Jump to content

Treamayne

Members
  • Posts

    5390
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    9

Everything posted by Treamayne

  1. I posit the existence of the as-yet-unnamed Cognitve Realm Bond in this bond post. We see a cognitive/emotion bond in Mistborn (Vin and Koloss), Warbreaker (Nightblood), YNP (Nightmares), etc. There are many posts in that thread on the subject, the linked one is just the most organized and cited. Hope that helps
  2. Short answer is RAFO. Brandon refuses to answer that question until either Warbreaker 2 or Stormlight back-half. Here are the known WoBs on the topic: We do have one possible "hint" hidden in a different pair of WoBs: Hope that helps
  3. Any chance? I would state it as a non-Zero chance. But not likely. WoBs have changed very slightly over the years: Hope that helps
  4. Welcome to the Shard. Thank you for the Intro Post to let us know what you have read. We'll avoid spoilers when possible, and mark them when needed. Also, please consider checking out the Sharder FAQ for some useful forum info and tips. I think it depends on Identity. The True Spren (Radiant Spren) may have been Splinters (combined Honor and Cultivation), but they Identified as being "of Honor and Cultivation." They still felt they were parts of Honor. In stories you have not yet read (Elantris, Warbreaker and Yumi), you will encounter other kinds of Splinters. But, I think that if the Spren had not self-identified as being "of Honor" (at least partly) then Retribution would not have been able to grab them back. I also think the honorblades are the foreshadowing of that point - they have some sentience, but almost no sapience and are fully-separated Splinters - which is why Retribution did not, and possibly could not have, reclaimed them (Connection would also be a factor). WoBs: Hope that helps
  5. I feel like, if there were a character archetype for this idea, it would be a Trust Fund Baby - making sure they never have to actually work a day in their lives/stretch the trust fund through compound interest and you can live your hobbies as long as you have Cadmium.
  6. There's also this thread discussing the known and potential rules - as a print and play.
  7. Mostly (Very slight non-plot spoilers) Generally speaking, Brandon does a good job separating book-arc from series arcs, and each book (SA and Mistborn) does get closure for its book plots.
  8. Welcome to the Shard. Please consider an Intro Post to let us know what you have or have-not read (whichever list is shorter). Also, please consider checking out the Sharder FAQ for some useful forum info and tips. I'm a big fan of giving people enough information to make an informed decision; so I wholeheartedly support your endeavor. Copied from my Reading Order Post - here are the considerations for Stormlight Archive: The most critical one is a mutual spoiler - RoW and TLM. Just be clear, you are fine with breaking up Mistborn Era 2 - it's only Stormlight Archive you do not want to break apart? If so, then based on the above I would recommend: That should minimize spoilers while maximizing the chance of recognizing Minor references and Easter Eggs. Hope that helps
  9. Hope you are enjoying it, so far Not sure if you really want these answers - they will be discussed (mostly in book 5), but in case you want some info now: Hope that helps
  10. Please note - the excerpted example was likely possible due to Connection. OB Ch 89 (and TES Day 30): Hope that helps
  11. Just with non-metal zippers. . .
  12. Known and speculated data can be found in (page 1 search results): Dawnshard Theory and how to Categorize Shards Theory on the 4th Dawnshard Compiling Dawnshard Speculation Shard/Dawnshard Chart Dawnshard Rubric Fourth Dawnshard Name Dawnshard Categories Another Dawnshard Chart Dawnshard Intents Shards/Dawnshard Division Dawnshard Commands Dawnshard Theory Hope that helps
  13. Unlikely, since Honor tied the Surges to Oaths and TrueSpren bonds specifically to limit thier application and prevent another Ashyn. But Roshar's ecology is tied to the Spren and there are likely to be many "hacks" that Singers could teach humans about how to use Rhythms and Light with environmental Spren to encourge certain effects.
  14. Glad we were able to help. Thank you for sharing. Hope you stick around too. . .
  15. Please do not Necro post, it i against forum policy: If you need to continue an old discussion, simply start a new post and reference (quote, link, or both) the original. The Sharder FAQ has tips and info on how to do this, if you need help. Thank you very much and have a great day.
  16. Vin, presumably, either coughed up the lead, like she did the first time she swallowed those beads for the attack on Keep Hasting, or burned them away with Aluminum. Metal poisoning is a very slow process. That said, it should no longer be a factor. This was eventually altered a bit. Unreliable narrator is always in play and people in-story can (and often are) wrong. WoB: What we do not know is if this was a change that was part of Sazed restoring Nobles and Skaa to the normal Scadrian human template and undoing Rashek's chenges. So, it is possible that Metal poisoning was a factor in the Final Empire, but not after the Catacendre. Here's the chain of WoBs that led to the tweak (I do not say RetCon because we have no evidence this changes anything in Era 1). Hope that helps
  17. Odium did kill Aona and Skai first - but was also wounded during the clash with Ambition. We do not know the full story of that yet, but Mercy was involved somehow (first or second clash is also unknown yet). WoBs: Hope that helps
  18. Nope, that's not quite what is happening, and we are not expected to think it is. WoB: It's another "level" of the translation and is similar to real life languages. Translating a Korean page - I might say "speak of the devil" (which is an English language proverb) - but the Korean might actually say 호랑이도 제 말하면 온다 (Literal translation - If you even say "tiger," he will appear) which is the same meaning and the proverbs are used in the same way, but a literal translation would just confuse some people. Hope that helps.
  19. Welcome to the Shard. Please consider an Intro Post to let us know what you have or have-not read (whichever list is shorter). Also, please consider checking out the Sharder FAQ for some useful forum info and tips. Keep in mind that not every bead in every Rosharan Shadesmar Ocean has to be a discrete object currently in the physical realm. Mistborn: Secret History Spoilers: So, that sack covered in 150yrs of Crem - that's a bead. The spare Spanreed nibs the ardent dropped crossing the Chasms - those are each a Bead. Etc. More importantly, the number and depth of the bead ocean is not defined by the number of physical objects around - it is defined by the Cognitive identity of Roshar and that continental location. That's why Physical realm rivers and oceans in Shadesmar congeal into an obsidian-like substrate - the less "thought" in and about a location in the Physical Realm contracts the space in Shadesmar (which is what makes worldhopping possible) - and the inverse is true. A densly populated area like Kholinar will be deeper and with more beads than a sparesly populated are like the farmland outside Hearthstone. It's not a discreet 1:1 relationship; it's a complex interpretation of Identity on multiple levels (example in OB was a bead for all of the Kholinar castle, plus a bead for each room with a strong enough self-identity, plus a bead for each object in each of those rooms). WoBs: Hope that helps.
  20. I'm a proponent of "there is not one best reading order - and people should be given enough information to make an informed personal choice." To that end, Please see Cosmere Reading Order Discussion I will caveat that with Warbreaker is free online for a no-money way to see if you like Sanderson's writing style. Also, There are many non-Cosmere works you can try that require less investment; such as Legion, Reckoners, and Cytoverse (or even some of the Solo Stories like Perfect State or Rithmatist). Technically, it's Mistborn: The Final Empire. . . Hope that helps
  21. Not this one, since the Kanda on Roshar has been on-screen since at least WoR, possibly WoK. 2015 WoB: Hope that helps
  22. I don't think the question was a theory, and neither the questioner nor Brandon seem to imply Marasi would do such a thing. It seems more about confirming that the power of the Well could be used to fuel a huge expression of a Misting's power - and that was confirmed as "Possible." Just my 20Yen. . .
  23. The only non-RAFO WoB I found is: Everything else is "Wait for Era 3, when we start discussing this." Hope that helps
  24. Welcome to the Shard. Thank you for the Intro Post; if you also read Sanderson, please consider updating that post to let us know what you have or have-not read (whichever list is shorter) so we can avoid spoilers in other Forum areas (as necessary). Also, please consider checking out the Sharder FAQ for some useful forum info and tips. Forum Policies can be found there, but double-posting is not allowed - if you were the last person to post, then please edit your post to make any necessary changes/updates. It is considered rude because it adds unneccesary scrolling and other problems (such as triggering Spam protocols), especially for many on mobile devices (similar reasons restrict how long a signature may be - please use your profile's about me page for long descriptions and link to that from your signature). The Sharder FAQ (linked above) has tips on editing posts (and many other topics) - but it's accessed from the "three dot" (a. k. a. hamburger) menu at the top-right of the post - just click there and select "Edit." Feel free to let us know if you have questions or need additional information/insight. Note: All links are to places on this site. References: I don't mind answering questions - but I am not a moderator. Your best bet is to report the second post so that an Admin can respond (and they can quote and reference things I can only link). Hope that helps.
  25. Sounds consistent with current known data - pending the reveals expected in Era 3.
×
×
  • Create New...