-
Posts
664 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Necessary Eagle
-
Stormlight 4 2020 Release Date Confirmed
Necessary Eagle replied to Isaiah Zayth's topic in Stormlight Archive
I think Brandon could hear me screaming all the way in Utah. -
Guessing Stormlight Book 5 title
Necessary Eagle replied to KandraAllomancer's topic in Stormlight Archive
Knights of Wit: Hoid forms the eleventh Radiant order. -
I mean, there's a bunch of 'em, but I'm rather sleep-deprived from staying up too late reading Starsight, so I can only remember a few at the moment: -Why do the delvers hate AI? There's nothing cytonic about robots... is there? -Why do humans have a special connection to delvers? -Why does Spensa hear stars, but Jorgen hears slugs? -Is the delver problem, like, solved now that Spin talked to one? Or is it just that one delver that decided to stop killing? Are there individual delvers, or are they a hivemind? Are there delver politics Spin is going to have to deal with next book? -Is it true that all those rubber-forehead aliens are descended from humans, and if so what does that imply about early human cytonics? -Does advanced Cytonics by itself really bring delvers, or is that a misunderstanding/oversimplification/Superiority propaganda?
-
My reaction, circa 5 PM: Starsight is here!? If I start now, will I finish by Reasonable O'clock? ...probably. Maybe. Who cares, I'm diving in. My reaction, circa 11 PM: er, eleven is semi-reasonable? In that it's not yet officially Tuesday? (But seriously: Wow)
-
Was the OA emissary a kandra?
Necessary Eagle replied to Necessary Eagle's topic in Cosmere Discussion
I don't think Listeners can pass as plausIbly human.- 16 replies
-
1
-
- sixth of the dusk
- kandra
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
The death of the OA emissary has always bothered me. Dusk and Vathi figure out that the machine is a trap, that they were meant to find it. Which means the emmisary's death wasn't an accident, either. The Ones Above must have somehow arranged for him to die. But how would that work? 1. The emmisary knew he was going to die. Which would raise the huge question of what about their mission he found worth choking himself for. I'm having a hard time imagining someone martyr himself for other people's profits. 2. My phone is a complete chull that keeps deleting the detailed paragraphs I've been laboriously tapping out, forcing me to sum things up abruptly instead of making eloquent arguments. 3. The Ones Above are a bunch of cold bastards who killed off a redshirt because they figured it would be easier to get away with one murder than wholesale violation of the Prime Directive. 4. Phone = storming rusting colorless deathant chull that tries to evade responsibility by autocorrecting to "chill" . 5. The emissary faked his death. Abruptly summed-up version: faking the dead when there's a bunch of people who will be desperately trying to revive you is difficult*. It's also risky because you have to survive whatever the local burial customs might be. Also they might try to cover up their theft by dumping your body overboard and swearing you fell or something. I mean, sure, they have sufficiently advanced magic for space travel, they can probably rig up something. But we know that kandra definitely are good at playing corpse. And it's widely thought that the OA are from Scadrial- which, coincidence coincidence, is where kandra are from. I'm going to cut myself off here before the Chull Phone strikes again, but what do you think? *I mean, I'm assuming. A bunch of godlike Space Dudes with the power to do Patji-knows-what if they're pissed send you an emissary, you'd probably be doing your best to send the guy back in one piece.
- 16 replies
-
5
-
- sixth of the dusk
- kandra
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Drifter begs to differ.
-
ThIngs you're disappointed you won't see in SA 4
Necessary Eagle replied to Necessary Eagle's topic in Stormlight Archive
If it helps any, there's a fic on AO3 where Adolin bonds him as a spren.- 19 replies
-
1
-
- rhythm of war
- timeskip
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
I didn't scream out loud, but my internal dialogue was definitely all-caps there.
-
i feel like there's a lot of loose ends we're not going to see wrapped up because of the one year gap. Sure, we'll have the aftermath, and they might be summed up in a memory or dialogue, but it's not the same as being there as it happens. Seeing the expressions on their faces, so to speak. The thing reaction shots I was really looking forward to seeing was what happens after Jasnah finds Ash and Taln. What Ash's reaction to waking up in (I assumeh) Urithiru is. What Jasnah has to say to her. How Jasnah breaks the news to Dalinar & co that she has two Heralds in custody, would they like to interview them? (Would they recognize them? Some of them saw Ash and Taln during the battle, but it was pretty busy and there was evil mood lighting).
- 19 replies
-
2
-
- rhythm of war
- timeskip
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
*happy dance*
-
I stand corrected, then.
-
It's a WoB.
-
What happens between book III and book IV?
Necessary Eagle replied to Oltux72's topic in Stormlight Archive
These are Skybreakers we're talking about. In terms of commitment to absolute justice, it might be a selling point. -
Why isn't the Stormfather red?
Necessary Eagle replied to Necessary Eagle's topic in Stormlight Archive
Nightblood isn't a shard, though. I think "corrupted" here probably means something a bit different from when Odium or Autonomy does it-- but who knows, I've certaInly been wrong before. -
Adolin reads his father's book... and has a bad several days. It turns out there's only so much you can suppress your emotions and pretend to be fine. Character study and action and drama, so there's something in here for everyone. Storms
-
1
-
- fic rec
- oathbringer
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Why isn't the Stormfather red?
Necessary Eagle replied to Necessary Eagle's topic in Stormlight Archive
It's a real WoB. Again, can't link on my phone, but it's from November 2017, look up "red" and "investiture" . -
Why isn't the Stormfather red?
Necessary Eagle replied to Necessary Eagle's topic in Stormlight Archive
What do you mean? I didn't link to a specific WoB yet (I can't copy links on my phone) -
Didn't Tanavast coopt the already extant Stormfather 1.0 as the top Honor spren, transforming him into Stormdaddy 2.0? That sounds like Brandon's definition of corrupted Investiture to me. (Also it's kind of hilarious that, with all the theorizing about the Unmade being preexisting spren that got Odium'd, the only Shards that we know for sure found powerful Adonalsium spren and remade them in their own image are Honor and Culti).
-
Might as well update this one while the thread's back up: OB pretty much confirms that Felt is a worshipper.
