Jump to content

Chaos

Head Admin
  • Posts

    8411
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    90

Everything posted by Chaos

  1. This thread isn't getting enough love recently. Time to fix that. I would like to announce that 17th Shard has over 100,000 posts as of today! Also Shardlet, I don't know what I'd do next at all haha.
  2. Thank you for all the kind words! It made my week. You won't have to wait much longer!
  3. Well, the idea with the rankings is that they are titles, not people. (Though I suppose you could say Hoid is technically a title, but still, none of us are Hoid) You won't see Vin, but you could see Heir of the Survivor or something. What do you think?
  4. *throws virtual bits at you* There, happy? You will get your wish on this. Kind of. I won't be doing it, but... there will be a thing. Also, I'm immensely relieved that I'm not the only one who didn't love Way of Kings initially. I was irrationally worried that I'd be crucified for saying that. I think it was a much better book upon a reread. Thank you all for the very kind words about the review. It made my week that you liked it. Now come back in a week and tell me if I was justified in loving it so much I think I am, at least!
  5. I'm shocked it took you so long to realize that 1337 was a joke rank like that XD
  6. These are cool! I will add these emoticons into the system sometime next week, probably after the Words of Radiance release. I really like them. I'll also add the dice roll one, but not the moustaches I don't think
  7. Exactly.
  8. Also note the "intentional" part could be to troll you
  9. Every sentence in the review was intentional.
  10. I disagree with Carl's assessment that "much of the tension is from characters not talking to each other." No, there's far more worrying sources of tension... Also, I felt that characters had extremely good reasons for not immediately telling others things. It felt very natural. So, I don't think you guys need to worry.
  11. I'm not trying to deliberately hype you guys but it's really good: http://www.17thshard.com/news/brandon-news/our-spoiler-free-words-of-radiance-review-r151
  12. (This special prerelease, spoiler-free review is specifically approved by Team Sanderson.) It's safe to say that Words of Radiance has the most pre-release hype of any of Brandon's solo works to-date. And it makes sense. The Way of Kings was Brandon's best work at the time, and so everyone is wondering, will Words of Radiance live up to the high bar set by book one? This is a sequel that has a ton riding on it. After all, despite the first book's length, there's still so much more of Roshar to explore. There's so many places that The Stormlight Archive can go from here, that it has been hard to predict what would happen in this book, much less a few books down the line. Words of Radiance could fall on its face. So, does it live up to the hype? Storms yes it does. "Of course you'd like the book," you immediately say. "You're a 17th Sharder, you'll love anything Brandon writes." I'd say this is somewhat true. None of us would be here if we didn't like what Brandon's done, but when you are a hyper fan, you set these books up to a high standard. You can see flaws that no one else sees, simply because you are so invested. For a while, I worried that Words of Radiance would end up like The Well of Ascension, which I have some problems with to say the least. I loved Well's ending (which made it entirely worthwhile), but rereading it is a slog for me. Well of Ascension was Brandon's first true sequel, and it shows a bit. Obviously, Brandon has grown a vast deal from almost a decade ago when that book came out, but it was still a worry. Sequels are not easy, to say the least, but it looks like finishing up The Wheel of Time really honed Brandon’s sequel chops. I also worried because--and this may sound like absolute heresy to many of you--I didn't immediately love The Way of Kings when it came out. I've come to love it after rereading it, but the first time I read it, well, while the Battle of the Tower was awesome, I had expected Part Five to be more. In all the Mistborn books the final part of the book contained even more awesomeness, but Way of Kings's final part was admittedly more of an extended prologue to the rest of the series. It took me a while to adjust to The Way of Kings and learn to love on its own merits instead of comparing it to Mistborn, which is a very different type of novel. I say this to convince you that no, we don't believe Brandon Windruns on water. So when I say Words of Radiance is absolutely phenomenal, an amazing achievement, and my favorite Brandon book to date, I'm not being a hyperbolic fan. It really is that good. It takes everything that was great about The Way of Kings and takes it up at least five notches--maybe ten or fifteen notches, even, depending on how you measure your notches. No matter which way you slice this massive tome with a Shardblade (in which case, can I have your Blade? Actually, that might be a bad idea), Words of Radiance is incredible. And when I say that everything is taken up a level, I'm again not being hyperbolic. Did you enjoy the interludes in book one? They are better and more plot important now. The epigraphs here are similarly more awesome and terrifying. The interior art? When you hold the book in your hands and see the gorgeous Shallan endpapers, you'll fall in love. Dan Dos Santos (artist extraordinaire, who did the beautiful US Warbreaker cover) does some art work and it is oh so excellent. You might think that Words of Radiance, being longer than The Way of Kings, would be a chore to get through, but you couldn't be more wrong. The plotting is so much better here. You'll be amazed by how much actually happens in this book. Every part of the book is focused and tight, and it has incredible, thrilling moments all along the way. Do you want to see more magic? Oh, we see more. Words of Radiance expands on the world and characters in such a natural way that you'll be thinking, "of course this is how it should have been. There was no other way." Brandon weaves together character development, tight plotting, and the world and magic of Roshar in a way that I can only describe as masterful. Brandon reveals so much in Words of Radiance. Things I expected to have to wait at least two or three more books to find out are explained in full by the end of the book, which leaves me to wonder "If he’s giving us this information now, what is he holding back?" Not only is the story great, it also has some of the most beautiful writing I've read--I teared up more than once, and that's rare for me--and it also has some of the most haunting writing I've ever read. And it manages to be hilarious, too (let me say that two characters meet in a rather unexpected way and leave it at that). It pulls at your emotions the entire way. It's relentless like that. You can tell how much he has grown as a writer in the years since he wrote The Way of Kings. And then, that ending. That ending. Guys, I'm not trying to deliberately hype it up for you, but you haven't seen anything yet. I had thought of giving you a summary with the spoilers heavily redacted, as in: "Then REDACTED REDACTED with REDACTED, because why not?" But I decided even that was too spoilery. All you really need to know is that there were four separate moments where I screamed "REDACT YEAH!" (insert your favorite storming swear here) in my empty apartment. Note, this was at Very Late O'Clock. So, to my poor neighbors, I would say that I'm sorry, but when you read it, you will understand the awesomeness. It was totally justified for me to scream and wake you up in the middle of the night. Pinky swear. And when the storm passes, after you think days, weeks, and months after you finish as you try to sleep "Wow, that was incredible" (I did this five times that I'm aware of), does Words of Radiance still hold up to a less hyped up mind? It really does, and there's so much depth in the book to dissect. There's also a deeper reason for why it has stuck with me. I love The Stormlight Archive for a lot of reasons, like its deep world and extensive magic. I'm a sucker for that, as many of you on 17th Shard are. But there's something more. As a genre, fantasy, with George R. R. Martin and others, has been trending towards darker, more "realistic" worlds. Stormlight Archive is not that. One criticism I hear about Brandon's works is that his characters aren't gritty or real enough. Well, you know what? I like heroes being heroes. Brandon writes about heroes. When you think about it, that's what the Knights Radiant and the Stormlight Archive are all about. What does it mean to truly be a hero? Having people try and struggle to do the right thing is fascinating, and allows for opportunities where you literally scream with joy (as I did) and just stand up and cheer. I'm so glad Brandon bucks that dark fantasy trend and gives me something to love. Wrap Up Words of Radiance is truly an achievement. It expands on its predecessor, fulfilling the promises it sets up, and manages to surpass it. There is no question about it: this is my favorite Brandon Sanderson novel. When I read The Way of Kings, I had thought that while it was (at the time) Brandon's best written novel, it wasn't my favorite, but that The Stormlight Archive series absolutely had the potential to be Brandon's best series. Well, that was entirely right. There's no doubt about it. Out of five stars, this book is ten heartbeats, with a 2:1 stars to heartbeats ratio. If you adored The Way of Kings, you will be blown away by Words of Radiance. Even if book one didn't thrill you, however, I can't see how you won't be enthralled by this volume. It really is that good. You'll be sold on the entire series with this. Fire and hammer forge a sword; time and neglect rust it away. And the same is true for The Stormlight Archive. Yes, we have seen the time and maybe even felt some neglect, but what Brandon was out of sight doing tempered his skill as a writer, and this book is the reward. The Knights Radiant will stand again, and this book is proof that they will stand for a long time. Thanks to Josh for his contribution to this review. Words of Radiance comes out in the US on March 4th, 2014, and in other territories on March 6th, 2014. Talk about the book in our Words of Radiance board.
  13. Hey all, with Words of Radiance fast approaching, I just wanted to take a moment to remind everyone about the spoiler policy. All Words of Radiance spoilers belong in the Words of Radiance spoiler board. There, you will be able to freely talk about the publicly released sample chapters, and when the book comes out, obviously the book itself. if you must post a Words of Radiance spoiler elsewhere (such as in the Stormlight board or General Brandon Discussion), they must, without exception be marked as such. That said, feel free to request a moderator to move the topic to the Words of Radiance board. To mark spoilers, use this: Words of Radiance spoilers: [spoiler] (put spoilers here) [/spoiler]If you somehow manage to acquire a copy of Words of Radiance before Tuesday, do not post any information on the book until Tuesday, even in Cosmere Theories or the Words of Radiance board.Posts violating these policies will be removed/edited immediately. One last thing! When the book comes out, please refrain from putting out big book spoilers in the topic titles. The overall spoiler period for Words of Radiance will be around six months. After that point, the Words of Radiance board will be merged with the Stormlight Archive forum, as it can be reasonably expected that people who want to discuss Stormlight Archive in great detail would have read it by then. This seems like a much better solution than having different boards for each Stormlight book, which in my opinion would be overkill.
  14. Hey all, with Words of Radiance fast approaching, I just wanted to take a moment to remind everyone about the spoiler policy. All Words of Radiance spoilers belong in the Words of Radiance spoiler board. There, you will be able to freely talk about the publicly released sample chapters, and when the book comes out, obviously the book itself. if you must post a Words of Radiance spoiler elsewhere (such as in the Stormlight board or General Brandon Discussion), they must, without exception be marked as such. That said, feel free to request a moderator to move the topic to the Words of Radiance board. To mark spoilers, use this: Words of Radiance spoilers: [spoiler] (put spoilers here) [/spoiler]If you somehow manage to acquire a copy of Words of Radiance before Tuesday, do not post any information on the book until Tuesday, even in Cosmere Theories or the Words of Radiance board.Posts violating these policies will be removed/edited immediately. One last thing! When the book comes out, please refrain from putting out big book spoilers in the topic titles. The overall spoiler period for Words of Radiance will be around six months. After that point, the Words of Radiance board will be merged with the Stormlight Archive forum, as it can be reasonably expected that people who want to discuss Stormlight Archive in great detail would have read it by then. This seems like a much better solution than having different boards for each Stormlight book, which in my opinion would be overkill.
  15. Darn, and I was going to troubleshoot it to attempt to figure out what was causing it. That said I am pretty sure I didn't do anything to fix it. Certainly not in any active way. I blame Hoid. And Shiro.
  16. Yeah, I don't like how the built in thing does it either. I do want to try and see a way if that can be changed to the old plugin we had, which is not available for this version of IPB because the original developer said "It's built into IPB now!" Yes but it's bad in IPB...
  17. You're a lucky duck. I will be posting a topic clarifying the spoiler policy, but I'll tell you the punchline: wait a week before talking about it at all on the boards.
  18. I hadn't heard of it before now, but entirely possible they announced it and I completely missed it. Please let me know if you find the original link announcing it!
  19. Actually, the J.J. Abrams joke was one Brandon told at SpoCon. He jokingly said something along the lines of "If someone's uncle was J.J. Abrams and was a big fan of Mistborn, that certainly would help". That said, I'd much rather have Joss Whedon work on it. Or Joss Whedon work on everything, really.
  20. Well, we will actually be livestreaming the event at BYU, if the internet there holds up. So hopefully that will sate you, at least a little
  21. Crafty Games has revealed what the first supplement to the Mistborn Adventure Game will be: Terris: Wrought of Copper. We at 17th Shard had thought its next supplement would be an Alloy of Law-era one, but this is not the case. That doesn't mean we aren't excited--to the contrary! Crafty Games has worked with Brandon to develop material that provides a detailed look at the Terris Dominance and its people, which is definitely not something we saw much of in the original trilogy. Other than that, details on the supplement are scarce, but Crafty Games will be having three Google+ Hangouts where they will reveal more, and the first one is actually tomorrow: will be an overview discussing "what players, Narrators and fans can expect to find in this book." will discuss the Rules as well as "all-new insights into the awesome power of Feruchemy." will discuss "adventuring in the Terris Dominance."We'll keep you posted on what is revealed at these Hangouts, so stay tuned, but definitely go watch them if you have time! In unrelated Mistborn news, the film rights to Mistborn have lapsed last week. Paloppa Pictures had owned the rights, and Brandon says they were wonderful to work with. In fact, news on the Mistborn film over the years had been immensely positive, with Brandon saying he liked Paloppa's progress and their screenplay a lot. However, they were unable to get the film into motion. As such, Paloppa's rights have lapsed, so theoretically, they could be sold to someone else. It's sad we can't see Paloppa's good vision for Mistborn on the big screen, but with the rights available again, we could see a production actually start eventually. On Brandon's blog, he says any offer for the Mistborn film rights would need to be "very serious" in order for them to consider it. But, you know, if your uncle is J.J. Abrams or something and you love Mistborn, get your people to contact Joel Gotler at Intellectual Property Group. Wow. That sounded way too official for 17th Shard... Thanks WeiryWriter for your contributions to this article! Cover illustration for Terris: Wrought of Copper by Tommy Arnold.
  22. I don't think that will be technically feasible. That said, in the new system, you'll have much more discovery and progression
  23. You seem to imply that there's only one shocking moment in the book.
  24. I will totally write anyone permission slips.
  25. I do highly recommend not going to the Words of Radiance board after release until you read it Also, allllll the nonexistent ad revenue from these hits!
×
×
  • Create New...