Jump to content

mathiau

Members
  • Posts

    2363
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

Everything posted by mathiau

  1. It's empty
  2. The joke is that as a French I can't figure out whether you're supposed to prononce Vin [vin] (the natural way for a French to say it if they assume it's a foreign word) or [vɛ̃] (the way a French would say it if they assume it's a French word and missed Vin was a girl) (the words insides the [] are written in international phonetic language)
  3. In French we call viola "alto" while we either call hurdy-gurdy a "viole" or a "vielle" Yes it's not very funny but I actually did that face when I saw Doomstick's meme
  4. French people who were confusing Viola and hurdy-gurdy Now I want the full story
  5. Wait, Kel is know to have a poor handwritting?
  6. Well Elhokar is dead so it can't be him. In terms of combat strength the best choice is probably Nale or El (the original Vyre), if Szeth end up Dalinar's champion I do think Nale will be Vargo's one. If Kal was Dalinar's champion it's very likely what would happen, but Kal won't be Dalinar's champion Galivar. You get all the best thing you'd get from having Gavinor as a champion and it actually makes some sense. Also Or Ishar for the TFE parallels
  7. Of course they have some overlap, it's just that someone compatible with Windrunners is more likely to be compatible with Edgedancers or Stonewards than with Skybreakers because there's more overlap between protection and helping the forgotten or standing were you're needed than with justice. Honestly I should have said Dustbringers/Edgedancers instead of Windrunners/Skybreakers, it's more obvious for them. I don't know, Skybreakers (Nale first) are supposed to be Confident.
  8. Be careful with shared-surges reasoning, there is more crossover between Edgedancers and Windrunners than between Windrunners and Skybreakers, at least on the compatibility side of things.
  9. Da'ar gave a slight reverence "Happy to have been able to help you" He found a chair, took out the dark circle from earlier and took a crystalline contraption out of it before putting it back, he did this process a few times.
  10. I don't know I just can't imagine Rushu, the gemstone shinning in all directions, fitting into that description
  11. I mean, there are DRs about events that couldn't have happened if Cultivation hadn't changed Dalinar's future so I don't think this will happen I don't know, there's another DR about darkness ruling and it's definitely not about Kholinar Well I think the fact H-Duralumin can steal Nahel Bounds implies it does last at least some time If anyone's interested, here's a 20min video of a girl theorising Dalinar will lose the contest and the Stormfather will become a Deadeye
  12. I don't know how much it matters but I'm a scientist IRL and the KR kizz gives me significantly more compatible with Edgedancers than Truthwatchers (68% vs 54%) Don't forget the cobbler was consider by the Lifespren council when they discussed who would bound with Windle so he was definitely compatible with both the Edgedancer order and the Truthwatcher one, it's probably the same for the Stump. So basically what you're saying is that Rushu is actually likely to become a Truthwatcher despite acting opposite to how the in universe WoR implies they act? the in universe Rushu, for you we already knew I don't know, I feel like the Alethi and Azish education system would select Elsecaller compatible people over Truthwatcher compatible ones to become Scholars, especially the Alethi one. Especially since we know Mistsprens are closer to Cultivation than Honour and it's likely Enlightened Truesprens are mostly Honour+Odium since Voidbinding is almost certainly the Honour+Odium magic system (why else would Voidbinders have to speak oaths?)
  13. Da'ar could almost feel Remembrance inside his mind, calming the defences his mind had reflexively put up, seeking knowledge inside his memories. He smiled "So, have you found what you needed?"
  14. Add to this that if Kal had become Dalinar's champion it would basically had been the only way for Odium to stop Lezian from breaking the contract and letting Cultivation splinter it.
  15. It's how I call follower of the Irali religion, it's a reference to how you had Kelsier say everything was one back in Forged Iron Yeah give eighty years he definitely would
  16. The decision has been taken, it doesn't mean it has been applied yet. Also I see you didn't mentioned my counter-argument, I suppose it means you agree with them? (in the sense that you agree they counter your arguments, not in the sense they prove your conclusion wrong) We are absolutely not?
  17. Four are about abandoning the tower (2-22, 8-1, 4-17 and 10-1) four other are about the tower falling apart (1-1 1s, 1-1 2nd, 1-1 3rd and 3-11) That's eight out of thirty, six drawers out of twenty-two. Also how do you explain this If the tower was already close to be abandoned?
  18. I asked why you thought every gemstone of the archive was from after the Sibling broke his bound, not why you knew some of them where from after he did. Also the Sibling withdrawn from men (other than Melishi) before he broke his bound, the protective fabrials were part of Melishi's plan to bring him back
  19. I fail to see where in these lines you find that the Tower was abandoned after BAM's capture
  20. So do you agree Trellism is not covered by religious freedom? There might be a possibility to annihilate them with antiinvestiture but that create a host of new problems Fair point
  21. After Kel being Oneist, Saze is Beyondist comfirmed! I love how you're implying Roshar was not the first time Mraize started a war
  22. Do you consider religious freedom should allows the people to kill anyone their god want them to kill? That might be harder to do than avoiding them to bleed in the CR in the first place, but honestly the main issue is actually that splintered Shards can be reformed While I don't agree this is true I don't see why you said that quoting me saying it seemed opposite to Adonalsium's explicit commends It... Never was?
×
×
  • Create New...