Macen
-
Posts
475 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Macen
-
Since Endowment doesn't get shattered if the holder dies, it would be counter-productive for the OC to kill endowment when they have figured out who holds it (as Clanky mentioned). Also, if Wilson is an OC, then they have knowledge of who every shard is. That would line up with how every odium attack has hit a shard holder... but it could also be that someone wilson trusts is an OC, or it could be just luck. The ploy that wilson did the other night with blocking the two people who she thought might be odium confuses me slightly though. If odium knew about that plan, you would think Odium would have NOT attacked that night (making it look like one of the roleblocks hit odium, so we lynched a shard). So, this is what makes me think that Wilson is probably good, because she could have used that gambit to get the villagers to lynch a good shard, and wasting a day of discussion. I'm going to go with Wilson for now, if Alv turns out to be good, then either Wilson, or one of her most trusted people, are Odium/OC Shard.
-
I just went through and read Alv's signature. I'm not going to lie, I read this: As "Two honorspren (Corrupted by Chlamydia)" Needless to say, I was a bit off.
-
Not the hat!?
-
How about we plan this. If alv is innocent, we lynch Wilson next? I personally do find it fishy that Odium has not killed anyone except shards and our village kills / lynches have all killed only good guys / no one. I still currently trust Wilson based on what information I've obtained, but that might change if Alv turns out to be innocent.
-
I will also be placing my vote on Second of Sky (Alvron). So, now we just need to figure out who the other OC are... hmmmm.
-
As I mentioned before. I missed the first few days due to being out of town (had my phone only, so I couldn't analyze much). I have had people who are now dead voice suspicion to me of Araris and he is the only one who hit on most of their lists. I don't have the ability to go back and analyze more of his posts from the past (Work is crazy busy right now), but that's why I'm voting for him. I'm not throwing out more because I don't have more, I Just want people to know I think he is a bad guy.
-
I suppose I should put my obligatory vote on Araris again.
-
They can't attack the same person unless they have ruin as well. Odium can only kill shards and his invested target can only kill Non shards.
-
Lariak is glad something makes sense to someone...
-
I will not be on much today. I feel like today should be a Brandon Sanderson holiday. The Nebraska Cornhuskers are playing the BYU Cougars. Brandon is from Lincoln and teaches at BYU. I live in Lincoln and have a tailgating spot and have already had too much to drink.......... I would like to wish good luck to the Cougars and apologize for the loss. Good day my friends.
-
Seonid, I don't think they can Invest AND using the new ability in the same night, can they? Or can Odium invest during the day?
-
It's all gone a bit quiet in this game. I still think Araris is a bad guy. Just saying.
-
Mail, Shouldn't you be in class or something?
-
Lopen, I've pointed out that I think Araris bad as well. I'm going to place my vote on him as well. I will see if I can go back and find the posts that made me most suspicious.
-
Nico, I think you misread the PM/AM Conversions. Understandable though if you're just going to sleep, because that means you are quite a few time zones off. I believe it ends in about 12 hours.
-
While I agree with you in most situations, resurrecting a thread that the whole basis was before WoR, with information learned after WoR was release (and thread had died before WoR) is counter-productive and seems like someone is trying to find an easy "You're wrong". I really don't think that's what Eternal Radiance was doing, but it can come off that way though.
-
Yeah, Brightlord/Brightlady are like the normal villagers. I'm curious as to how many Shardplates0 are out there.
-
Two bad games in a row. At least we got another one! 8+0 This is for a little code I made. I like making codes. 15+42.
-
I'm on Wilson's list, so I support the lynch train as a not-so-silent partner.
-
Fine guys. I would like you all to know. I am a Worldhopper. It may come as a shock to some of you, but there you have it. You're welcome.
-
So. I've been trying to get caught up and I thought I would post my suspicions at the moment. Hero - Araris - Hael. I don't have any perfect examples to type out yet, and because of that - I'm going to refrain from actually voting. I've just been reading and think they are likely to be bad (Probably only 2 out of the three though, just not sure which two). I will try to post a bit more detail analysis when I can.
-
This theory was before WoR ever came out (when we learned he has an Honorblade).
-
I just read the rules here Joe, this game is EPIC. I'll be signing up as Lariak. I'm still wording on the story for him.
-
Right you are Raven. I went back and for some reason I thought that stink had made the post Orlok did.
-
Raven, I could be wrong here, but wasn't STINK FOR the first day lynch? I have missed a bit of the chatter so far, but I seem to recall STINK wanting a first day lynch. *EDIT* Added my vote in.
