark was double tapped - I find it hard to believe that was coincidence. Also, since he probably has quite a few items, it's possible it's just him, or him and 1 other who is less active. He may have wanted to have his defensive slot available and used his Bow and t2 slot instead of the GB kill.
