bmcclure7
Members-
Posts
1195 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by bmcclure7
-
If there is some sort of disaster the tower could serve as a sort of ark. It has portals to all of the countries of the coalition and is not dependent on stormlight (Should some thing happen to the high storm) and the enemies powers wont work there and its completely self substantiating. And could easily see a scenario were thr rest of roshar is concurred or destroyed so the coalition evacuated to the tower.
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
We have no idea about the destruction of ashy. Odium has been clear he needs humanity as his army. He clearly needs them alive. No, He doesn't alter laws, That would be illegal. Kings and other legitimate authorities change laws and When they changed it in his advantage he adapts.- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
Wrong on both accounts so far we only now of one fuse that attempted genocide. Odium but it very clear that he needs humans alive. He killed Radiants for commit crimes that would be punishable by death and only after getting a lawful death warrant. If that makes him evil then ever officer in Roshar is evil.- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
Nail isnt genociding anyone.- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
Melishi didn't enslave all the Parshmen. And keeping with your logic (the side you support did terrible things 4 thousand years ago so your immoral for supporting them) then yes he is.- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
The humans The lottomized the entire race of singers and then inslaved them. By your own logic this makes Kaliden immoral for supporting humans. If Nale was trying to avoid torture then he wouldn't get involved at all. Just like the rest of the Heralds.- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
Nale is crazy and beside by that logic the human reduce singer civilization lobitmised animals. But that logic Kaliden is immoral.- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Herald's Appearances and a theory on the Oathpact foundation
bmcclure7 replied to Could Be Fire's topic in Stormlight Archive
This theory makes a lot of sense. -
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
As I said their stupid not immoral.- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
Yes give The singers are rightful land back so evil. How dare he seek to restore land to unabused and slave minority. And since you can't see I'm rolling my eyes.- 40 replies
-
1
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
You mean the force dedicated to restoring the land rights to an enslaved class?- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
You see stupid not immoral.- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
No an entire order has side with the singers. They gave their reasons for it The reasons are stupid but not immoral.- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
It dose suggests that who has developed enough moral for a Spren to try and bond him.- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Szeth & Moash: They're More Similar Than You Think [Discuss]
bmcclure7 replied to a topic in Stormlight Archive
He literally saw him about to swear an OATH what do you mean he doesn't have that benefit. You don't have to make things up every time a character dose something bad just to give it some form justification.- 40 replies
-
- rhythm of war
- szeth
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
I don't think he could be pushed to fight hes too stubborn.
- 36 replies
-
- roshar
- knights radiant
- (and 5 more)
-
Stubborn yes that he is you have to be to be a pacifist.
- 36 replies
-
- roshar
- knights radiant
- (and 5 more)
-
Lirin has been saving people for years. He also killed far less.
- 36 replies
-
1
-
- roshar
- knights radiant
- (and 5 more)
-
OK so you say they're just the same and then go on to explain how they're direct opposites. Me personally much prefer Lirin. He sticks to his principles even to his own hurt. He treats his enemies As well as everyone else. In this way he reminds me a little bit of a wind runner even if he does have much more Synthesis with the edgedancers. He also a very humble man. He knows there is nothing he can do to stop odium. He's not even a radiant hes a surgeon. And to be quite honest he realizes that other people smarter and more powerful than him already have it handled. He might not be able to save the world, or change society but he knows he can save the person in front of them so that's what he dose.
- 36 replies
-
- roshar
- knights radiant
- (and 5 more)
-
Lirin has decated himself to the dark eyed farms of a tiny village. People no body else remembers. He is the perfect edgedancer .
- 36 replies
-
2
-
- roshar
- knights radiant
- (and 5 more)
-
Steelslayer (with his epic powers) Fire fight Prof Wingflare Life force ( as seen with all his abilities at the end) Obliteration Nightwielder Regalia Loophole Jax (with watch, Sword, and sonic gun.) Round one, matches chosen at random. Prof v fire fight. Loophole vs wingflare Jax v Regalia. Nightwielder v Lifeforce Obliteration v stealslayer
-
Night of Sorrows- Migration to Shadesmar theory
bmcclure7 replied to KaladinWorldsinger's topic in Stormlight Archive
Why would it be unlikely we know scholars regularly visit the physical realm I would be surprised if they didn't have connection all over the PR. -
The fused are surge binders
-
Night of Sorrows- Migration to Shadesmar theory
bmcclure7 replied to KaladinWorldsinger's topic in Stormlight Archive
I think we can presume that they get water and food from the physical realm. That won't really be an option For the refugees from roshar. Consider that if it was that easy to colonize the cognitive reaugmentative realm why didn't it be humans from ashen Do that Instead of crossing over to roshar. -
Given what happened at the end I don't think that this is the case.