-
Posts
602 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by ScavellTane
-
[OB] A question regarding timeline for the recreance
ScavellTane replied to lilyjab's topic in Stormlight Archive
I would say Feverstone was first, the Stonewards and Windrunners disbanding. And the Shattering of Stormseat was last. All the Oathgates in the other nine major cities were locked on the outside except Stormseat. Which means we can safely assume that Stormseat was the place the residents of Urithiru evacuated to. If so then it's likely the remainder of the Radiants and the civilians settled in the warcamps. Or were the 'warcamps' where they housed the Parsh after their Connection were severed? -
Theory: The severing of the Nahel bond by the Ancient Radiants and their spren is not the cause of the Radiant-sprens 'death'. It is being 'locked' in a static state (blade-form) that is considered death by the spren. Spren always move, they are never completely static. Being locked in a static state is what the spren consider 'death'. Without the Nahel Bond all spren should just be mindless/regular spren. The Ancient Radiants 'locked' their spren, that was their betrayal.
- 292 replies
-
- oathbringer
- adolin
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
-
[OB] Theory- Gemhearts location and reclamation
ScavellTane replied to MonsterMetroid's topic in Stormlight Archive
Then perhaps the Chasmfiends aren't eating people/flesh, but the gemstones. -
It looks like Dalinar's request gave her an opening to intervene.
- 2 replies
-
- cultivation
- old magic
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
[OB] About that moon story...
ScavellTane replied to The Invested Beard's topic in Stormlight Archive
Maybe a Cognitive Shadow? -
Theory: 10 were 'Made' but only 9 were 'Unmade'.. Why? To shackle Odium to Roshar.
-
Here the name Daigonarthis is written in one word, but in Mythica it's written as Dai-Gonarthis. It leads me to assume that the other un-hyphenated Unmade names are just translation errors. Nergaoul <> Ner-Gaoul Moelach <> Mo-Elach Chemoarish <> Che-Moarish Ashertmarn <> Ashert-Marn This further leads me to taking a closer look at the Order names. Wind-Runner, Sky-Breaker, Dust-Bringer, Edge-Dancer, Truth-Watcher Light-Weaver, Else-Caller, Will-Shaper, Stone-Ward(er?), Bond-Smith And so.. Ashert-Marn <> Reveling Heart Che-Moarish <> Dust-Mother [Moarish <> Moash(?)] Dai-Gonarthis <> Black-Fisher Mo-Elach <> Death-Rattler(?) Sja-Anat <> Secret-Taker Yelig-Nar <> Blight-Wind Ba-Ado-Mishram <> [Void(?)]-Light-?? Ner-Gaoul <> ??? Re-Shephir <> ??? I'm not sure how the title of Midnight Mother fits in, as I see a kind of correlation between Re-Shephir <> Will-Shaper. Non of the Unmade titles may be one-to-one. But considering how names/titles are shaped, it seems like the names of the Unmade could very well be their descriptions and their original purpose.
- 19 replies
-
11
-
Sounds familiar. Lightweaver surges <> Illumination + Transformation
- 1 reply
-
1
-
I believe all conquests throughout the modern history of Roshar was because the Stormfather was performing his duty of finding a Bondsmith. He gave all these conquerors the visions and it drove them to 'Unite' Roshar by the means they believe best. Even Gavilar received the visions. The problem was that non of these conquerors found the words to the Ideals.
-
(OB) Who will have a bigger role in SA 4?
ScavellTane replied to Toaster Retribution's topic in Stormlight Archive
I would like more of the women of bridge four. I would mostly like to see the change with the gender roles, men writing and women fighting. -
I never realised how cool Sylspear looks.
-
I was under the impression that mink refer to felines (cats).
-
Khriss believes there are ten levels of voidbinding, so there are probably ten types of voidbinding?
-
[OB] [BoM] [Emp's Soul] Spoilers - The Tranquiline Halls
ScavellTane replied to teknopathetic's topic in Stormlight Archive
I'm not really sure they bonded Amarams soldiers, I think they just crossed over and now reside in the Everstorm.- 10 replies
-
- shai
- reincarnation
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
I would guess that it's easier for Odium to influence humans than the Ancient Singers due to their dependency on spren and their natural ability to view better the CR. It would have required him to generate spren of his own on Roshar.
-
[OB] [BoM] [Emp's Soul] Spoilers - The Tranquiline Halls
ScavellTane replied to teknopathetic's topic in Stormlight Archive
The Ancient Singer's 'immortality' comes from Odium. I would say that the Listeners viewing them as gods is because they can technically be considered spren.- 10 replies
-
1
-
- shai
- reincarnation
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
sigizil [OB] Why did Hoid choose him?
ScavellTane replied to USS bridge four's topic in Stormlight Archive
If Hoid didn't pick him, he wouldn't have ended up in Brdge 4. Let's face it, he's going to teach Brigde 4 how to read and write in Book 4. -
It's strange that the Larkin are 'supposedly' only found on Aimia when the island is the furthest away from the Highstorms. How would they sustain themselves?
-
My though was that Yelig-nar bonding a gemheart would grant all the powers, but when housed in a specific gemstone would only manifest the surges tied to the gem type. Now going through the text I see.. Tension Cohesion and Division Abrasion Gravitation Looks like everything is on the Right side of the surgebinding chart. Couldn't find a reference to Adhesion though.
-
Yeah, I listened to the audiobook. Must have somehow glossed over it.For some reason I only distinctly remember him melting the ground,floating and the flaming blade.
-
Could Amaram manifesting Skybreaker surges because Yelig-nar was housed in a smokestone? If Yelig-nar was placed within any other gemstone, would Amaram have manifested the surges that corresponded to their gem-type/order? Side note: Did Gavilar experimented his dark gemstone with her? Or did the 'thing' the Fused is digging for under Kholinar reached out to her? Or am I just over thinking it?
-
My concern is that I might not live long enough to see the end of SA since its gonna take like another 20+ years.
-
The Radiant spren might form the bow, but the lesser spren that forms the shardplate could form the arrows. Arrow velocity won't be much of an issue for a Windrunner.
