phattemer
-
Posts
1032 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by phattemer
-
Wow. So that means there are a lot of keepers of tunnels, hm. Wilson, I think you might actually be right about only 1, possibly two priests/warriors. I didn't include those with items or keepers in my calculations.
-
...did I do something wrong?
-
Well, I would like to cement the vote on someone before the Cultists get all manipulaty in our faces. Feligon
-
wilson, Aonar is viewing it now
-
Winter, you can just google it. I will now: Eastern is two hours ahead of Mountain Wilson, here is my response to you: 1: I agree with Winter on lynching. Let's not worry about a mislynch of a priest/warrior because we've no doubt got multiple. What about those Elantrians? Was anyone else posting anything else then that I could reply to? No. By multiple, I meant two each. 2. I'm not sure that lynching a really experienced player is good, but I don't want to cast vote because I don't really know what I'm doing. Why would I just vote for a random person? I was making the point that lynching someone random is usually bad, and that maybe we should get some discussion first. 3. Let's talk about killing someone. Now can someone else suggest someone, because I don't want to. I had just read Kasimir's post, and agreed with him. I didn't want to suggest a random person, since that makes me sound like a Cultist, despite being a bit obvious. 4. Wilson's guess about my priest/warrior mislynch was right, but I'm not going to explain my reasons because I don't know if I can trust her. Oh, and Mckeedee might be a debtor. What do you mean your guess? I have a very good reason for thinking there are multiple, but yes, I can't tell you yet. Nobody else had said that, so why would I not. 5. I agree with Kas about lynching someone. Let's not worry about the Gyorn. Maybe the Converts should post the lists, but not yet, since that might ruin their strategy if they get picked as Odiv. My list of suspects is the predominant people who've been discussing things. I was reiterating my previous agreement. My next point was that the Gyorn is not as dangerous since we can easily tell who he is by who has not been converted near the end of the game. The Cultists should be our first target, since their kill both helps the Gyorn and harms the village. What, am I supposed to be naming people who HAVEN'T said anything? I listed reasons too, did you read those? 6. Mckeedee seems like he's trying to attract a Duke/Duchess to get rid of his debt. .... I didn't say that. I said that if they weren't a debtor, they sound like an Cultists/Gyorn because both would gain an advantage from a lynch. EDIT: 7: A debtor would admit that they were a debtor. Well, if people think they are that or a Cultist, yeah they would.
-
I mean that if they were a debtor I think they would have admitted it, and the other role with an incentive to lynch beyond that of a villager is the Cultists.
-
Well they seemed like a debtor since they acted to sort of force a vote, but then they denied it, and I don't really see why being a debtor is something you'd want to hide, unless they are hoping a duke/duchess will try to get them.
-
Well, Kasimir, my earlier post was actually agreeing with you in that we need to lynch someone- I mentioned the multiple priests/warriors because with 31 people, maybe 5-6 cultists, 1 shu-dereth, it seems likely to me that more than 9-10 people will have a role. Of course, that's not counting the Elantrians, since depending on the secrets they could have powers also, but in my opinion, there are probably 2-3 ChayShan Warriors, and 1-2 priests. About the Gyorn v. the Cultists- Right now, the Gyorn doesn't really seem to be a huge threat. If he makes a Cultist or a Warrior his Odiv, it gets worse, but I think we should probably be able to just keep him in mind and not worry too too much about him converting 30 other people. I also agree that the Converts should probably post when more people get converted, but they might not want to do that until an Odiv is chosen since they could be made the Odiv. Besides that, the only people that look kinda suspicious right now to me are: Wilson: little bit overreacting, seemed like they were shooting down ideas (though mainly just because she voted for me, most of what she said made sense) Kasimir: Your reasons for voting Orlok seemed contrived, but I can see why you did that Mckee: First second vote. You seem like a debtor, though you kinda denied it, but you could be just jumping on a lynchwagon Orlok: If Mckee seems suspicious, you automatically don't, which makes me think it's all a plot.
-
This was really good, are you planning to continue?
-
Wilson, I did indeed mean two(even so that's like a 10-15% chance), and I will have to explain later for many reasons, first of which is that I don't know if you're a citizen. My post was really just a stream of consciousness on how I was thinking about the game. I did that on purpose because I didn't want to just give conclusions without showing that I had considered both sides. Orlok, Mckee seems more like a Debtor to me.
-
Well that makes sense. So, does anyone have a target for discussion about killing them?
-
Why Meta? I appreciate you not being afraid to be the first one to vote, which immediately makes you a target, but killing a random experienced player doesn't really seem like a good idea. But then again, I don't want to lynch a new player either. I have no idea what I'm doing, do I.
-
Axies noticed a young misfit who wanted to join the game. Aha! Well, long game 12 just started, so I would suggest reading this: welp, this didn't work: http://www.17thshard.com/forum/topic/5627-sanderson-style-elimination-general-rules/sorry,but you can paste it. And signing up as a pinch hitter. A new quick fix and mid range will come up soon too.
-
Well, I guess I agree with winter in that we do kinda need to lynch someone. I think there are multiple priests/warriors, so we can't go terribly wrong. Does anyone else think that one of the current Elantrians is probably a cultist? They could not be, but it seems to make sense to me.
-
Axies nodded. "That corroborates with my experiences." He then tripped over his own feet and fell.
-
And it never would have happened if you hadn't lurched yourself. Dang it, I SO wish I hadn't told anyone. Could have had Feruchemical chromium... humph. And maybe even be Spiked. Stupid lurchers...
-
As Axies wandered down the streets of... nice try, he's not giving away his location THAT easily... as he wandered down the streets, a sign caught his eye. It read "The Knights Awkward. Inquisite(ors) within." He entered the building, moving as silently as he had at 6 AM the previous night. Books... before friends. Wait. Where had those words come from? They entered his mind, at first softly, then more insistently. "Books... before friends? That is wrong on sooooo many levels." Axies exclaimed. "First of all, wouldn't you have to have friends to put stuff before them? I mean, really. The words began to grow quieter, as if being driven away. "No! I didn't mean it! Come back! Books before friends. 17th shard before the real world. Release dates before birthdays. What could they mean? Books before friends... journey before destination..." Suddenly Axies realized what a fool he was being. "BOOKS BEFORE FRIENDS! 17TH SHARD BEFORE THE REAL WORLD! RELEASE DATES BEFORE BIRTHDAYS!" Then Axies realized that a crowd of people were standing in the room. Yup, he'd made a fool of himself again. This time, however, would be different. He turned back toward them, strengthened his nerve, and entered the crowd. "I am Axies, also known as Seixa, also known as Sienene! I will read all Brandon, even if it is not Cosmere! I will... I will..." Axies stopped, awkwardly. He couldn't tel what the next words should be. "I will go sit down now..."
-
Well, now that I can post, yay! Unfortunately I decided to tell Winter everything, which wouldn't normally be so bad... but she was spiked. At least I told luckat too, and my scan got a Spiked lynched. Yay! https://imgflip.com/i/lvway (SANDERSON MEME MODE) *except I always do, so far
-
https://imgflip.com/i/lvvtx
-
https://imgflip.com/i/lvv1r https://imgflip.com/i/lvva5 https://imgflip.com/i/lvvff https://imgflip.com/i/lvvgk https://imgflip.com/i/lvvi5 https://imgflip.com/i/lvviz https://imgflip.com/i/lvvkr https://imgflip.com/i/lvvly https://imgflip.com/i/lvvn9 (yes I know they are included in definition. it would not be funny that way.) Can someone explain how I post full pictures? It says I can't use that extension on this community.
-
I'd also like to be put on the midrange and quickfix gm lists. -
I was just reading Brandon's AMA over at r/books from 2 months ago. It was pretty far down so I don't know if others saw... But both Herdazians and Horneaters are the result of human-listener interbreeding. :/ So, apparently they had been 'discovered' long ago, not to mention that relations were probably quite quite good. So Rock+Rlain=fam forever.
-
An Abundance of Doctors
phattemer replied to Wonko the Sane's topic in Social Groups, Clans, & Guilds
What?! A doctor not wanting more power?! This is an outrage! -
As Seixa... wait, no... Axies... wait this was Sel, wasn't it? As Sienene walked down the street, he noticed a mob of people trying to get into the palace. He recalled seeing some poster... wasn't today the the day the Patriarch was supposed to be here. Axies, no, Sienene had never been a religious man, but nevertheless, his step quickened as he *jumped* over the onlookers and through a window. He entered the main room of the court, only to fall back in shock. He'd recently had a bad experience in some caves, and he recognized some of the people from there. Then he saw something that made him instinctively duck behind a pillar. Was that an Inquisitor!? Sienene cautiously peeked out. "What... he is supposed to be dead. Long ago." Edit: hero, can an elantrian become a veteran and how?
-
An Abundance of Doctors
phattemer replied to Wonko the Sane's topic in Social Groups, Clans, & Guilds
Welcome, esteemed colleague. If you haven't seen the rules and tips yet, some of them are on the original post, and the unofficially sanctioned ones are scattered among the middle pages. Axies is extremely glad you are here, because he needs to inquire about some of the more unorthodox uses for bamboo. Does it really grow fast enough for the nonaforementioned purpose?
