Mailliw73
-
Posts
7523 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Mailliw73
-
I’d be surprised if there was a third party role. Steel seems off to me and he’s still under Devotary and droguht in my suspicions, but I don’t think he’s a neutral.
-
Shane also had one, making 6. Me and Itiah were missed on his post for whatever reason. As long as you’re counting me as 0, then, sure. I’m probably not going to go through and count them all.
-
I actually recounted the Bendalloy that cycle and they are all accounted for. So no worries.
-
I’m not sure... Devotary feels more off, but I can’t really find a reason why. Drought is one who wouldn’t claim for a while and interactions with Roadwalker were more suspicious. I’d be okay either way. Edit: also, about your point on Itiah and Elandera’s zinc. According to elandera’s table, Elandera and Drought claimed zinc D2 while Itiah did D3 and elandera did not.
-
I just went and reread most of the game, specifically Roadwalker’s posts. A few things that stood out to me: he was very against Bendalloy. I think this was to focus our efforts on those who held it that cycle when he revealed those of us who held it. We still only have 5 Bendalloy that cycle accounted for. @Furamirionind @I think I am here. @FatherTiempo, did any of you have 2 Bendalloy cycle 2? Roadwalker’s interactions with Fura have turned me away from suspecting him much as well. He’s also been the only player open about having iron, and I suspect the elims have at least one or two of them to keep pulling medallions to themselves. Drought and Devotary are my two highest suspicions now. Also, did anyone notice that devotary’s rp character is a southern Scadrian? :P
-
Who was the other option for having rioted the vote? I personally don’t think Roadwalker would give up his teammates like that. Doesn’t seem fitting to him. Obviously it could be an IKYK, but I’m doubting it. The whole Ark thing has been pushed too hard by too many. Also, that paragraph is super hedgey. I had no medallions last cycle. I’m inclined to believe that the Elims have a few iron going around and they’re pulling everything towards them. Maybe Steel that we haven’t found either. This only increases my suspicion of Fura.
-
Sweet! There’s one. So 7v3 hopefully. @Kidpen Writeup says Elandera was village, but player list says elim. Fura.
-
Not unless the Southerns kill you.
-
The disadvantage to this bendalloy thing is that it kills night discussion since we’re all still waiting on results. Any thoughts, @Roadwalker? Also, we’re still missing a lot of D1 claims. At this point, we need all the info we can get. Anyone want to share what they had that cycle?
-
Quick Fix Game 36/Anonymous Game 5: Dream Thieves
Mailliw73 replied to Steeldancer's topic in Sanderson Elimination
That’s alright with me. Especially if Alv is playing. Going head to head and working with him are equally fun. And I’ve done both in the last two games I’ve played, so I’m excited to see how this one goes. -
@Kidpen Is it possible to keep a medallion after a cycle?
-
GM clarified for you?
-
@Furamirionind If you have a Brass, Roadwalker must’ve been lying, correct? Because his scan came before Shane died with a brass. And he said there was only one. I’m confused by how the “brass wouldn’t move” though, like Elandera said. For the sake of transparency, I had a Pewter medallion for C3 as well as that Tin one. @Droughtbringer How come you haven’t shared any of your medallions? It can’t hurt to share the first few cycles’ now. I don’t see what the point is in not sharing. I’m also going to stick with Roadwalker for now. The scan feels off to me as well.
-
This is exactly what I was going to say. If making this day an hour shorter or something helps, go for it. We’re grateful you’re taking the time to run the game, so you do what you gotta do to keep going.
-
Hmm. Those numbers present interesting points, one being what Devotary mentioned about Shane and brass. Theres also only one duralumin, so whoever has that would have to be the one who changed the votes. If anyone has Tin charges left, that’d be a good one to check tonight. If there’s only 4 aluminum left, does that mean someone lied on that first day about their aluminum? I’m not sure how that worked out, I just know that there were 7 claims and one aluminum just died with Shane. Edit: and Cadcom died with aluminum, so there’s two confirmed. Also, since Fifth died with an iron, that means there were 5? Seems like a lot.
-
Wait so did someone get soothed off of Shane too then?
-
Five players of 13 is all we have active? My other thought was that Roadwalker could’ve used Brass (or someone wanting to protect him)since Devotary seemed to be headed towards voting for him and since you only have a medallion for a cycle anyways, there’s more reason to use it.
-
Have we considered that the vote manipulation may not have been to save Ark? Two of the 3 votes placed on him were done in the last hour of the game and it seems more likely that someone was trying to save Drought or another option up for the lynch.
-
So best odds right now, we’re at 9 villagers, 4 Elims. We definitely need to start widening that gap again. I’m still behind on D2, but something is off between Elandera, Devotary, and Fura. I’d be very shocked if none of the above was an elim. My current top suspicions would be Steel, Fura, Roadwalker, and Devo or Ark.
-
That’s a good question for Kidpen, but since I was around, I could’ve just voted myself. I also know Fura was around at the same time I was. I’ve already tagged and revealed Roadwalker as the only Gold holder.
-
I was concerned as I couldn’t recall if Gold was a night or day action but I just checked and it’s a day action, so @Roadwalker, what were the results of your gold scan? Yeah, it was started up by Hero(?) I believe a few years ago to counter inactivity and that’s what began voting for inactives.
-
Gotcha. And we’ve got almost the max of bendalloy too. Unless, @Furamirionind, @shanerockes, @I think I am here., And @FatherTiempo, did any of you have multiple bendalloy that cycle? Yay! The Contribution Crusade returns! I haven’t heard that mentioned in ages. Sorry, Shane I specifically didn’t vote because of my last minute addition to the game, but I forgot that that’s exactly how zinc works. Also, I had Tin during the day and scanned for Gold. I don’t have time to reread the rules again, but is now a good time to post the results or after the night? I’ve been reading through the thread up to D2. Some thoughts: I love that Fifth encouraged practice lying. Always a good strategy. Steel is my number one suspicion from D1. The vote to save Fura seems really off to me. I also think Fura would be a valuable lynch as he’s had many interactions with lots of players and knowing his alignment could help us figure that out.
-
Just to clarify my position, apparently Eternum requested that they be replaced so as not to hinder the game. I can see how that could make it seem like he was an eliminator, but figured I’d throw the reason out there for clarity. Do we have any idea on the numbers of medallions out there? Or if any weren’t made by the southerners? Because we know of 5 Bendalloy medallions now which is one short of the max. I find it interesting that the eliminators made so many, since it does help them if one of their members gets lynched, but not much.
-
Definitely can be useful, but it takes a concentrated amount of time. I’ve used it before, but mostly to figure out who was PMing who(to narrow down PM abilities). Trying to use that to analyze who could’ve put in the night kill isn’t as useful because most players are at least on at some point during the 24 hour period.
-
I just checked to be sure and yep. I stated it right. D1: 1 Bendalloy D2: 2 Bendalloy, 1 Tin. I’m interested to hear from Roadwalker too. I’m not sure why he’d have lied about it, but it’s a strange discrepancy.
