The thing is, Eero, even though I'm slightly more familiar with 4e's mechanics, I'm still relatively new to D&D as a whole, so I'm pretty flexible. I'll see what I can do about getting my hands on the rules and go from there. I normally tend to play casters, but since the majority of us seem to have the same feelings, I might try something new.
Is there any particular campaign setting I should be looking at in terms of lore, deities, etc? I didn't see anything (except the dungeon name) mentioned specifically, but I might have missed it somehow.