Mat
-
Posts
7773 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
10
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Mat
-
My goodness, people. That was by far the longest QF cycle I've ever seen. It's actually longer than a lot of MR and LG ones as well. 1. Thanks for not killing me 2. Thanks for not killing Dannex or Liranil 3. Reading? I mean, sure... I bet there's probably one more Yellow, btw. Condensation, I'm betting WGG. Tentatively. It'd mean an elim Warder and they could protect once without taking a hit. Mixing with the light Connie suspicion last cycle and I really don't see any other reason Connie would have been attacked. Edit: @TJ Shade, if an Aes Sedai (or Warder) dies, is any information regarding their bond revealed?
-
I won't be on again. Try not to kill either Dannex or Liranil Please don't kill me Liranil Thanks and bye
-
There's always protects. But yes. Edit: @James Brafin Lemme get this straight Liranil claims a role and you don't believe them, voting on them for it Dannex claims a role and you're adamant about getting people to switch off them. I see no difference between the two.
-
@Ashbringer @Liranil @Shard of Reading @Condensation Edit: Liranil I'm not kidding when I say move your kill off me Alternatively, Yellows, protect? Me? ?
-
100% gut on their posts. No reasoning, but I don't want Liranil dead after the claim and don't want Dannex dead either. ...Ninja'd by Illwei saying literally exactly the same thing.
-
Liranil Lotus The claim might be fake (though I doubt it) but I'd rather investigate that later. @Liranil, please don't kill me It wouldn't be good for anyone. Except the elims. I'm in school and shouldn't even be online. Likely last post of the cycle.
-
Less adamant than what Dannex said, but in this post: You say you wish there was an option other than Dannex You say Liranil is next in line Liranil is nearly tied in the exe You don't switch your vote Why? Seconded about Burnt, though
-
Yes, more people switch to Liranil I mean, that is the weaker point of the two (and one that's not my own, and one I'm probably remembering differently from when it was made). Edit: I likely won't be on until after rollover, though to be completely honest I don't know exactly when it is
-
Hmmmmmm worth mentioning a bad gut on Lotus. Especially after her latest post.
-
And here I was thinking I had 4 actual pages to catch up with, cool. Reasoning for this vote: An echoing of Illwei saying how Liranil was more free with votes before (and something else, slipping my mind :P) coupled additionally with the vote on Dannex. I no longer think Dannex is a good idea. It caught up to speed with no resistance far too quickly for my liking. Saying this after I ranted about how I hated people leaping onto my trains super quickly xD Why? For that matter, why'd you vote Liranil in the first place? Do you have reasoning for that? I'm curious. Same... I agree here. Here's the thing: Earlier, you claimed that you didn't have PMs. Meaning that if you even have a role (which I find likely because if you are vanilla what is the point of this), it's an Ajah without a Warder. Chances are, based purely on my thoughts on distribution, most Aes Sedai will have Warders and most people will be one of the two. So in my eyes, it's actually more likely for Liranil to be a powerful role assuming you weren't lying before; an Aes Sedai with a Warder is more powerful than one without because they can be protected. 1. I buy that, role analysis is something you've done before in all three alignments. 2. Perhaps labeling it as making 'absolutely perfect sense' is a bit... strong, but I do see what you're saying. I'd still rather just wait until someone flips vanilla for the concrete evidence. As James said earlier, in a game this size not having any Vanilla doesn't make sense. So I'm fully expecting there to be some and don't think we need a claim to assume that. But you're village for pushing this so hard through the suspicion, imo. 3. This is something I just completely disagree with but I don't find it AI for you, honestly. You come up with convoluted plans either way and this could come from either side. 4. Agreed. Thanks for explaining. Overall I agree with Illwei's assessment that Dannex is a bad idea right now. @Ashbringer, your vote makes me extremely nervous. I always vil read you though so this could be a change. @Shard of Reading, @Condensation, what say ye about ^that? ;-; it'd help if you put it into words as opposed to blaming it on the 12 pages ;-; then maybe I could explain ;-; Oooooh that's a fun point. We'll see where this goes, interesting.
-
Connie Liranil Reasoning + Other responses in the morning. Good night.
-
hey in my defense I was only half following along a 750+ page game and the fake mod confirmed role confused me. I wasn't really paying attention until Eevee died anyway. But that's not important lol 999 posts make the next one a good one -ninjad -I didn't expect anything else tbh Disagree on these two, though it's an interesting point on Liranil.
-
Controversial was the wrong word. I just didn't want to insult anyone. I don't want to disregard anyone's playstyle and certainly don't want to discourage seriousness. But If someone is being read as doing 'x for y reason' and that would make sense on a site where everyone has a better idea of strategies, that's opposed to here where that isn't the case. Again not trying to be rude or anything... Nothing please xD Heyyyyy Lahilt's viewing the thread! I remember you!!!!
-
You can be one? Because it'd be your alignment? ?
-
I think people naturally assume PMs because most games played here have them. Additionally people typically read the rules on the first day of signups and not again, unfortunately, so it's easy for things to slip the mind. Interesting I end up defending Dannex here. Devil's Advocate, hmm? I think assuming a bus here is a quick assumption. I doubt that Connie is bussing Dannex. Rather a lot :P. Sorry Illwei, you ninja'd me. So reply I will :P. This next part is probably going to be controversial. And hopefully not rude. Apologies in advance if it comes across that way, I make no intention of insulting anyone Whoof. How do I say this. In all seriousness: Other mafia sites are, well, entirely dedicated to mafia. The people go to the sites solely for that purpose. Here, it is but a feature. As a result, there is a larger margin of people- myself included- who came to this site because they love the Cosmere, floated around for awhile in GenDis, then looked at SE and said 'That looks fun! I'll try it out.' and don't really have a good idea of epic strategies or how to accurately read people or how to weave together a genius bus/vote pattern and whatnot. Someone said earlier that it's way more casual than other sites, and having read through other sites' games I definitely feel that. What's the point of saying that? Good question. I guess it's a general 'hey people who are really good at this' and maybe a filler up on the meta. You can mostly ignore this. I'm not good at words...
-
(If it isn't too much trouble, could you link the posts when you mention the numbers? For the... probably everyone else that doesn't keep track counting to number 89 is less desirable Thanks) Note that I agree with your Dannex read for the most part. However Illwei has a point about his playstyle, so the aggressiveness/etc is to some extent NAI, I think. There is a line to be crossed, though.
-
May I ask a few terminology things? And I'm assuming the numbers (16, 46) are in reference to the 16th post in the thread, and 46th. Correct?
-
...White text? I mean I do sometimes... I did in that FFA game... No, that's just you. But I'll remember that for future planning Also maybe this is just my GM empathy but maybe halt the OOG conversation? For TJ's sake :).
-
Maddy hesitantly put a hand out in front of Colonel. "I agree that the crime is real, but this man seems to be sincere. He likely should be taken into custody, but to do so calmly is what I think is appropriate for one of your rank. Sir."
-
No, it's hilarious
-
-
You sneaky time traveler
-
Happy birthday!!!!
(Tomorrow!!!)
-
"Uh, no." Maddy said. "I didn't expect to have to cuff anyone."
-
No :P. Also entirely unrelated but I tried to browse Mafiascum and my computer doesn't want to let me on the site, or the site doesn't, or something.
