Mystic He/Him Posted April 20 Posted April 20 (edited) 16 minutes ago, Doc12 said: I started a trend way back in QF78 where I romanced Jo's character (we were both converted elims) and then Coco in LG110 (we were both elims) and I told Mist I'd romance his character next game if we were both elim so C’mon Doc, you’ll expose the three of us as Elims : ) I’m currently fine with anyone being exed, I’m a lot more interested in how everyone’s reacting. Plus I won’t be around for Rollover today. But, I’m also willing to add to the ties to see who breaks it. Plus I had a vote on him earlier Striker Im looking forward to see how people respond Edited April 20 by Mist. Changed “Mint and I” to “The three of us”
Divergent He/Him Posted April 20 Posted April 20 I'm catching up and I compiled what people stated regarding where they were visiting N0 Basement (3) - Mist, Striker, Mint Ground Floor (5) - Wahr, Fizz9, ___, Star, Conure1243 Upstairs (4) - Divergent, Doc12, Verdance, Miss Fallen And it seems like the odds aren't that far off from each scenario being likely to happen? I do find it curious though that there were several who picked the Ground Floor. To the people who chose Ground Floor, were you interested in playing the standard game or was there another reason for the choice?
___ He/Him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 3 minutes ago, Divergent said: I'm catching up and I compiled what people stated regarding where they were visiting N0 Basement (3) - Mist, Striker, Mint Ground Floor (5) - Wahr, Fizz9, ___, Star, Conure1243 Upstairs (4) - Divergent, Doc12, Verdance, Miss Fallen And it seems like the odds aren't that far off from each scenario being likely to happen? I do find it curious though that there were several who picked the Ground Floor. To the people who chose Ground Floor, were you interested in playing the standard game or was there another reason for the choice? I didn't vote; I forgot, so mine was random
Fizz9 Posted April 21 Posted April 21 3 minutes ago, Divergent said: To the people who chose Ground Floor, were you interested in playing the standard game or was there another reason for the choice? Just want to be standard game.
Divergent He/Him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 Other thoughts I had: - I have a light village lean on Mist for being the one to initiate asking where people explored. It's well within his range to initiate things as elim, so it's not a hard leaning, but I think him doing that so early contributes to a game where people will be open about what they're doing and dissuades any elim from doing something shady - I'm feeling a light sus on Wahr for the whole Basement/Ground Floor thing. He mentioned that the mixup had to do with English not being his first language, so I'd like to hear a little more of how that happened. Other than that, I don't think his reaction to being wagoned is necessarily suspicious, since I think he's defensive regardless of alignment. At the moment, I wouldn't want to vote him too since I think he falls under players I easily misread, so I'll be observing him more if he remains sus later on - I also liked Mint asking people why they chose the floor they did. I think that helps us later on, especially when we've figured out what scenario we're in and looking into if there was something suspicious about the reasoning people gave out Also, could someone clarify what that discussion about being able to figure out if it's Scenario 3 based on the flips meant? I didn't quite catch what the takeaway from it was 1
Divergent He/Him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 - I'm a little confused with Star calling their vote on Wahr a "poke" vote when it's not a poke vote at all. I guess they're new to SE (?) I did like their line of thinking though for the vote, which picked up on the same Basement/Ground Floor thing - Currently, I'd want to vote Akimiko. I find it a little off for her to say that she's here now, but then disappear without saying anything else Other than those, I don't have much of a leaning for everyone else. I feel like that's probably on brand for D1s to be slow, especially in this format where we're not certain what kind of game we're looking it, but it'd be good for people to share their thoughts, so we can get a better handle of what their perspective is or where they stand in the game
Mystic He/Him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 19 minutes ago, Divergent said: Also, could someone clarify what that discussion about being able to figure out if it's Scenario 3 based on the flips meant? I didn't quite catch what the takeaway from it was We got this confirmed by Araris, but if the person who dies tonight has a role, it cannot be scenario 3. If no one dies tonight it can’t be scenario 2.
Divergent He/Him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 2 minutes ago, Mist. said: We got this confirmed by Araris, but if the person who dies tonight has a role, it cannot be scenario 3. If no one dies tonight it can’t be scenario 2. Ohh okay, that makes sense For Scenario 2, is it because either someone gets shot or the one with the gun die if the kill fails? 1
coco.pudding she/they Posted April 21 Posted April 21 2 minutes ago, Divergent said: For Scenario 2, is it because either someone gets shot or the one with the gun die if the kill fails? The person with the gun has to kill someone. If they choose not to kill (or are blocked) they die.
Miss Fallen she/her Posted April 21 Posted April 21 I know some people are reading mist as village, but I’m reading opposite actually. Part of this may be sibling antagonism, but in that spirit my votes on mist. Also, I’d soft read striker as village for starting the discussion with pokes, despite the possible train on him. Current vote count (I think) Mint(2): Striker, Wahr Doc(1): Dive Fizz(1): ____/mippo Wahr(3): Fizz, Mint, Star ___/mippo(1): Qian Striker(2): Doc, Mist Akimoko(1): Divergent Mist(1): Fallen Basement (3) - Mist, Striker, Mint Ground Floor (5) - Wahr, Fizz9, ___, Star, Conure1243 Upstairs (4) - Divergent, Doc12, Verdance, Miss Fallen *thanks Doc and Divergent for tracking these
Stardust She/Her Posted April 21 Posted April 21 17 minutes ago, Divergent said: - I'm a little confused with Star calling their vote on Wahr a "poke" vote when it's not a poke vote at all. I guess they're new to SE (?) I did like their line of thinking though for the vote, which picked up on the same Basement/Ground Floor thing So I am new to SE, but I called it a poke vote because all these people before me called it a poke vote; I figured that's what it was. (look below for all the mentions of poke vote) On 4/18/2026 at 11:33 PM, StrikerEZ said: Anyway, I think our best course of action is to proceed as if this is a standard elim game until we get actual info proving otherwise. So, to start things off, I’m going to give a lovely poke vote to Frozen Mint to start us off. Someone’s gotta throw down the first vote. On 4/19/2026 at 2:19 AM, Through the living Wahr said: Now I will poke vote Qian On 4/19/2026 at 9:10 AM, ___ said: Let's poke Fizz On 4/19/2026 at 3:08 PM, Fizz9 said: I'm going to poke someone, so I might as well poke Through the living Wahr. 9 hours ago, Qianweilian said: I'm going to poke vote mippo (or ____ if I must). You haven't responded, and your username is atrocious.
Divergent He/Him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 12 minutes ago, coco.pudding said: The person with the gun has to kill someone. If they choose not to kill (or are blocked) they die. I see. Good to know that there's other ways for us to figure out the scenario we're in, outside of the clues, which may be unreliable (due to the possibility of getting clues from a different scenario by chance) 1 minute ago, Miss Fallen said: I know some people are reading mist as village, but I’m reading opposite actually. Part of this may be sibling antagonism, but in that spirit my votes on mist. Also, I’d soft read striker as village for starting the discussion with pokes, despite the possible train on him. Current vote count (I think) Mint(2): Striker, Wahr Doc(1): Dive Fizz(1): ____/mippo Wahr(3): Fizz, Mint, Star ___/mippo(1): Qian Striker(2): Doc, Mist Akimoko(1): Divergent Mist(1): Fallen Basement (3) - Mist, Striker, Mint Ground Floor (5) - Wahr, Fizz9, ___, Star, Conure1243 Upstairs (4) - Divergent, Doc12, Verdance, Miss Fallen *thanks Doc and Divergent for tracking these Thanks for this, I forgot to unvote Doc12 before voting Akimiko
Mint11 she/her Posted April 21 Posted April 21 mm okay I'm gonna take pity on Wahr. and will move my vote to Fizz Mint(2): Striker, Wahr Akimiko(1): Dive Fizz(2): ____/mippo, Mint Wahr(2): Fizz, Star Fallen(1): Mist ___/mippo(1): Qian Striker(2): Doc, Mist Mist(1): Fallen @StrikerEZ curious on your reasoning for keeping your vote on me since the initial vote was a poke vote? 4 minutes ago, Through The Living Star said: So I am new to SE, but I called it a poke vote because all these people before me called it a poke vote; I figured that's what it was. (look below for all the mentions of poke vote) a poke vote is essentially poking someone to say "hey say something". its something people do on D1. it's not really a "I find you suspicious" vote the pinned SE rules/etiquette post might have a better explanation, I think wilson defined some common terminology in there 1
Stardust She/Her Posted April 21 Posted April 21 3 minutes ago, Frozen Mint said: a poke vote is essentially poking someone to say "hey say something". its something people do on D1. it's not really a "I find you suspicious" vote Ohhhhh that makes so much more sense. Thank you! Well in that case, my vote is Wahr
Miss Fallen she/her Posted April 21 Posted April 21 9 minutes ago, Divergent said: Thanks for this, I forgot to unvote Doc12 before voting Akimiko Nope, that was on me; I didn’t connect Dive with Divergent. thanks Mint for fixing it. Right now we’ve got a 4 way tie, which is gonna be random. is this a normal out come for D1/is there anything we should do about it?
Mystic He/Him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 7 minutes ago, Through The Living Star said: Ohhhhh that makes so much more sense. Thank you! Well in that case, my vote is Wahr I actually don’t like this, Wahr has a vote taken off and you immediately put another on him. I think for me this is more evidence of V!Wahr and I’m E!leaning Star now 1 minute ago, Miss Fallen said: Nope, that was on me; I didn’t connect Dive with Divergent. thanks Mint for fixing it. Right now we’ve got a 4 way tie, which is gonna be random. is this a normal out come for D1/is there anything we should do about it? Pretty much.
Stardust She/Her Posted April 21 Posted April 21 (edited) 4 minutes ago, Mist. said: I actually don’t like this, Wahr has a vote taken off and you immediately put another on him. I think for me this is more evidence of V!Wahr and I’m E!leaning Star now I meant that since I technically had my first vote as a poke vote because I misunderstood what that was, my actual vote is on Wahr. Does that make sense? Edited April 21 by Through The Living Star
Verdance he/him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 If i randomly poke someone or announce a vote, that person will probably die and people will find that suspicious of me, given my limited experience from last game. So, I am either not voting (my vote will be random), or not announcing my vote Now we’ll see if I’ve learned something or if I’m overcompensating
Mystic He/Him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 1 minute ago, Through The Living Star said: I meant that since I technically had my first vote as a poke vote because I misunderstood what that was, my actual vote is on Wahr. I can understand that, I just don’t like the timing of it. I won’t vote you today though, so you’ll have a bit to convince me otherwise
Divergent He/Him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 21 minutes ago, Frozen Mint said: mm okay I'm gonna take pity on Wahr. and will move my vote to Fizz Is this a poke vote or an actual vote? 9 minutes ago, Miss Fallen said: Nope, that was on me; I didn’t connect Dive with Divergent. thanks Mint for fixing it. Right now we’ve got a 4 way tie, which is gonna be random. is this a normal out come for D1/is there anything we should do about it? Yeah, it's fairly common for D1 votes to either tie or be really close (at least from what I remember since playing in QF77) 3 minutes ago, Verdance said: If i randomly poke someone or announce a vote, that person will probably die and people will find that suspicious of me, given my limited experience from last game. So, I am either not voting (my vote will be random), or not announcing my vote Now we’ll see if I’ve learned something or if I’m overcompensating Is there anyone you're leaning towards voting rn?
Stardust She/Her Posted April 21 Posted April 21 3 minutes ago, Mist. said: I can understand that, I just don’t like the timing of it. I won’t vote you today though, so you’ll have a bit to convince me otherwise Yeah that's on me. I didn't really think about how it would sound... Thank you for giving me another chance though (even though I realize that's likely cause I'm a new player)- I will convince you! (hopefully. I can never know how people will think)
Miss Fallen she/her Posted April 21 Posted April 21 Star’s vote is still counted in the 4 way tie, for current VC
Mint11 she/her Posted April 21 Posted April 21 2 minutes ago, Divergent said: Is this a poke vote or an actual vote? its a real vote. I feel like we're too late in the cycle for pokes I felt kind of bad for wahr, fizz is my next best guess, and I'm very curious to see who, if anyone, breaks the tie @Verdance I'm like 95% sure that votes can't be case privately. you can't do it via DM, only in thread
Verdance he/him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 5 minutes ago, Divergent said: Is this a poke vote or an actual vote? Yeah, it's fairly common for D1 votes to either tie or be really close (at least from what I remember since playing in QF77) Is there anyone you're leaning towards voting rn? I just said no :3 not really sure yet, social cues i rely on in irl werewolf don’t exactly exist on a forum i will be picking a random person to vote for if nothing changes
Divergent He/Him Posted April 21 Posted April 21 5 minutes ago, Frozen Mint said: its a real vote. I feel like we're too late in the cycle for pokes I felt kind of bad for wahr, fizz is my next best guess, and I'm very curious to see who, if anyone, breaks the tie @Verdance I'm like 95% sure that votes can't be case privately. you can't do it via DM, only in thread I see, can you explain more why you think Fizz is suspicious? 5 minutes ago, Verdance said: I just said no :3 not really sure yet, social cues i rely on in irl werewolf don’t exactly exist on a forum i will be picking a random person to vote for if nothing changes Fair enough, it can be a difficult transition going from irl werewolf where you can see people's body language and the like in real-time while in forum, it's more reading between the lines
Recommended Posts