Ishar

@A stick Also, do Highprinces count as "Ruling their realm" when there is a king? Adolin

Whichever one inhabits a planet where it is easier to get a divorce. Would you rather eat Scadrian waffles or Rosharan Pancakes.

Kingdoms or Countries I guess. Gavinor

I am not happy about it either.

This is perhaps my favorite meme on the entire thread.

Jasnah

I was going to say that... (Also, it is spelled Sebarial) Nohadon.

Proof: Sazed would have never ascended if it weren't for Dockson Theory: Animal's horns (no matter what the animal is) are Hemalurgic Spikes.

Hmm... but of the plot of this thread is explaining times you misunderstood a book, isn't explaining the thread fall outside of it's guidelines, meaning it isn't in opposition to the thread, but merely there?

Proof: The Cosmere is fictional (Sadly) Theory: Unicorns are Hemalurgically spiked Rhyshadium.

Wasn't I the one who said this originally?

I would enter for the next round, but I feel like I would end up insulting people's choice of character instead of the actual character.

This thread:

Who exactly was correct?

Daorn

When your non-sanderfan friends automatically assume that whenever you say something that doesn't make sense it is a book reference. When your sanderfan friend gets a unicorn onesie and tells you that it has a gold horn, so you immediately warn them to be careful of hemalurgic spikes. When you begin wondering if you hemalurgically spiked a horse in the cosmere through the head could you create a unicorn? If anybody knows please let me know. Also, on your starwars topic, the original lightsaber's where just CGI surrounding sticks (at least that is what I have heard). And do you know what that means? It means that the stick Shallan failed to soulcast was also Luke's lightsaber, among other things.

I mean, there is no rule about how specific. You could pick an entire planet, or, say the safe where Shallan had kept pattern in.

Kaise.

Whitesands: Steelheart: Firefight: Calamity: Rithmatist:

Hmm... saying the character is noble blooded makes me think mistborn over all the other books with nobles... Breeze.

Roshone's Manor.

Yes. No rule against it, although personally I doubt they would repick somebody from a recent round. (By guessed I assume you mean a character who was previously picked. Either way, same answer) Shauka-daughter-Hasweth

I agree. I do think that Lift and Lopen are bit to unserious, especially in comparison with some of the other characters in the Stormlight Archives, and I feel that they aren't necessary or needed as comic relief because we already get that from characters like Pattern and Wit, where it fits significantly better. To be fair though, I only realize this when I am looking back on the books and actually thinking about it. Lift and Lopen are still some of my favorite characters despite this, and I really enjoy reading about them. Adolin annoys me. I don't really know why, but he does. Maybe it is a combination of him just seeming to be too perfect, and honestly more there to support Shallan then anything else. I just find Adolin really hard to relate to I guess. I am not a fan of Mistborn Era 2 or Warbreaker overall, and those are easily my least favorite cosmere books. For MB Era 2 I think it might be more the setting that bothers me. Personally I dislike most industrial settings that don't have totally modern technology, not really sure why, just not my type of books. For Warbreaker, I think the reason why I didn't like it is because it was harder to get attached to the character, such as Lightsong. In Mistborn you had a full 3 books to get attached to Vin and Elend and Sazed and Spook, but in Warbreaker you only had 1, and I don't feel that it was enough to communicate who the characters were, and so it was difficulty to get attached. I do feel that characters such as Vivenna and Vasher's future in the cosmere could be much more interesting. I am actually kinda happy that Brandon has not yet published Dragonsteel, because I feel that if he feels it isn't ready, then it probably isn't ready, and that it would be a lot worse to get a poorly written book with a poor plot to set off the beginning of the cosmere than to wait a while and get a really good one.

Most controversial cosmere thought: Reckoners is cosmere.

Dilaf