mathiau

Note that Kel's medalions technologies can be used to allow people to use Sel's magic offworld It's almost certain you cannot worldhop for Scadrial to Sel but have to hop to Roshar/the Expanse of Vibrance (or of the Broken Sky if it's not Taldain and you're mad) I don't remember these cuts being deep enough to leave scars Note that Shai could become a Lightweaver, althoug she'd ne more likely to become an Edgedancer. She'd also make a good foil to Mraize, being far nicer I think she'd make sens in Khriss's organisation, but we really don't know much about them Shai will probably be a side-character in Elantris 2 so yeah, these two story are quite close. Elantris happened centuries before Era 1

Vax is a place actually, the character is Wax

1000 breaths is enough to create sapient things, if broams could hold that much stormlight the stormlight inside the king's drop would have become a spren long ago

Permission to steal that to update the OP? I don't think Honour and Cultivation were the one chosen to take care of Unite and Change, Change almost certainly came to Roshar after Ashyn's destruction since Horneaters have story of it and we know Odium's human had one on Ashyn which probably was Unite since Ishar was already known as the Binder of Gods by that time. I think Change was given to Invention but at some point he decided to stop contact with the other Shards and sent his Dawnshard to Cultivation. For Unite I think it was given to Devotion and taking it from her was one of the reason Odium decided to take a stop to Sel while searching of Ambition, along with Devotion being the Shard the closest to being Odium's opposite.

It's probably the Survivor, Ladashwy shouldn't have the power to free her and he asked me what I'd do in that situation earlier. She marked a pause. If you start needing to take control of her because someone broke mine this then whole deal isn't actually useful for you

For a small chapter with Renarin's Sharblade, see chapter 10, in Adolin's part near the end I don't think Renarin has a plate yet Official art from the WoK leatherbound kickstarter Renarin has a (significantly more yellow) Shardplate in it. In universe he doesn't have one yet but I doubt Brandon would have let them print this if Voidbinders couldn't have plates

I never said Gavilar was a Radiant.

That part is factually wrong, a any bound between a physical being and a spren-like being is a Nahel bound and they can be form before the words are spoken Also about Galivar

Depends, at the start of WoK is Kal bounded to Syl or not?

If we go that way there's no way to explain Yelig-Nar

It's more "was bounding" than "was bonded" but yes, he was. Also no double posts

This is a better argument for the existence of the Create and Destroy Dawnshard than I've seen even in the topics actually discussing about what the remaining Dawnshards could be If we're assuming the Dawnshards are Create/Survive-Remake-Destroy-Unite then the odd one is Unite, the only one applying only to sapien beings If we're not then I guess it'll be Hoid's one since it comes with a Topaz Your other theory suggest that every Dawnshard give microkinesis, wouldn't that mean Cohesion s related to all Dawnshard and not just Unite? And Edgedancer for hypothesized Survive I assume? It could work It's Roshar, things not being symetric is an actual argument Rosharans seems to be far more fond of vertical symetrie, but you've got both here Note that I'd be the first time (to my knowledge) we have something horizontaly symetric on Rohsar that's not both veritically and centrally symetric. We have a few thing just centrally symetric (the Voids, Taravangian's chapter picture) and a lot of verticaly symetric things, but very few horizontaly symetric things.

I think these two things are unrelated. Vin is unchained in a moar power way while Ishar is unchained on a far more fundamental level

I don't see why RoW changes anything

Fair. Still, paying people with a money they cannot use would be like not paying them so there's no moral point in paying the Parshmen

Powers Renarin has shown : Summoning light with a Malatium like temporal side effect (=Void of Illumination) Healing with a Perfected self temporal side effect (=Void of Progression) Visions (could be a second effect of the Void of Illumination, a second effect of the Void of Progression (note that the Surge of Progression is actually two very different powers) or an hybrid Void) No need for him Surge binding, he's just Voidbinding

I meant that money stored by workers always end up being used sooner or latter, with latter being at the longest of a few decades, not millennia like with Parshemen

They factually are

Because for them it's sure they're not 90%+ Honour If Mistsrens are more of Cutivation than of Honour then not every sprens are 50% Honour No clue

If it was that simple you wouldn't need to change the frequency of tie Rhythm to fuse Stormlight and Voidlight Isn't that contradictory to you're previous idea? There are perfectly stable mesons just as there are perfectly unstable baryons, and most of the time the reason they're unstable is because their quarks are unstable, not because they're matter-antimatter compounds It's not. I'd way to see Cryptics or Mistsprens die before coming to that conclusion Brandon comfirmed Mistsprens were more Cultivation than Honour so they're wrong about that point. Also Spren most of Honour doesn't mean order most of Honour though it's similar Godmetals don't exactly follow the same rules as the rest That's because Atium's Rhythm is relatively close to gold's one, for RAFO reasons. Also I doubt Atium's Rhythm will be exactly like Ruin's one, similar of course, but not identical We no Autonomy was involved in some way, might be that Stoneshaping actually. Not that it changes anything to your point

Nightblood is not a Spren so no

It's not that worse than a lot of other thing people did and don't seem to regrets that much, like having human slaves

Which has been theorised to be the Void Sja uses to Enlighten Sprens. It would be quite funny if it allowed Shallan to transform Sja into a Spren of Honour/Cultivation Also, I think Brandon talked about another type of spren than Mistsprens that could be convinced to be Enlightened and I can't remember if it was Cryptics or Reachers, does someone remember I'm 99% certain Renarin has both Voids

Not much sadly. Hoid used to hold at least one that's related to the gem he mentioned to Kal. Him being immortal and unable to physically hurt people is a result of him holding a Dawnshard for a long time, the immortality part is common to every Dawnshards, no confirmation whether the non-violent part is specific to one of them. One of the Shards is different from the other The Dawncities where made using a Dawnshard. I want to say Change+Stoneshaping but I'm not sure whether the Dawncities predates Ashyn's destruction while it's almost certain Change arriving to Roshar happened after. There's a "Dawnshard known to bind any creature voidish or mortal" mentioned in The Poem of Ista which itself was mentioned in Jasnah's notes. This one is most likely still on Roshar

It has actually been explored before And "does Adhesion exists" would be among the first thing to test. I'm a bit confused here, in the group of four thread you seemed to agree with my assessment that Odium was an aspect of Unite We've seen Odium divisive because he's using divide and conquer, Dominon would do the same if they thought it would be useful