Jump to content

Magestar

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    1462

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Magestar

  1. Magestar
    Mage wanted to have a Shard. This is true. Sorry for wanting awesome powers, Len. Wrong. I tried to trick Odium. If I just told the thread that I had a Shattered Shard, an asked Cultivation to fix it, what do you think the odds are that I would get hit by Odium that same cycle? That's why I tried to make it seem like I was a Mistborn. Or, perhaps, I'm any number of the other roles that lack knowledge of who the other Shards are. Let me think. I believe that's nearly all of them? Seriously, how is not knowing who Cultivation is a point in favor of me being a Sharder? Except that that Bandwagon rose up counter to the person I wanted lynched. I not only defended Lopen, especially later in the cycle, I was pretty adamant in my attack on you. Don't you think, if I was even going to be that blatant with a Bandwagon, I would attack the person I actually wanted dead? Len, I'm not 17th Shard. To be honest, I don't know if you are either, but you have less points against me than I do against you, and you haven't defended against them. I'll admit, it'd be pretty hard, because the evidence is compelling. But there's almost nothing on me. Besides that maybe-bandwagon, the other points aren't really valid. @Master Elodin, what reasons do you have for voting on me, exactly? He took his vote off of me because I defended myself adequately. I answered his questions, and he decided that I wasn't really suspicious. Why, again, do you think I'm suspicious? As far as I know, Endowment must have trusted me, to some extent, and gave me the ability? I did talk about wanting the Mistborn Role ability in some of the World PM's, so Endowment might have seen that. And why would I lie about Endowments investment? Finally, if we could look at Len's behavior so far, that'd be great. There's someone who's been behaving erratically. He said that, because I claimed Mistborn, I was probably Hoid or Autonomy. What? And, refer to my earlier post! Look at all the evidence against him. Finally, if I can survive this cycle, I can give you undeniable proof of my innocence. I think.
  2. Magestar
    To be honest, I'm watching and waiting to see if I have anything relevant to contribute. I don't right now, plus, I've been somewhat busy since this game started, due to RL issues, and I'm trying to do things in the other games I'm in. I hope to have my thoughts gathered by tomorrow, when I'll have more time, but as of right now I don't have a whole lot to contribute. I also plan on playing the AG, so I need to build a character. While I'm not quite as booked as Seonid, I'm still kind of busy. Seonid is taking the cake for business RN. I will say that while it's unlikely that the Ghostbloods and the Sons of Honor will be able to work together in the long run, I think that killing the Diagramists should still be our top priority. So basically, I agree with what's been said so far. I think.
  3. Magestar
    Well, this is gonna be the third game I'm playing at once! Ha! My mind is going to die. I'm going to be some kind of Narcissist/Compulsive Gambler Combo, and don't worry, I'll be able to mention just how much better than you I am at everything, in every post. In fact, I'm willing to bet that I can beat you, in any contest, of your choice. @Metacognition, doesn't the Narcissist think he's better looking than the Casanova? Actual RP to come when I have time.
  4. Magestar
    Yeah, I suppose that's what happens when you false-claim. My intention was to get Cultivation to fix Preservation without anyone realizing what was going on. At this point, I'm glad they didn't, as I would have died, but if someone had attacked me after cultivation had fixed Preservation, then I would no longer be 'Invested' by Preservation, and I could have been killed by Odium, or, in this case, Ruin. Unfortunately, as I'm not a Mistborn, I have no idea if you lose a vial to being role blocked. So I went with what I had, hoping to buy enough time to get Cultivation to fix Preservation, (Giving me a Shard. That would have been nice) and simultaneously remaining anonymous. After that, with a Shards Protection, plus Preservations investment ability, I would have been nearly unkillable, which would have been very nice. If I understand Arinian correctly, his vote on me was largely because he didn't realize that holding a Shattered Preservation would give me it's investment ability (An Extra Life.) After Seonid clarified, he retracted his vote. Also, he said the shard of Unsurvival. My vote on Len stands for several reasons. A; The reasons for lynching him last cycle hold. He was pushing a lynch against what seemed most logical, in my opinion. B; This leads me to believe that he knew Lopen was Odium, because he was 17th Shard. He assumed that, by lynching Odium, he could gain the trust of the village, and place himself on firm ground. This is why he pushed a Lopen lynch against other options. C; The last minute Bandwagon on Lopen. I feel as though there was definitely something suspicious behind that. D; I have a general bad gut read on Len. Then again, that's fairly normal. However, normal Aggressive!Len hops around, violently accusing multiple people, from my experience. It's not like him to drive one lynch on little data. That's about al my reasons for distrusting Len, at the moment. I'd like more people to get on and reply, but I don't have the time to ping everyone. Someone start pinging.
  5. Magestar
    In response to Len; Why would false-claiming a Mistborn make me likely to be Autonomy or Hoid? What? How does that make any sense? To be honest, I did misunderstand how Mistborn Charges work. I'll admit I did fake-claim, and, seeing as my extra life is gone, I got Preservation after it was shattered. I'm passing it this cycle, unless I get a really good reason not to, since its usefulness has passed. I was trying to un-shatter it, but Cultivation declined to 'refill my Mistborn Charges'. As far as targeting Alv with the Mistborn Ability, that did happen. I was invested by Endowment while on Scadrial, for whatever reason. Also, going off of what I said in the World PM, Len. My reasons for lynching you last cycle have not changed, and I feel even more confidant that you are 17th Shard now. I'll elaborate later. Seonid, love the Writeup!
  6. Magestar
    Example A; Vague Curiosity. Example B; Vague Vagueness. You guys are so effective.
  7. Magestar
    I was role blocked on N2, and targeted Alv on N3. Typo, sorry. Technically, I did also target Alv on N2, but I was role blocked. So I tried again N3. Sorry Alv. I was a little bit worried you had a kill role. That's basically my action history.
  8. Magestar
    Actually, as I'm also out of charges, I can say that a Mistborn can confirm someone is not Odium. Cultivation, I would not mind a refill. I targeted Alv N2, and he did not use any kill actions. But Odium did use a kill. So, I can be reasonably confidant that Alv is not Odium, I think.
  9. Magestar
    TL;DR: Looking back, it might have not have been the greatest idea to vote on Mage. I'm choosing to interpret this that way. Don't judge me. Thanks. I needed to hear someone say that, finally.
  10. Magestar
    Oh, look, someone with a vote manipulation wants me dead. What else is new.
  11. Magestar
    I am also INTP. It means that this test labels you as INTP, Zathoth.
  12. Magestar
    -sigh- With 11 minutes left, I think it'd probably be wise for me to move my vote to Lopen. Len. Lopen, I'll have you know I'm not terribly suspicious of you, but we can't have another no-lynch, so I'm going to prevent any vote manipulators from causing one. Sorry about this.
  13. Magestar
    Oh. Well, there goes my last major suspicion of Lopen. Glad I've already got my vote on Len.
  14. Magestar
    Oops. I missed that. Sorry Drought. edit; Agh, Ninjas. But he could have been 17th Shard, I think. @Seonid, Autonomy can convert 17th Sharders, right?
  15. Magestar
    I got that. Look up a bit. edit; Also, I can see what Arinian is saying about putting his vote back. Why he did it, that is, even if his reasoning is flawed.
  16. Magestar
    I think it's; Magestar (3) : Araris, Stick, Lopen Lopen (4) : Elenion, Arinian, Alvron, Assassin Elenion (2) : Kas, Mage Assassin (1); Bard. @Araris Valerian said they'd take their vote off of me, I think. I'm still not sure why Stick voted on me, so Lopen is the only one who has even a partially valid justification for voting on me. I don't know how Elenion's lost so many votes. Like I said earlier, I feel pretty equally about Lopen and Elenion, however, I still think Elenion is the better option in this case. The Lopen lynch currently has A; Len's vote, which has been repeatedly bashed. B; Arinian's seemingly random vote, which I can't make sense of, C; Alvin's supposed info-based vote, which we still know nothing about, and D; Assassin's vote, which is reminiscent of Arinian's. The biggest thing I see against Lopen is this; Important bit Bolded. I was confused as to how he was certain about this. I asked him. And he still has not responded. (He might not have been on, though. Not sure.) However, all of this could just be a slip up, so I'd like to hear what Lopen has to say. I agree with Bard that this sudden Lopen bandwagon looks really odd, and I'm still far more suspicious of Len than Lopen. edit; Forgot to update vote tally since Bard ninja'd.
  17. Magestar
    I'm not seeing him being suddenly supported. Right now, it's him and Len who are the two main people up for lynch, (Besides, against all odds, me.) and I'm not seeing a lot of support for him. Could you clarify? Juicy info? Where? I'd like some! In all seriousness, I only have a rather nice coincidence to thank for my knowledge. It's nothing particularly juicy, just a bit of somewhat useful information. I'd love to be able to argue against your vote on me, but I'm left with absolutely nothing to argue against. Please give your reasoning soon.
  18. Magestar
    You guys keep saying that. What is it you have against lunch?
  19. Magestar
    It's mostly a gut read, from how you've been acting and responding to posts. I know you've been sick/away, so my read on you is mostly from how you responded to things in the first few cycles, and how I've been reading you're posts. I do think that a Lopen lynch is pretty weak, so I'm voting for Len. If he ends up being good, we should probably take a closer look at you. Wait, when did I say that about Sheep? I've trusted Sheep for most of the game. (Regardless of the Fact that he kept voting for me. ) I don't like being implicated for lynching people, I'll give you that one. This becomes a problem when people who are lynched actually end up being bad. In this scenario, I have felt that almost all of the lynches have been on pretty weak evidence, and that when two people are up for lynch, then the one who doesn't die should be looked at later, especially if the other lynchee ends up being good. Also, I'm pretty sure the three votes on me are for A; Not mentioning a PM (Or possibly having known Sheeps role. (I didn't)), B; The same thing as before. (What was that again? @Araris Valerian, you still haven't reminded me why you have your vote on me, and I'm fairly certain the reason you had last cycle no longer applies.), and C; Because I don't like being responsible for lynching villagers. Does that sound right? Also, Lopen, I'm curious to know how you know that Joe was a villager when we lynched him. As far as I know, the only people with that sort of information would be the 17th Shard, or Autonomy, I think. Scanners, you need to be more active, btw. There's a reason for having scanners in this game, and right now, we're lynching just on analysis, which I don't like.
  20. Magestar
    Actually, I'm pretty sure I can confirm that Alv isn't Odium, unfortunately. Like Araris, it might be better if I didn't say why, although if it comes down to him being lynched I'll put my information forward. Curse you Alv, why can't you just be evil? :P. Can you remind me of the reasoning for this? I'm going to put my vote on Len. Depending on how the day goes, I might change my vote, but right now I think a little more pressure should be put on him. If he ends up being good, well, we can kill Lopen. @Elenion, would you mind backing up your vote on Lopen a little more? @Alvron, is there any way you can clarify a bit on what roles you think Lopen might have, and why? Yeah, I'm going to kick myself for not voting on Harambe that cycle for a while. That repeated no-lynch was awful.
  21. Magestar
    Wrong. The extent of the rules involving Devotion being in her PM's says this; And, having been in one of those PM's myself, with Sheep, I can assume he can be in the PM's he creates. Also, looking at the original PM, it looks like Sheep just split that into three separate PM's, and replaced Jondesu[DEAD] with Elenion. It makes sense, to me. I agree with this. Also, if you don't know who has a shattered Shard, well, there are only two in the game, and refills aren't bad either. Use process of elimination, and start targeting people you trust. If they've got a Shattered Shard, great, if they don't, then either they get a refill or nothing happens. I don't know if you're already doing this, but if you are, continue doing it. On Odium's kill strategy... I'll admit, it's really, really confusing me. His hits look really random, not following any of the three or four strategies I've seen used, or would have used myself. I'd say maybe he's targeting partially active players, just from the looks of it. Not inactives, or lurkers, but people who are contributing right around normal, but not quite as much as the super active posters? Idk. That seems really, really specific to the people who have died, so I might just be making things up to fit the evidence. I'll not say I'm not feeling the Lopen/Len lynches, because I think they make sense, but I feel pretty equal about both players. It's equally bad, but it's still equal.
  22. Magestar
    I've got a moment, so I'm going to post some thoughts. Cool. Scadrial's PM just died anyway, so I'm moving, and Nalthis sounds as good as anywhere else. I can confirm this is accurate. Except my 'Blurbs' were actually succinct, well thought out, discussion inspiring, logical tidbits. Not Blurbs. I can respect that. Right now, I'm thinking about joining Lopen in voting on Len, however, if I recall, he just started being able to be active recently? So he might just being normal Aggressive Len. So I'm going to wait on that for a moment. I'm not suspicious of Kas at all. I think I'm going to look over the thread again. -sigh-
  23. Magestar
    Well, first of all, I was role blocked the night before last, and Odium killed. So I can't be Odium. There's no evidence for this unless whoever role blocked me steps up, however, so I'm not going to stand on that one. As far as the PM goes, I basically ignored it because it's not useful for anything. Sheep didn't claim to me, although he might have guessed something about my role and yours, and decided we should talk? Not sure why. After Len saying he also got a two person PM, I'm unsure as to whether there's a really important reason for them, or if Sheep just paired people he trusted. Would you mind telling me what Planet you're on? If Sheep thought we should talk, it might be a good idea. Plus, I plan on leaving my planet today anyway. I have people coming over, so I don't know if I'll be able to post again until tomorrow morning. So I might not respond to responses to this response immediately.
  24. Magestar
    Not sure about the second one, however, it's possible he just ended up not doing it. It really wouldn't have been helpful. Huh. It feels like there are more.
  25. Magestar
    Yes... He protected Harambe. At least, that's what he told the PM he was doing. My guess would be that Ruin is being passed constantly from inactive players. There are a rather large number of them, which is really unfortunate.
×
×
  • Create New...