Jump to content

Macen

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    475

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Macen

  1. Macen
    The only other thing would be to create trust for the other person. Build up an animosity throughout the game, then being that to a breaking point, so that when one of them dies and is evil, no one thinks the other is also a GB.It's something I would do... *EDIT* it pretty much creates a huge trust for the one who lives.
  2. Macen
    I don't have time to read, but the other option is DC and Wilson are both GB. They both can take a hit, so they waste a lynch cycle for the villagers. Don't think it's likely, but possible l.
  3. Macen
    Sure makes you look like a GB. Wasted a whole lynch cycle for us to gain very little info.
  4. Macen
    I don't have much time to post, Babysitting for some friends who went to a concert. I want to say it has nothing to do with your activity levels Kas. I have played with you numerous times, and I played with you your first game (the first play through of this) and I just feel like your posts have too much smoke and mirrors in them. I would never vote someone based on activity level (especially if they post a RL reason, because I have the same stuff come up all of the time. I will try to analyze more posts when I can, but time hasn't been forthcoming lately. *EDIT* I don't have time to read the rests of the post right now, but I should before the cycle ends.
  5. Macen
    I think it comes down to this: Some of the early games we had here, people focused too much on winning and would do the "Dictator" play style and WOULD win. The problem with that is, one person has fun as the dictator, while the other 10 villagers are bored as rust and don't have fun. It's not fun to have 0 knowledge and just wait around to have someone tell you to do something - and it started to kill the community because people stopped playing (I did myself for a bit). That's why a lot of the people who have been playing for a while try to avoid any sort of Ruling groups (i forgot what we used to call it?) where one group of people has all of the power and decides everything.
  6. Macen
    I tried to decypher it as well... spent about 10 minutes then gave up haha. I'm usually pretty good at code breaking, and have won a few code breaking things on here before (the last instance of this game is a good example). But, I don't see enough of a pattern in the text to make it easy, and I can't see one of the GB giving free information away to us villagers - even if it was encoded. *EDIT* Let me correct myself. I'm almost positive it is a code, and i'm sure it has something that will help us villagers a little bit, but it doesn't seem worth the effort.
  7. Macen
    Well. I'm glad that clears everything up.
  8. Macen
    I stand by my suspicion of Kas. I can't pinpoint exactly what it is other than his playstyle seems off to me and I honestly think he is a baddie. I also lean towards Wilson being bad, but I'm not certain. I don't really have strong reads on anyone else. I'm weary of anyone who has a spanreed, because my estimates put there being 4 spanreeds in the game. 1 started with the GB, 3 with the villagers. 1 Villager spanreed went over to the GB, so that gives any spanreed holder that was revealed after night 1 a 50% chance of being a GB. I know this sucks because this makes the spanreed holders less likely to use the spanreed and bolster communication, but those are the numbers. I could be off, but I think that it's a very reasonable distribution.
  9. Macen
    I didn't trust you, but I definitely thought we had one more cycle to go before we completely lost.
  10. Macen
    I think the list needs to be taken with a grain of salt. We have to weight it into our analysis, but we obviously can't take it at face value. We know Hellscyth was good, and we know he thought XYZ. Well, I know I'M good, and I know what I think, but lord knows I'm wrong all of the time. It wasn't like he had a bunch of additional information that we didn't, he is basing this on about as much information as we have. The only difference between him saying it and me saying the exact same thing is, we all know he was a good guy. I'm the only one who knows I'm a good guy.
  11. Macen
    Fair enough, I can understand that. I don't really have any defense for myself. I was super inactive the first 3 cycles (almost froze to death) and gave Luckat and Joe a full accounting of what I've done.
  12. Macen
    Just clarifying. And I agree, wilson didn't give anything away by declaring she has a single-use spanreed.
  13. Macen
    First of all, a second vote is not a bandwagon - I was just as suspicious of him before you voted for him. You just voted before I did.
  14. Macen
    He changed the name to have something to do with the writeup he just posted.
  15. Macen
    I will also Vote TinyStrawMan. Burnt seemed to be pretty keyed in on him, and then burnt died. My other major suspect is Lopen. I've given my accounting of pewter to Joe - which I had also given to Luckat.
  16. Macen
    Wilson, will you send me a PM? This worked last time, so...
  17. Macen
    I see what you did there... At least I hope you ... erm...
  18. Macen
    I know you know. I may be stating it incorrectly, but I've always interpreted it as telling people you have something to see how they react. You could be bluffing, or you could not. It's like in poker telling everyone you have pocket Aces before the flop. *EDIT* On a side note, I'm a huge fan of IKYK, because it forces actions. I just don't like doing it without some sort of way to keep myself alive, lol.
  19. Macen
    Sorry ahead of time for the wall of text... I'm going to have to disagree with you here - as i noted in Red. I can't really argue with your numbers here, but I can argue your outcome. There are a LOT of items floating around right now. If i remember from last time, nearly everyone has at least one item, so the eliminators are going to get at least one item from everyone they kill. This situation gives them a target if they so choose, but also detracts from a target because he has an heir. I don't really see the negative of the general thought. Unless he has a soulcaster/bow and they get lucky and get that item...
  20. Macen
    Stink, I wanna know! I always feel left out...
  21. Macen
    Unless you declare an heir, then swap your heir that night, so the GB think they know where your items are going...
  22. Macen
    I'm here and I've caught up on the reading. I didn't really garner much information as of yet, need to re-read and analyse the posts a bit better, but as of right now my only suspect is Kas. It's more based on gut feeling then any evidence at the moment. I'm going to analyze posts and see if I can figure out why I have that feeling.
  23. Macen
    I would say to share the list with one or two people you trust most and work with them to figure out who you think likely suspects are, then go from there. Giving the list out to the public isn't going to do much except give the eliminators more information.
  24. Macen
    Posted in the wrong thread.... ooops!
  25. Macen
    Do not fear, Ace is here! All kidding aside. Getting caught up on reading - had an unplanned family trip this weekend to see my fiances sister and kids before they move to Kentucky. They live in a very rural area and reception was shotty at best. Going to get caught up on the day 1 reading and hopefully have some posting (Doing it for both of the games I'm in).
×
×
  • Create New...