-
Posts
5391 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
9
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Treamayne
-
We do not yet know how that will play out, but for the time being Harmony is not really one Shard yet (discussed here - which has links to other places it is discussed) At the risk of quoting myself: Which brings us to Era 2, when there are now two separate Mists - Preservation's and Ruin's (Light and Dark), rather than one Grey Mist. But we do know the process has begin to integrate the Powers, because it is more likely that if he lost or gave up the power only one Harmony Shard would drop. So, maybe in Era 3 or later Harmony (or Discord) will develop his own Color, but it does not seem to have happened yet. Hope that helps
-
Without @hwiles's links - WoK Interlude 3 (Axies the Collector) takes place in Iri (specifically Kasitor), and Dalinar's wife was part-Iriali* (but from Rira) Hope that helps
-
The answer never addressed that part of the question. The verified answer only confirms the points posted above.
-
I can see that as one interpretation - but I disagree that it is the only interpretation. I'm not saying you are wrong, I'm saying it is also possible (based on the way those two WoBs are worded): Hoid left without breaking the bond or killing Design, but Design stayed on Roshar Hoid left without Design, but Design (and their bond) recovered as soonas he returned to Roshar. Based on those - the confirmed facts are simply: Hoid left Roshar Hoid did not kill Design or break his bond to do so Hoid's special Whereas non-confirmed theories: Design was on Scadrial (or Scadrian Shadesmar) Hoid had access to Rosharan Lightweaving and Soulcasting on Scadrial Hoid's other many investitures or abilities were part of why he was able to be on Scadrial during Era 2 As opposed to simply Realmatic Knowledge Again, please realize I actually agree with your postulation - except - that you are stating them as facts instead of theories.
-
Pardon me if I do not take unreliable narrator Mraize at his word. We also have this WoB: We do not have published confirmation that a Radiant cannot leave the Rosharan system (or if they did, what would happen to their Spren and Bond), nor do we have confirmation that Design was on Scadrial (only that Hoid was there and did not break his bond by being there, per your referenced WoB). It's okay that we have different interpretations and opinions - the answer is not yet confirmed in any non-Hoid/non-corner-case way based on current available (non-preview) material.
-
I was specifically refering to the version used by Spanreads, splitting a spren into two parts - which we know from The Sibling's reaction is bordering blasphemy (and therefore not likely to be the mechanic here) This may be closer to the mechanic, but while these are "paired" they are not paired in the way current rosharan fabrials are (such as the Ch 4 Farming tool) And we do not yet know if this time of split spirit Fabrial does or can apply to spren. I would agree that if this is a realmatic principal, then it is more likely to apply to spren - if it was due to that Shard's nature, then less likely it would apply to spren.
-
We may get more information in SA5, but for now the only WoB close to the matter is: It seems important to me that one each is described as Black and White. From Ivory and Blended we know the Inkspren are black with iridescent oil-like tones. So the other would either have to be a different Spren, or an Inksren that was changed, somehow. Likely they control different functions, but I doubt it would be like Paired fabrials because: Those are a recent developement The Oathgates do not only go to/from Urithuru - that's why the mosaics exist to select destination. Radiants can transfer between any two of the eleven locations Hope that helps
-
I prefer YNP, but every time I use that people are like "What's this?"
-
Welcome to the Shard. Please consider an Intro Post to let us know what you have or have-not read, so we can avoid spoilers if necessary. Also, please consider checking out the Sharder FAQ for some useful tips and tricks - as each forum is slightly different. Also, I have reported your post for you, since this is the wrong Forum. All book discussion belongs in the appropriate section (Blue Header Bars on the main forum page): "Cosmere" for those works, "Non-Cosmere" for everything else, "Spoiler Zone" for Preview material and new releases in their Spoiler Period, and "Related works" for Unpublished material and non-books (blogs, podcast, youtube released, etc.). Each forum also has a synopsis on the main page to help determine where you should be mosting a given topic. For example, you posted in: When this should be in: It is difficult-to-impossible to give a Spren an ability with Hemalurgy, partly because they are averse to the use of Hemalurgy in the first place, and partly because they are Splinters and already Comprised of investiture so gaining abilities with Hemalurgy does not work (or work well - depending on ability). WoBs: A worldhopper that becomes Radiant isn't prevented from going off-world (see Hoid in Mistborn Era 2) - it's the Spren that cannot leave Roshar (yet) which is why Design was not present in Era 2 as well. The Bond should remain, but the Spren will not - until we discover how Hoid was able to circumvent these restrictions by the time of YatNP. Hope that helps.
-
What would happen if Nale took up Odium (Shard)?
Treamayne replied to RhysDowenUunda's topic in Cosmere Discussion
Welcome to the Shard. Please consider an Intro Post to let us know what you have (or have not) read (whichever list is shorter), so that we can avoid spoilers, if necessary. Also, please consider checking out Sharder FAQ for forum tips and tricks. Have you read M:SH? (Spoilers for Mistborn) Hope that helps. -
Kandra, less so than other targets. If only because, biologically, they do not have a central "brain" (and part of why head shots do not kill them). That said, Harmony can just take them from you when he wants to do so. . . WoB:
-
I cannot speak for others, but I use Calibre (GNU GPL Freeware - donation optional) to organize my eBook library on my computer - and it makes looking up quotes and references very easy (especially with RegEx searches). For example: It's subtle, but it is meant to be - because Foreshadowing. WoB and Reference: Please see the Sharder FAQ (also linked in my Signature) for that info and many more tips and tricks for the Forum, Coppermind and Arcanum.
-
Welcome to the Shard. Please consider an Intro Post to let us know what you have or have-not read, so we can avoid spoilers if necessary. Also, please consider checking out the Sharder FAQ for some useful tips and tricks - as each forum is slightly different. Because, while 16 does have Cosmere-Wide importance, it also has Specific Importance to Scadrial (Mistborn). While not every Shard has an associated Number (or other traits, like color), many/most do - and those traits will be expressed in their stories (e. g. Honor's number is 10 and color is blueish while, Preservation's number is 16 and color White, Ruin's number is unknown so far, but color Black (as seen in the antechamber of the Well), etc.) WoBs and Minor Spoilers: Hope that helps.
-
Great Observation Here is the quote: WoK Ch 17: Discussed a few times on forum such as Here and most recently Here. Likely just a nod to Scadrial, as Mistborn Era 2 happens years after the events of WoK (in between SA 5 and 6 to be more precise) - so I doubt it is any inherent knowledge for Syl - Though SR shenanigans and Connection cause some interesting effects (like the scenes in WoR where Shallan draws Yalb and Shalash (sitting in the lait, before arriving to the Plains), or Syl turning into a version of Shallan before they ever met).
-
Early indications of inclination, that possibly drew their Spren: Kaladin: Renarin:
-
Maybe consider editing your Intro Post with an updated "Complete" list (or add to your profile) so we can easily find what might be spoilers and tag them appropriately. This Thread (and many others) discuss reading order considerations (which things spoiler which other things). If you need it, the Shard FAQ has tips on editing posts (and other forum functions).
-
Many of us also get excited at the mention of Worldhoppers and other Manifestations of Investiture. However, (Stormlight Archive, Tress Spoilers): I missed that feeling, and that reduced how much I enjoyed TLM. I cannot speak for others.
-
What would you see if you looked at the other Shards
Treamayne replied to Sythrin's topic in Cosmere Discussion
Dungeon Keeper (Pre-StarCraft RTS) - Though I doubt most of the people here would be old enough to remember this great classic (cheap on GOG).- 12 replies
-
1
-
- shards
- shard of adonalsium
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
I htink Jorgen would be better served by meeting Tindwyl. . .
-
For people that find mutton and lamb (Venison, etc.)to be "gamey" I use a yogurt marinade before cooking, as it draws the excess blood from the tissues (while tenderizing the meat) and reduces gameyness. Just light-rinse the reddened yogurt off before cooking. . .
-
I don't know if he said he would change these things (except once to Vin), just talked about how brown plants, a red sun and soot clogged air wasn't right (based on Mare's Dream - and the Logbook descriptions). TFE: I think it's more likely he shared Mare's dream with some Skaa (and likely the soldiers in the caves) and, over time, that turned into the "prophesy" you asked about.
-
If a Spinner went to an art gallery, would they see the Spiritual Realm?
Treamayne replied to Doomslug99's question in Cosmere Q&A
Welcome to the Shard. As @Sophrosyne mentioned, please consider adding to your profile or an Intro Post a list of what you have or have-not read (whichever is shorter) so spoilers can be avoided. Also, please consider checking out the Sharder FAQ for some forum tips and tricks. This is less about access to Fortune, and more about the paintings originations. The Nature of Endowment allows artists of the correct Heightening to imbue something of themselves into their work, so other invested people (like your examples of Lightsong and Kaladin) get a glimpse of the Artist's Intent. WoBs: And I would agree that a Spinner tapping Fortune would also likely see these things, if they were there to be found. But it is not necessarily present in all artwork. Hope that helps -
I had similar conclusions. I wonder if it means something that the "Prime" designations are like this. I've read White Sand prose thrice and Aether of Night twice (and expect I will reread it again) but I don't think I'll reread this or TWoKP. You hit th enail on the head - Interesting to read. . . once.
