Karnage

*takes deep breath* I have been following this thread since it started. While, there is much I could say, I will just shorten it to my two cents. I can see both sides of the argument on whether or not Brandon should say anything. Both sides are tempting and make sense. It would be great (absolutely great!) if Brandon said something, but personally my feelings and excitement about Brandon, his works, and the cosmere, does not hinge upon him saying something. Again, it would be great but everything doesn't hinge upon it. I get this, it makes sense, but I think that Brandon does speak through his books. Trying not feel attacked (this is my favorite author you are talking about). Everything he does or thinks does not have to be on the internet. This comment really bothers me because of the fact that it is very "judgy". You don't know his personal life, you don't know if he has "lived" up to the stuff he writes. The whole point of the BLM movement comes down to not judging. Whats up with that? Amen.

I really don't have much time to post but a tie is not going to help us. Araris, ILUVHATZ

*Sees WoR and automatically interprets it as Rythm of War* Screams out loud in excitement and envy, "What! They are a beta reader. So lucky". *Then realizes that it stands for Words of Radiance and contrinues to devour the rest of the post* I don't know if I am the only one that does this but I am so excited for RoW that I freak out (in excitement) whenever WoR is referenced. Somewhere in the split second of reading it I misread it to be RoW.

Hey y'all I still here! For a while I might just have to meet the minimum requirements to be active because I have been busy, but we will see. First off there is going to be a lot going on in the game. A lot. I suspect that we won't be able to trust anybody's role call (if they do make one) since there are many roles that can have similar results while going about it different ways. I think that the best way to catch eliminators is by catching them in the act of lying (as they don't want the villagers to know anything) which will requiring some sleuthing which I know many of y'all are good at and goes over my head some of the time. So either catching them lying or finding them going under the radar. The radar part being a hard route to find them since there will inevitably be some villagers who won't be active in the game. The thief seems particularly troubling in the elims hands (as Magestrar said), honestly they could probably just target the person who has made the most posts so far and gradually just get more and more money till they can get the most powerful items to use. As for the elim team. I suspect that there might be 4-6 people on the elim team with 1-2 of them being newer players, 1-2 of them being mid-experienced players, and 2-4 being experienced players. I don't really want to vote on Mist since they are newer to the game. I will place a vote on Araris since they are pretty experienced form what I know and in the MR the most experienced ones seemed like those that could hide the best and make themselves the most invaluable. (Looking at you Straw). I feel like getting a more experienced player lynched could be a good thing and a bad thing. The good part being that whatever they end up having done they would have done it in the best interests of whomever side they are on, a second good thing is that if a newer player is on the elim team then it is harder to get a read on what they have done or were trying to do. The bad part is that we get rid of an experience player who can help out a lot more that a non- experienced player.

Uhhh, guys. I think I just won on accident. Oops.

I AM SO EXCITED. Now that I have dies in the other game I have been itching to get in another game. My name for this is going to be Lance Neverwatch.

Ohhhhhhhhhhhh, yah. Hyperactive Kyle, Mafia, Robbery Gone Wrong, and a bunch of the early stuff was great. The JK fill in the blank sketches were great especially the Stacy and Matt angel one. Not gonna lie, Studio C has been a great source of comedy and a huge part of my childhood.

How'd you find out about that, there is no role to spy on the GM PM is there. I bet the GM that I would die yesterday night with a yellow lightsaber. Not sure how Elkanah found out about that but it seems just a little susp.

Such a troll, I don't believe it for a second. Tho, it wouldn't be the craziest thing thats happened in the game. Thinks over the game so far. Wow thats a lot of stuff that has happened. How were other games won in the first few cycles, can you point them out to me?

Okay.............

Oops I forgot to red highlight my new vote. Elkanah. Still not so sure about that vote but I will be back in a while.

What are you talking about. All I accounted for was the Bleeder Kill. Do you know something otherwise. Some inside info perhaps? With the discussion about Pyro, I think it could make sense to leave him in, anything he does might give us info and we will always have a elim lynch ready to go when we need it. We might want to focus more on finding the other elims for now. I am not sure who else I am suspicions of tho. With the three of my main suspicions dying last night. Anybody have a suspicions with stuff to back it up. I think I might spend a little time in a few hours looking back through the threads. Pyro, We will lynch when we want to. How about that. The only problem with leaving them alive is that we don't know what abilities they have. Should we be scared enough of them to lynch them now instead of trying to find other elims? I see that two people have voted Elk, why is that?

Was-up, hows it going. I survived but I do not think anybody protected me as in bodyguard terms. I used my scanner ability on Fura but then it was moved to Orlock by some unknown means but they bother ended up dying so my scan ability was useless last cycle. Pyro I am kinda surprised that you didn't die instead of Orlock, maybe some kinda manipulation there on the elims part, I dunno.

Well if there are any villagers that want to help out, I would very much like to keep both lives. I gotta go. Be back, don't go cray while i'm gone.

Did the.... are the elims giving up? What is going on. Umm, since the elims are revealing things willy nilly i've got a question. Even tho we cannot trust y'all completely can yall tell us how many elims there are (from the begining of the game. So Pyro, Orlok Straw, and one mor eperson are outed as elims. Or self outed. Can someone point out the one other outed elim? Also, wow this has been a productive 1 1/2 cycles. This has got to be a record right?

I just found this place, let me just say its been interesting reading through it all. Its amazing how technology can create such a front. I honestly didn't expect AonEne or Nameless to be able to join this group. All this diversity is amazing as well, looks like there are a few in here that are from elsewhere in the world. It makes me wonder though how many kids actually are on this site and us not know it at all. By the way, my favorite order are the Stonewards purely for the theories/ not know anything about them/ they could be really cool. But the one that has actually shown its face in the books that I enjoy the most (with the possibilities) are the Wallshapers. 17, 5'11 (but still growing) (its pretty late and weird) ( I just want to reach the magical 6'0) Also, Ene big fan of seeing you around the forum, Nameless same to you. It seems like we are all on separate corners of the 17th shard with Ene being into the role playing, Nameless in the theories, and me lurking and watching those two while playing Sanderson Elimination.

How do you have a scan. The only other scan ability is Bleeder. Could you explain at all? I got ninjad by Straw

You keep on saying that, while also using other peoples analysis (such as styker) to vote. I get it because you're newer, but just spend a little time to get caught up by reading the posts and you will be fine. Its that or your just faking it which I am a bit inclined to. Right now I am trying to choose between wether to scan Orlock (if he is and outed three members it would be too good) Emi or Stryker. I am more inclined to the Stryker or Emi because like I said before they do seem a bit linked.

I am thinking the same thing except instead of Matrim I'm leaning more Emi because I feel like they are being heavily influenced by other elims (possibly Styker), such as the bandwagon vote only using the same "weird logic" that I saw from Stryker. They literally just quoted Stryker and put their vote on me last round. You know what, I was thinking that I would scan Pyro this hour but since most of the thread is already leaning Pyro for next lynch (unless somehow I messed up or I was lied to by the gm in terms of the Straw scan). I was thinking that I might scan Emi/ or Stryker. Yah what is hedging? Also if there are any village (or possibly elim) bartenders do if one of y'all wants to focus on Pyro then that would be great. I am leaning Bleeder for them with elim being a close second.

I haven't read the rules yet, I will later. But I'm in! Name to come later.

Exactly. I will be back in approximatly 4-5 hours. Y'all don't get into too much trouble. A question for y'all when I am gone. As of right now Straw is pretty much lynched, therefore I am thinking that elims are jumping on the train to not look suspicious. Does this seem plausible or do y'all thinking that they are the ones that haven't posted yet, or maybe a mix?

Yah, I guess that makes sense. It would break the game otherwise. 1. I am not sure why I got Gambling Tycoon. @A Joe in the Bush were extra roles randomized? 2.Yeah, the only logical thing for Straw to do is to claim to not be a constable, I was expecting this. 3. I agree it was risky, I was thinking that maybe we could get elims and village working together to stop bleeder from winning, and second make an unkillable role scanner. But the pm idea not that I look back at it, is a really bad idea. Someone could claim to be a bodyguard and then not guard me. Mmm any ideas to make this idea better? I was just thinking about ways that we can get around only being able to protect someone once every two turns. I was thinking that we could orchestrate it, but I guess that would not work. @little wilson and other more experienced players, would there be a way to make this work? Like I said before, even if I was lying this could only be a good thing for village. 1. Distraction for Bleeder 2. Once we lynch Straw we will have already caught 1 elim. Not sure what all this extortion convo is about I will have to re-read the rules about it so I can understand what y'all are talking about.

Exactly. I don't get it pyro why are you so against me? I will scan Pyro this turn since he seems very suspicious. I am Flogs tho so if I get killed then 1. Theres no way to find elims other than by lynching them 2. Bleeder is that much closer to winning and both elims and villagers are that much closer to losing. 3. If I die we lose a source of village "working together thing" if anybody does end up pming me. If Pyro shows up as non- constable than I am assuming they are Bleeder. If anythings this role claims and elims and village working together to keep me alive helps bleeder the least then elim team and finally village. Therefore Bleeder will do anything to try to convince everyone to kill me as flogs. Edit: I just saw wilsons post and I would agree Pyro you look really suspicious, and depending on what you flip with my scan you might be nex on the lynch after straw.

Okay I am taking a HUGE risk. I am Flogs I am also a Gambling Tycoon I was trying to decide whether it was a risk I should take but seeing as the conversation is already steering towards the idea that I am Flogs, I figured that Bleeder would be onto me soon anyways. Few things I was thinking -There are probable 2 Bodyguards in the Village and maybe one in the elim faction. - Elim faction wants to keep me alive so that Bleeder doesn't beet them -If protection is coordinated the each turn I can be protected from Bleeder and the village is that much more closer to winning (same with the elim faction -If the Bodyguards each send me a PM offering their protection (I promise not to reveal your role to the thread unless I get permission) then I can respond each hour to one (that one would then protect me) while the others protect others on that turn. Each turn I will respond to each one and hopefully forever stay safe from the likes of Bleeder. - Not only does this help the village but it also helps the elims (except for the fact that I can scan people) Speaking of Scanning- I decided to scan straw because they are very hard to read, because they are so integral to the discussion in every game that I have been in with them. I scanned them and Joe replied with saying that they are Constable. Straw Are we allowed to screen shot pm's? I will wait for a response before I post again. Hopefully this stirs the pot for the better for the village. If you are a bodyguard and you want either the village or elim team to win I suggest you pm me. -Karnage