bartbug

Each month, you'll get a token that you can redeem for one audiobook, of your choosing. After you get the audiobook, it's yours to keep. Forever. Even though I'm not big on audiobooks, I highly recommend audible.

Killing inactives is not helpful. I understand getting Quiver, because I think he's been on, but Chide just isn't here. So, I make a plea into the Hallandrens: we are down in numbers, I believe. Let's take down an Idrian.

Umm... can't vote, but I think that Wyrmhero is kind of suspicious, mostly because he (vehemently) did not like my idea <pouts>, But in all honesty, I feel that his reasons were kind of... off. Like how it was bad because it wasn't fun. Can't vote, but he's the first one who comes to mind

Alright, I can see that you guys really don't like the idea of giving your Breath to Aonar. That's fine: I would need full support from literally everyone for it to be worth it. So here's another go, a revised version of the same concept: If you are clearly going to be voted to death, make sure to give your Breath to Aonar before you go. This way, Aonar will continue to get Breaths, hopefully up to the 5th Heightening, and most of you get to keep your Breaths. EDIT: @Gamma: I can see if you don't necessarily agree with my tactics, but how do they help the Pahn Kahl?

All of the mercs should be guarding him. Also, if a Returned sees him about to die, then they should probably save him. EDIT: Also, if we get him to the 10th Heightening, then any Pahn Kahl who gets his breath will be revealed as a Pahn Kahl. I don't see why we shouldn't do this; the advantages outweigh any of the disadvantages by a serious amount. And also, strawman are a really bad way of mining for info. Unless you get lucky enough to find the single Pahn Kahl (1 / 5-8 chance), you won't find out who the person is, just what they did last night in a very vague way.

@Dyring: I was a drab until last night's end. I'll explain. Start of game/Day 1: I have 3 Breaths, 2nd Awakening. Night 1: Create a Strawman, spy on Meta. Day 2: Have no Breaths, because all in strawman. Night 2: Take back Breaths in Strawman. Day 3: Have my Breaths back, so I give it to Aonar. EDIT: And by the way everyone, I say that all of you need to give your Breaths to Aonar. This way no one dies today, but we cripple our enemy and god mode one on our team. What say you?

Alrighty, I'm going to give my Breath to Aonar: My life to yours, my Breath become yours!

Have any of the Heralds been on a different Shardworlds since they split ways in the prelude? Have any of the Heralds Returned? Could a Herald return? Who was Vasher before he died? Was he a person of cosmeric significance back then?

You find out what nicrosil does in the terris one, which is pretty cool. It lets you converts charges into pure investiture, which you can you for any feruchemical ability.

OOC: Ummm.... ew. Cows everywhere are screaming in horror over this mental image.

I listened. It was pretty interesting, but it was kind of frustrating how they would skirt taking in depth about the cosmere, only to retreat back to standard topics.

Swimim! Come on, man. You need to get over here, so you can change our mind so we don't kill you.

Dang it. Nothing cosmere related, other than the brief overview of Hoid.

By the way, in case anyone was wondering, I'm drab, but with a three Breath strawman. So, if you want me to be able to get those Breaths into Aonar, I suggest voting for someone other than me, because as it stands, those three Breaths are gone.

And, just want to make it clear: Just because we four are the only players openly doing things, doesn't mean we're the only players doing things. In general, killing off your most proactive players is not your best bet.

I'm a little disappointed that we can't go beyond voting for the first person to vote, but oh well. Swimim, because he lied and I don't want to die. And I have a proposal: If you want to kill me, don't kill me today: Kill me tomorrow. Give me a chance to get back my Breath, and then I can give that to Aodan.

Alright. Aodan, I officially retract my vote for you. And... poop. No vote, for this round, I guess. We don't need to kill anyone for this to be a productive round, and Cog's not going to die anytime soon, it seems. Good job, team. And I'm out. Only until my name comes up as a suspect, again. And guys, by the way, if Aodan's spy agency works out, then we don't need to kill anyone without being certain of their alinement. If he coordinates it all, then we should be fine.

@Claincy: So the Idrian monk absolutely cannot be Pahn Kahl?

What do I have to say? I'm confused. And by the way, if I forgot to retract my vote for Cog, then here it is. If you want me to be honest in my dealings, then that's fine. I agree with dyring: the easiest way forward is that of honesty. So: 1. Talked in secret Hallandren cabal, talked about things, Swimim said he was the spy. 2. Talked to Vard. He was the first one to tell me, and he told only me. If this makes you want to kill me, fine. I'm useless. 3. Talked to Aonar. He sent a PM to Awesomeness, Meta, and me, which is part of the reason I am suspicious of him, and Meta. Replying to three people at once seems kind of unnecessarily foolish, but its not if you know what roles they have. 4.Awesomeness sent me some... instructions, about how to act upon his death. He told me how Swimim told Awesomeness that Swimim was lying, just to make him look not guilty. 5. Sent a strawman after Meta. I wanted to try and affirm if my allies were actually my allies, and also check his capabilities. 6. Everything that you've seen here. I voted for Meta because he lied about being a drab, and in a way that told him who the Returned were. There you have it. Everything I've done. And of course, by telling you, and by being the first person to seriously vote, I've put myself on the chopping block. That's fine. To get the Pahn Kahl, we have to burn the forest. @Hero: Wow. I feel kind of embarrassed now... I completely ignored all of the Idrian roles. Maybe I got too deep into my character.

The way I see it, the only way for the villagers to win in this particular game is to burn everything to the ground. There are no sure ways to check someone on their innocence, other than their death. I think that Aodan is messing with us pretty good, and that's not okay. Besides, killing him gives us more information: if he dies and is proven innocent, we learn that there are probably two Idrian agents. If Cog dies, then we learn nothing if he is telling the truth. If Cog is not dead by morning, however, I will lead the charge towards him. @Gamma: Cog's argument is all semantics. What we need to evaluate are the facts: He lied to us. He asked the Returned to PM him their identities. He got more Breath. And Aodan, as I have said, serves us better dead than alive. Which reminds me... Are the Idrian Agent(s) willing to step up and tell us who you are? Or better yet, space out your entry to make the Pahn Kahl sweat. If there are two of you, it would do a lot to help us verify if Aodan is telling the truth. And if he isn't, then we can set our targets on you. One of you, at least, will have to be a Pahn Kahl. Idrian Agents, do you understand? If you come out, you have the potential of ending this game early.

This is a really great first theory. Well thought out, and it fits reasonably well in a realmatic sense. Have an upvote.

Just being clear: I am not voting for Meta because I am 100% sure that he is Pahn Kahl. I am voting for him because he is a). too weak to be a big loss, and . he has acted the most suspiciously. Unfortunately, in all likelihood, he's clean. In this game, however, it is impossible to find out exactly who he is without killing him. Sorry, Meta.

No ones voted yet, so I guess I'll step in. Meta. Said he was giving up his Breath, but was really trying to buy more. Drab my chull. Yeah, I sent my strawman after him. Fortunately, that renders me somewhat useless now. No Breath for you to steal.

I agree that Mistborn would be probably the best place to start. Go for it, Mikanium! After Mistborn, I would say Warbreaker, then Stormlight, and finally Elantris. You gotta keep him interested, so he's already invested in the cosmere by the time he gets to Elantris.

Oh. I don't have either of those, but I'll un-private the photo.