Frustration

If they only cut identity to the SR why do they cut inorganic matter, or dead matter like it isn't there? And Shardblades cut on all three realms not just spiritual which is where Identity is located.

So it being a base effect of the metal doesn't work for you but identity does? I'm not sure I follow, if it was identity then spren could cut people apart by flying through them in spren form.

The basic function of the Shardmetal, just as Lerasium can make someone a Mistborn. Not having evidence to the contrary isn't evidence to support it, there isn't evidence that says that corrupted Dustbringers can't splinter shards, but that isn't evidence in support of it.

And do you have any evidence to back that up?

They cut the soul. I don't see how anything else is relevant.

Shardblades sever, they don't add

@Chinkoln I suppose I can make one of myself

check the spoiler box

RoW spoilers aren't allowed outside the designated forums, even with a spoiler box.

Shard meme WoR

This came up in Scadrian vs Rosharan magics post RoW

@Dannex

@ReadAndFindOut just for clarification it was 19k in one day for RoW, not total.

I am offended, boots! Why do you think that?

Ok, how was I supposed to know that Renarin was hinted at being made of gold in WoR, I still don't know where everyone else got that from.

Odium is yellow-white

That would be rather hard, most of the CS are on Braize at the time the name would have come around, and making new ones is really difficult except on Threnody.

Odium could see the memories in the breaths as to your second point, most likely.

Apparently this is unpopular but I wasn't impressed with design

It only appeared on one person at a time including Kal.

Nice, good job man

My opinions of the facts? I don't think so, but if you have examples I'm willing to hear them. Could you provide an example? On the contrary it seems he thinks it's useless I underestimate Twinning, or what you think it could accomplish? On compounding, the only one you can argue with is steel and Brandon has said it won't break the sound barrier, and that peter/steel might be faster than steel/steel, so I don't think that is an underestimation. I gave you a suggestion but you "didn't see the point." Hemalurgy is stealing, not storing, Leeching does not store, it destroys. Forgery is about changing the history of an object, and Nahel bonds don't store anything. But none of that matters because none of them are Feruchemy. I have been dismissive? I have kept this discussion within the realm of plausibility. If someone has left the discussion because of me I would like to apologize to them for it, but people leave threads for hundreds of reasons. And again I have given you situations, two quite recently in fact but you "didn't see the point" and never gave more than a one line response to them. That could probably work, given that Harmonium was based on Cesium, but more powerful, I could see that working. only two potential downsides I can see, you don't want to accidentally hit yourself or your allies, and we don't know how rare it is. Given that, it would probably be best in an airstrike to prevent friendly fire, but it could be incredibly effective.

Straff is also on drugs at this point. Saying we don't know what compounding does, doesn't mean you can assume what it does and treat it as fact. Lack of awareness? I have argued based on factual evidece on all my points, what am I unaware of? No, we are shouting down unsupported and occasionally outright wrong information, you will note that when @Enter a username gave quotes on the size of the ship I came to the conclusion that it was too big for a Radiant to significantly affect. Radiants aren't invicible, but I don't think your methods of dealing with them are enough. Why would I make a sugestion if I didn't think it worked that way? Or if all known evidence was contrary to it, that's like saying I can use a single atom of Anti-matter to delete a Black hole from existence. I make suggestions based on what we know. How do you know Aluminum compounding does work that way? Brandon RAFOed it. Ok, 1. We have never seen anything that suggests you can store someone elses attirbutes 2. I would give your ideas consideration if you coud supply evidence to support them, If you can't support your theories they won't be considered, it's just like real life science, evidence is everything. I am not trying to intimidate you off this thread, just correct your misconceptions, you can still support Scadrial, I think that several of the people that do have good points, but I'm not going to throw out everything we know about the cosmere to have the battle take place the way you think it should.

Syl isn't only able to form a sheild, I don't think the oaths have anything to do with wether or not you can transfer plate.