Archer
-
Posts
3779 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
9
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Archer
-
huh
-
I'm an idiot, he's got to be a Threadmaster Steel Sart
-
The big upside of voting Sart is that Orlok's scan is pointed at Steel. If Orlok doesn't return and change it, it's a waste if we exe him. I don't really see any reason Sart would be village except maybe the ??? of it all
-
Technically he hasn't posted since then, so this would be the first time he could announce the result. No wait, he was on D4 and the result would have had to have been received after D3. There's no way Sart removes their vote EoD D4 if they knew Bip was evil. Sart Steeldancer
-
Yeah but that was a love shove. He didn't mean it I did receive information! Hm Tallybot is gonna hate you for that Bad something better to do, maybe, in a tight action economy world? Or just that's what they wanted us to see But going through the tie guy results POE from your crack at it would hit the nail for firmly on the head, I think Future thing to think about is whether an elim has double Night actions and can submit a kill with one of them. Helps to avoid mass claiming of actions leading to clears This reads as stalling to me on Orlock's part. It moves the exe to either save e!Steel, delay the need to bus him, or allow him to claim he got a green result. Or just claim a convenient RB.
-
That's what I was an referring to and it's weird that Silh didn't mention it. I'm side eyeing you for backing off e!Steel here since they got scanned evil
-
Hi I'm counting on y'all to figure out the action interactions so someone tell me when that's sorted out, please and thanks. Do we know why they didn't just RB Randby, would that have done anything? I don't see e!Sart and e!Steel together since the elims benefit from the tie if they can make up the results. Similar situation with e!Silh. Which now that I think about it implies v!Steel, redscan aside. Interesting consequence of this game is they're bound to gun entirely for role based kills. Discussion Leader (the role) is a more manageable threat via murder than Discussion Leader (the characteristic). It's rather refreshing. Hey what's he ever done to you :P. Everytime I open Reddit it asks if I want to translate the site from German. I think because Reddit looks like a German word
-
That is a fascinating result because it indicates that we can retroactively check claims. We should take advantage of that N7. You getting the actual action reveals their role too. You're not assuming her action right, that's specifically what was said to you? Anything with Drake kind of works for me because it gives a logical reason for the Tani claim. Why not Steel?
-
Did you get a PM Spider result about a previous round, or is that repetition of previous results? You should save that for exlo. It makes a hammer harder to do because it eliminates the allure of side trains and prevents an exe on the GMs. This is a very bold take about someone scanned elim. Really they only had to mess with three players, since Araris removed himself from the chain. We can't reasonably expect that all four players were messed up, but three and Araris wasn't targeted but lucky for them it didn't matter, seems more believable. I'm looking at e!Araris from that. There's four PM Spiders, so 1/4 being evil would fit with general distribution trends. But I'm hesitant to do distro speculation like that because of the possibility of unclaimed Spiders, an elim PM spying role, or just GM Trolling. I wouldn't say it's necessary because an elim getting to PM 3 or so people over the course of the game isn't super helpful. That said, e!JNV fits really nicely Correct! Steeldancer Sart
-
Ok I had to try teaching ChatGPT to play forum mafia. It's 1am now but this is for science TL;DR It's a little simplistic, but I gave it very little info to comment on. With a little work, ChatGPT could play in a game. But it's prone to oversharing, so it needs an editor to remove its meta commentary and occasional admissions to being evil. I'm all for Sart based on the assumption that at least one of the two messing around at EoD were evil, but I don't share you confidence in v!Silh. I don't see e!Ash (with accurate roleclaim or even with Thug) and e!Drake on the same team, so I can't make the 2nd Tie Guy results work without e!Silh, unless e!Bip slots in as the second elim.
-
Alright but what if his role is just that he gets written up as a survival when he's exed. Technically, we'd be hard pressed to tell the difference between a Zombie and a living dude with no active actions
-
Stop @ing me, it's my Night off :P. PM Spider can learn alignments. Also, I see Drake shot at me. Rood. I wasn't notified though. And are we 100% sure Ash isn't dead?
-
I wonder if vet has a relationship to Araris' mystery added vote. I'd rather take Ash out of the tie because then e!Silh is more incentivized to act. The elims can afford to do nothing to a e!ThugAsh-v!X matchup. I'm cool sitting this one out. I understand the reasoning. Biplet
-
How do you differentiate between Thug Ash tanking the exe and Thread Master Ash, unless you exe them twice, which isn't viable?
-
If JNV doesn't have a quokka role I'll be very disappointed Personally, I think Walin was evil. And maybe Dannex. The challenge of going outside of the pool is that it is technically an unknown number of elims. But the odds are better if you're pessimistic, so Biplet seems to make sense of the three. Steel I still want to know why Tani claimed. There had to have been a reason. There was an upside. I regret going for it now, but I can't undo it. That seems like an RPer task. I suspect they'll turn up Thug trying to get ahead of being in the suspect pool today.
-
Mechanically accusing someone but refusing to divulge their identity isn't very cash money of you Counterpoint: I've done a terrible job of using my PM :P. Also, am I supposed to be covering for TJ when Tani could have submitted the kill so he wouldn't have to?
-
Fun fact, you can never tell if you were trolled by scanning yourself by those rules That's Araris. He just seems to attract a vote every round out of respect
-
I forgot to mention, that's not an alignment indicative role to have. Can you turn a zombie's no vote into a vote, because wasting Tani's wouldn't be a bad idea. To satisfy my curiosity about who the UPS is, I'd like everyone to attempt a left-hand turn, please and thanks >:) Do you scan whether someone was trolled or that someone is a troll/ing? inb4 that's all that the role does
-
He has one with me. And no, it was D2 because he'd indicated a preference for scanning the alignment scanner, which made more sense TJ didn't receive a GM PM and is really just a spectator
-
It would have worked then, but that ship has since sailed. I guess there's no reason to be clandestine about it in this situation so here's the highlights What You Don't Know -Day action to activate, the flavor being that I declare I have not read the rules -I get a bubble of ignorance that gives me invincibility to some actions -The GMs have very deliberately PAFOed questions about this role but not my other one, which I believe is confirmation that they are Trolls. :P. Also because I've since discovered that it can't be turned off. I had a theory that roleblocking could but it appears not -Interestingly, I don't get told if people target me. Or at least I didn't yesterday
-
>.> Wiz is a snitch On the subject of TJ's action, I fully believe it because I am a limited Smoker. A lot of actions won't work against me - including alignment scans, unfortunately. I highly doubt that anyone else has this role, but on the off chance someone wants to also claim it, I'll just say that the flavor has to do with reading the rules. I also agree with Mat that Drake deciding to stop killing right about the time our suspect pool got really small is a bad look. Realistically I don't want to exe them, but I'd appreciate an alignment scan on them if possible. As for Ashbringer, my money's on they're a Thug going for broke. They're on my potential exe list. I'd rather do Steel over Biplet. Silh also needs to die eventually.
-
On a related note, I've caught myself falling into the rut of relying on scans to solve this game and subsequently getting lazy with my analysis. I know people like to take Nights off to decompress, so I propose we set aside some time next Day just for non mech analysis. Can everyone get some reads together for say after the initial post-rollover results sharing time and the midway point of next Day (Sunday, essentially)? That still leaves time for strategic considerations to be brought up afterwards.
-
Ya know, I don't feel like getting in touch with you has been a problem so far :P. To clarify, the Spider must be in the 1 on 1 PM they make You have my blessing I honestly won't keep up with a PM you make with me, so maybe go for Wiz instead
-
See I was leaning more elim on them. I don't think we can conclude much about them for being in an unbroken tie, although I was expecting Tani to make a last second appearance under unfavorable circumstances for the elims. Araris got an extra vote again. Does anyone have a good reason to want a PM with me?
-
Steeldancer Sorry for the double post, Kas
