Bzhydack

But Chorus is not native to Canticle. Came to this planet with the colonists so it cant be Invention creation. While still can be Invention influenced. But I like your take on this topic that this can easily be Invention planet.

And when Jasnah come to her, real Shallan was the one in Plate, not the normal one Like this supose to be deafult. I always assumed she was really in Plate but she didnt recognize/doesnt want to aknowledge she has one.

@robardin Im sad, because it is probably not His Majesty Prime Aquasix Yanagawn the First, because he will probably know about Kal and Szeth mission, because they literaly write their visit in Azir Oathgate Logs, and he will probably be present on the meeting. This actually very good guess. "His" part of Shadesmar is also mor or less Tukar or Azimir, so directions will match.

Actually I felt the oposite. When I saw promise between Kaladin and Shallan and Adolin, my first thought was: "They are not gona make it. Brandon, dont you dare to kill one of them!". I was sure Adolin will live, but now Im not longer sure and I hope he didnt die, because suddenly apears like it can happen.

This would be preaty wild, and also funny, because Adolin refuses to be Dalinar succesor, and this way it will come back tho the same family in circle

So while we all suspected the Creationspren will be Lighweaver Armor, it is good to have confirmation. But what is new, we didnt know about Creationspren tendency to imitate beads in Shadesmar, however we shoud consider tis, because they like to make themselves into real things, and beads are their representation in Shadesmar. This is logical, but also super powerfull in Shadesmar - altho I'm not sure if Creationspren-bead can be Mannifested into real thing, it still gives Knight enormous control over bead ocean.

This basicly ruled out ALL our suspects, because all of them knew about Kal's quest.

I had very similar idea some time ago, it was idea of masproduction of Hemalurgic Spikes. It is somewhere here on Forum, but I have too many posts to search throu Also, Idea was before we know Hemalurgy doesnt grant Compounding anymore. First, we need Gold Compounder. Point is, Gold Compounder can heal himself in two ways. He can heal himself with his Feruchemy, taping Metalminds, but he also can heal himself with his Allomacy, burning Metalminds with his Identity. So we can "kill" him with cadmium Spike, stealing his Allomancy, wait utill he heals himself with Feruchemy, then we can "kill" him second time, with golden Spike, steal his Feruchemy and let him heal with Allomancy. Then we can repeat process and get as many Spikes with both F-Gold and A-Gold as we want, basicly. Next step was to spike every other Misting/Ferring with both Spikes, making them Gold Compounders, and make Spikes with theirs Abilities, leting them heal every time. This doesnt work anymore, but maybe we can get workaround - we need Aluminium Ferring, spike him with F-Gold Spike, let him fill metalmind utill we are sure he will be able to recover from spiking him and steal his F- Aluminum. Now our Gold Compounder can make a lot of Unsealed Metalminds, so we can give them to Mistings and Ferrings together with F-Gold Spike. So Voilla, we now made End-Negative process into End-Positive one.

My theory is, that it is not Ba-Ado Mishram doing anything. She is trapped, isolated, cant do anything. But she is "warping" Realm around her. Rest is Shallan's ability. She is looking into Spiritual Realm, and is drawing Fortune to see something what requires her attention. Point is, Shallan doesnt comunicate with Re-Sephir when she sees her with her art. Also, She was drawing Sia-Anat even before she was able to comunicate with her. So I think Shallan is detecting "Warping" of Spiritual Realm and she sees Ba-Ado-Mishram as she was in the moment of imprisonment.

Pardon my bad manners, of course he is, and always been, Yanagawn the First! My assumption is based on fact Author is refering to the place of Contest of Champions as "in the East". Urithiru is located almost in the center of Roshar, so this rules out anyone from Alethkar, Jah Keved, Kharbrant, Thaylenah, Herdaz, Purelake, Shattered Plains, Horneater Peaks, New Natanatan and Urithiru itself. Seems to be also not from Shinovar. And Azimir is known for its documents. Its a longshot, I know, but it have some sense I think.

Aaa, yeah, it was about Nale, not Dalinar. THX @Child of Hodor What if Author is Gawx? He is not the warrior type, so he definitly can become Scholar and Philosopher Emperor of Azir. He also was around Lift long time, so maybe he heard some Spren atracted to her?

From how this is written I dont think this is someone from Shinovar - author is talking about Shinovar like something he didnt have acess too/ is far away from him/her. Also, arent Shin using normally phrase Man-son-someone, when naming people? Szeth is basicly always Szeth-son-son-Vallano in his POV. Isnt He even talking to Dalinar as Dalinar-son-God at some point? Can someone check this?

I dont think it is Syl. The next epigraph is: We know Contest of Champions is meant to happen in Urithiru, and here is described as "in the East". So it is someone who has point of reference in western part of Roshar, maybe in Azir.

Looks like Enlightened Spren have enough small part of them changed to still be able to enter the Tower. But this doesnt mean full Voidspren will be able to enter - similarly Fused and Regals cant function in the Tower now, but Venli can, despite fact she still is bonded to the Voidspren.

This is very unlikely. She is between dozens of Honorspren, every one of them knows her, so someone will notice she was changed. Dont even mention Sibling, who knows everything whats going in the Tower. Sibling is also explanation why she get there so fast - Sibling is literaly giant lighthouse for Spren.

But last sentence of that quotation sugests that author is talking about entire "Clensing of Shinovar" - he is taling about Witnesses of those events. He uses the same word on the start, and about with sources.

Dude, Nohadon is dead. Long dead. You don't have to "see the body" of someone who lived in the Silver Age of Roshar to assume that. Even if he isnt dead, his mental state will be in similar shape to Herlads i.e. in condition nowhere near to ability to write book. At least historical book. Other than that, he will be less relaiable narrator than Shallan is.

No way. And you even quoted why Szeth is first person involved in Cleansing of Shinovar, it is literally why he is going there. Why he woud need to discover what happened? He was there! Also, he didnt think of himself as Historian, not Philosopher, while this still can change. Jasnah or Sigzil is still more likely candidate, but Sigzil never mentioned about strange voices he heard. Also, I saw very interesting theory, without any evidence, tinfoil basicly, that this will be Dabbid, healed after he bonded Spren.

Point is, Nightwatcher is refered as Mother by Cultivationspren, and they have direct relation to Lifespren (they both are Edgedacers Spren for Sword and Armor) and Lifespren are used to comend Regrowth in Singer Music Ritual. Also Rythm used here is directCultivation Rythm, also directly associated with Nightwatcher. Boon - Curse is something entierly different, what (I assume) Nightwatcher gain after she was changed directly by Cultivation - basicly unmade. About Connection - in my theory Every One of those Old Magic Godspren was able to form Conection to the singing Singers, but Ba- Ado- Mishram was able to make them stronger to the point of binding entire Race. Seems Tention to me. Adhesion is normally associated directly with Honor, so I dont think Odium will corrupt this spren, and also is associated with air and pressure - and Wind is both.

I have very simmilar thought, except I dont think all Unmade were previously Old Magic Gods. I think there were 10 Gods, for each Surge, they were worshipped by Singers before Odium and Humans came to Roshar. As we can see in Venli's Vision Singers were able to manipulate Cohesion with proper Song, I think conjoined Song of proper Godspren resulted with some Bond with singing Singers and Godspren, and as result Singers get acess to matching Surge. So this is how I think they match: 1. Adhesion - Wind 2. Gravitation - Stormfather 3. Division - ? Chemoarish? 4. Abrasion - ? Dai- Gonarthis? 5. Regrowth - Nightwatcher 6. Ilumination - Re- Sephir 7. Transformation - Yelig- Nar 8. Transportation - Sia- Anat 9. Cohesion - Sibling 10. Tension - Ba- Ado- Mishram As you can see, I left out mindless Unmade, because I think Unmaking process left inteligence level of Spren mostly intact, and Odium wasnt able to Unmade all Old Gods,so he needet to find replacement in form of some lesser Spren. Also, looks like Honor and Cultivation also did the Unmaking, with Nightwatcher and Sibling. Yelig- Nar and Sia- Anat can be easily swaped, but I think Yelig- Nar matches Transformation beter. Also, I think this ancient Singer religion survived as Horneaters religion. Also if Singers helped Odium Unmake those great Spren this will explain this ancient betrayal they did.

Actually doesnt matter wich Bondsmith he will listen. Navani will probably agree with Dalinar, and third Bondsmith is Ishar, and he wants (when he was sane) for someone come to him in Shinovar.

For every Feruchemical ability with not usefull, annoing or dangerous storing: F- Steel, F- Zinc, F- Gold, F- Electrum, F- Pewter, F- Chromium, F- Cadmium, most usefull Allomantic ability will be A- Bendalloy, because is bypassing time of vulnerability you have during ability storage.

This reminds me about visions Venli have in Stone of Urithiru. Singers singing to one Rythm and manipulating Surge of Cohesion. We should assume they should be able to do this with every other Surge, so is possible that before Odium (and Humans) gods od Singers were powerfull Spren, for one Surge each, and providing it for his singing worshipers. Note that lesser Spren can also do that, but on much smaller scale. So this will also explain how BAM was able to Connect to all the Singers.

Szeth plus Kaladin are not 2 witnesses, but 4. Kaladin, Syl, Szeth and his Highspren. We can also count Nightblood, but he (it?) is unrelaiable, because he (it?) does not feel time properly.