Amethyst Scorpion

We did, technically. More than happy to call it a draw (or a loss :p) given the circumstances though.

You were findable, I was just confident enough in my early read that I didn’t look. As Mouse might say… not reevaluating was a mistake :P.

Your exe tilted me in this game more than anything else I won’t even lie >>

I took notes on why it was so bad

I haven’t taken notes during games for years 

But anyway  

This game is certainly one of the games I have played

I probably will lightly o7 from here on out but it’s not actually related to my ridiculously confident Beagle read lol. Probably more on that in the identity revealed thread. Not like my identity is hidden that much though :D.

Penguin MVP, was obv vil from D1 <3. But Beagle real MVP, was also obv vil from D1  Completely deserves to win this

I had a hard few first cycles and a hard few last cycles but thoroughly enjoyed the middle. Twas a fun game all around.

Well yeah I dunno. Also trying to stoke IKYKs a bit.

Losing to e!Beagle after locking them v harder than anyone I’ve ever locked v before by being misexed in the deciding exe of the game would be a fitting end to my SE career 

Not going to case anyone. Because I don’t know. Something something about Beagle’s effort being e indicative something something but mostly it’s just me and three of my strongest village reads left alive so I don’t know. I can repeat why e me never ever plays as I’ve played but when the same can be said of everyone here that will fall flat.

The problem here is that battle lines are drawn. Penguin prefers e Beagle to e me and Cham prefers the opposite. So e Beagle knows exactly who to kill to win and e Penguin probably wins anyway.

9 hours ago, Oxblood Beagle said:

 

And then there’s this from D4:

Elephant takes precedence over Alb in their ordered PoE for ?? reasons, despite the fact that Alb had put out actively elimmy content whereas Elephant had been supremely inactive. I don’t recall Scorp ever sharing what made Alb more village over Elephant at any point in the game, so this is really odd in hindsight. Not just that, but in the same post they don’t vote either of these two but instead vote Iguana? For science? It doesn’t add up. 

Explaining my vulture progression and explaining why that misinterprets basically my entire turn would take too much effort to bother with but this is easy, you’re completely ignoring that I made that list before casing Alb or looking at any of his posts. At the time I was going purely off vibes, of which Ele’s were worse. After they died I took an actual look at Alb. Plus, half of their case was the response to Ostrich which hadn’t happened when I made that list.

I didn’t quote the part you randomly bolded but I don’t see why e!Alb isn’t frozen just because… their teammate is up for the exe…? Like? Is that question not already answered?

With how fluid the votes were and based on my understanding of the trains at the time, basically calling my Vulture vote useless is simply wrong. In my mind, at least, I was solidifying that option over all others. My vote was on the side train before that. I swung it past the point of no return.

I wish I could show my Zebra PM where I death pushed the Vulture shot. Or actually I wish I could show my Vulture PM lol

Oh yeah and the for science was obviously a joke used to excuse my indulgence of my ig paranoia

bad case obv elim /jk

NO MERGE

one day I’ll understand

edit: oh thanks mods

We could lose to a coin flip or e Cham but that’s it

Nah no way

actually no way >>

NK should be indicative at the very least?

2 hours ago, Sage Kangaroo said:

You're one of the top trusts along with Cham, why on Earth would e!me push for you over Penguin, a known Smoker?

Because Lion handed you an e!me case on a silver platter at the end of last turn and honestly, I don't think anyone was seriously entertaining e!Penguin. That was pretty obvious. In my mind we're on equal footing.

Kangaroo

Edit:

I did ISO Kangaroo. Their early posting is extremely paired with Vulture and Albatross. Especially Albatross, they treated them as textbook bussing material, village reading them until it was popular opinion to not (and even then being properly wishy-washy). Could write more of a case but that'd be a waste of everyone's time.

4v1, 2v1 if we get this wrong which will probably be Cham/Penguin/me because I've jumped in people's PoE. Granted I think the reason I've jumped is because Kangaroo is framing me but this world assumes I'm wrong about that. So I actually don't think it's possible to lose this unless Beagle is evil. That's contrary to the previous math I did in the e!Penguin world and I don't know what changed there. Maybe I'm just bad at math.

11 hours ago, Sage Kangaroo said:

I don't know what either of those two mean. I'm just saying don't condemn me for being the player who as spoken the least among those of us alive. Don't park a vote on me and just doze off for the rest of the cycle. Go through my posts. Go through other players' post. Don't waste these two days because you WILL need to solve [Scorpion, Beagle, Penguin] after I die. 

I'll start off with hunch that Lion was as much killed for their last cycle case on Scorp or perhaps even more so because of it, rather than them being a Seeker

I don’t think anyone has said that about you at any point. It’s PoE and other people are more trustworthy. But I’ll humor you and do an ISO later.

Really? Cause that’d be pretty stinking obvious, don’t you think?  I’ll reiterate:

—e!me never spends the whole turn blatantly refusing to vote Vulture only to undermine that all by solidifying their train at EoD

—e!me never death pushes for Zebra to shoot Vulture

—e!me never death pushes Albatross for two straight cycles over the multitude of other available options 

You say all that like you protested against literally any of it

Penguin is the worst out of all of them.

I have friends that are going to mean girls tomorrow

Okay. We’re looking for a Smoker. That means PoE is Kanga/Penguin/Beagle. Elim has to be in there. Yes, I’m willing to stop vil tunneling Beagle. No, I don’t want to kill them tomorrow.

I could v case everyone there. I could e case everyone there. I have no idea where the hit is.

I think I start on Penguin out of those but I want other thoughts 

Someone tell me that there isn’t a way for a Soother to make the VC look like the way it did that one turn

We are so losing this game lol

3 minutes ago, Chartreuse Penguin said:

Not sure what E!me gets out of lying about Smoking Meerkat, unless I'm teamed with Kangaroo somehow. But I don't know what's going on this game anyway.

That's kinda the problem. There's no reason you smoke a random villager because as far as you know Swan is a real smoker, and even then.

So I'm staying on Meerkat and just hoping it ends

Idk I kinda assumed there was a reason to vote away from the mechanically implicated person :P.

Like, sure, the purity clear for Meerkat is... kinda real. Even this turn. Is that just me? I understand the desire to not vote Meerkat. But the immediate next option in that case is Penguin, not Kangaroo. Something has to explain the missing vote.

Ok I'll bite

Why?

1 hour ago, Salmon Meerkat said:

Vanilla? I swear ive said this before. 

Swan's riot failed when they targeted you.

22 minutes ago, Salmon Meerkat said:

Penguin

What is your role

Meerkat

@Salmon Meerkat what are you really

Also, unless there are two elims, Croc is clear.

Last elim surely is just in [Swan, Meerkat, Kanga, Croc]. I just looked through D4 for edge cases but just found that Beagle pushed Alb over Penguin (I am assuming v!Penguin here, they’d be next in the PoE) and Alb pushed Lion. We already had this PoE, of course, but it’s nice that a check confirmed it I guess :P.

Later I’ll do the math to figure out if we can lose to e!Penguin here but I don’t think so.

Edit:

It's a 9v1 now. If e!Penguin--

• ZNK Swan, NK Zebra (7v1)
• Exe Meerkat, NK me (5v1)
• Exe Croc, NK Beagle (3v1)
• Exe Kanga, NK Lion (1v1)
• Coinflip (because if Cham loses the exe they get NKd)

So short answer is actually yes, but I just realized this is all probably meaningless because we know either Swan or Meerkat is lying so the logic follows that one of them is evil.

I guess Swan could be a MB, I dunno. But yeah Lion why didn’t you soothe them :P.

If Swan is a rioter they’re village. No way the elims got two.

Shoot croc? :P.