Rasarr

Heal First of the Sun, hurt Roshar. 3. First of the Sun - 34 5. Roshar - 8 6. Scadrial - 13

In Soviet Roshar, Parshmen possess voidspren. However this works.

I'm gone for a day and First of the Sun is leading? Yay! Heal First of the Sun, hurt Roshar. 3. First of the Sun - 26 5. Roshar - 17 6. Scadrial - 15

Heal First of the Sun, hurt Roshar. 3. First of the Sun - 185. Roshar - 196. Scadrial - 18

I would agree with this train of thoughts if it wasn't for the fact that Stormfather is, for one, an extremely powerful spren, and for other, he's implied to have merged with Tanavast's Cognitive Shadow, which would give him an additional "oompf" that could let him survive the Recreance even though he was (apparently) bonded at the time. This being said, I do agree that it'd be easy for three people to hide their oath-keeping, though it would also be easier for other Radiants to check whether the Bondsmiths really did break the bond - after all, three people among thousand to not-Recreancing would find it easier to disappear than three people out of three.

Heal First of the Sun, hurt Roshar. 3. First of the Sun - 17 5. Roshar - 19 6. Scadrial - 19

Heal First of the Sun, hurt Roshar. 3. First of the Sun - 145. Roshar - 216. Scadrial - 20

I've heard the theory that Kalak is the man Nalan's talking with at Gavilar's party in Jasnah's version of the prologue; the one that worries about Ash getting worse and acts like a hipochondriac. I'd also add Taln's actions and descriptions from WoR; I understand you suspect him not be "actually" Taln, so to put it, but I'd say if this is to be a repository of all knowledge Heraldic, a mention of Taln's massive frame and astounding reflex should probably be added. Also, you keep on using "Starlight" instead of stormlight

Bah. Hurt Roshar, heal First of the Sun. 3. First of the Sun - 10 5. Roshar - 26 6. Scadrial - 19

I admit I have some issues with your statement, @WayneSpren. And anyway, who doesn't expect Roshar to win? First of the Sun emerging victorious from this struggle would be a neat twist. Heal First of the Sun, hurt Roshar. 3. First of the Sun - 125. Roshar - 246. Scadrial - 19

Likewise. 3. First of the Sun - 11 5. Roshar - 25 6. Scadrial - 19

Heal First of the Sun, hurt Roshar. 3. First of the Sun - 13 5. Roshar - 22 6. Scadrial - 20

If I understood marianmi correctly, you're having this in reverse. By their theory, Cultivation is dependent on Rosharan life, rather than the other way round, so Odium killing 90% of Roshar -> Cultivation dying.

Heal First of the Sun, hurt Roshar. 3. First of the Sun--9 5. Roshar--25 6. Scadrial--21

Guess there's not much hope for First of the Sun now, is there? Nevertheless, heal it, and hurt Scadrial. 3. First of the Sun--8 5. Roshar--24 6. Scadrial--23

I won't be able to come at all, it turns out... Inasmuch as I'd like to meet Brandon, my family would not take kindly to me calling off a visit to them to go to Italy. Well, nevetheless, have fun, people!

Aw, no... Heal First of the Sun, hurt Roshar. 3. First of the Sun--6 5. Roshar--23 6. Scadrial--17 8. Taldain--9

Hurt Nalthis, heal First of the Sun. 3. First of the Sun -- 9 4. Nalthis - 4 5. Roshar--17 6. Scadrial - 17 8. Taldain--8

Hurt Threnody, heal First of the Sun. 3. First of the Sun--9 4. Nalthis--5 5. Roshar--16 6. Scadrial--13 8. Taldain--10 9. Threnody--3

Heal First of the Sun, hurt Threnody. 3. First of the Sun--9 4. Nalthis--6 5. Roshar--15 6. Scadrial--12 8. Taldain--9 9. Threnody--4

Heal First of the Sun, hurt Sel. 3. First of the Sun--8 4. Nalthis--6 5. Roshar--14 6. Scadrial--11 7. Sel--3 8. Taldain--7 9. Threnody--6

You and me both. And there are pretty few "good guy" Lawful characters in fantasy - most are more of "cool rebel" kind of people - so that would be something of a breath of fresh air. I was thinking about something more along the lines of "I will consider circumstances of the crime, not just the crime itself" to keep Skybreakers from becoming mindless police robots, but this is also a good idea. Upvote!

Heal First of the Sun, hurt Yolen. 3. First of the Sun--7 4. Nalthis--6 5. Roshar--11 6. Scadrial--10 7. Sel--7 8. Taldain--6 9. Threnody--7 11. Yolen--1

I have to say, I would like to see a Skybreaker who would develop without Nale breathing down his neck. So far, our view of the Skybreakers has been pretty negative, really - Syl dismisses them as being sticklers to law, Nale acts like a misprogrammed robot, and our only Skybreaker candidate at the moment, Szeth, is pretty much a serial killer on a leash. The Skybreaker mentality as presented to far seems to lends itself well to acting like a "bad cop" to Windrunners' "good cop", so I would like to see what a "proper" Skybreaker would look and act like, and what kind of moral quandaries they'd have to face and resolve to stay on their path. Also, I just know that with Division and Gravitation, Skybreakers would be the best at superhero landing.

Well, I come to the thread for the first time and Ashyn's exploded already. No love for magic diseases, I suppose. Heal First of the Sun (storms, but I do love the name), hurt Braize. 2. Braize--2 3. First of the Sun--7 4. Nalthis--6 5. Roshar--8 6. Scadrial--8 7. Sal--7 8. Taldain--6 9. Threnody--6 11. Yolen--5