choose your own distro MR75 [Signups]: Tyrian Twisted

[Divergent He/Him]

3 hours ago, Doc12 said:

Alv has a theory that the Elims might have stolen Tineye to make us more reluctant to lynch them. If the Tineye is elim, we lose PMs. If they're village, we lose anyways. I've told two people who the Tineye is. 

Part of me just wants to vote on Dive because TwinStorm was one of my suspects. 

 

I have a follow up to this theory and that is, you, as Elim, suggested to steal Tineye, so that you know where it is and keep them alive to keep PMs open 

And hmmm why the slot that just subbed in when there are other players that you may have had interacted more and could have a better read of?

There are two posts in particular that made me more suspicious of you:

Spoiler

I wish the vote manipulation could have told us something, but honestly I don't see analyzing that as very profitable. There have been many times when villagers move votes last minute or riot their own votes just on a whim, and it leads to both the person they're trying to save and themselves getting exed. Maybe an elim was trying to save Stick, maybe they were just trying to make us think they wanted to save Stick. Maybe an elim just really wanted Araris dead, but I didn't see him making any strong accusations. 

Last time I was elim, I said something similar where I said "analyzing the reason why someone was killed is not beneficial" and this feels like a similar situation. I do think there's value in discussing it, even if we don't really find the correct solution because we can at least see how people approach the scenario and whether or not the way they do so comes across from a more informed perspective. And I think you somewhat dismissing that reads as an elim dissuading from that discussion because you think that it might lead people closer to finding the team

Spoiler

I think I am voting TJ because as I said before, trying to solve distro isn't necessarily alignment indicative, and I can see an argument that exp is making that trying to solve distro and get claims helps the elim find the power roles. 

In this post, you voted TJ out of agreeing with Exp's idea where an elim would try to find the power roles and yet, this was also something you were caught doing, so this feels like a rather opportunistic vote

[Doc12]

Honors ghost, I'm sorry if it felt that way, but I did not intend to blackmail you. I wasn't saying I'll unvote you if you vote with me, more that i was asking if you'd join me in a different vote, but I can understand how it came off as blackmail. I apologize, I don't want to pressure players like that. 

You know what. Screw it. I'm exposing the tineye. I'm halfway convinced they can't be trusted anyway. 

The first message they did, they said 4 players were village, 2 of which died that night and were confirmed village. Now if they were elim, they couldn't have predicted the coinshot kill, but still would know at least one of them was village. 

They claimed it was to get reactions from the four and see if any of them were working together.

They told me they were the tineye night 1, and said they would use the phrase "be careful" on day 2.

Then the next two days they just start accusing me. Be careful of Doc. Be wary of Doc. And yeah, I can understand suspicion for asking for a role. But they say they've told no one else but me. So I'm both the only person they trusted with their role but also the person they suspect most because of it. 

This plus some weird interactions with honors ghost where they claimed to IHAT honors ghost was Mistborn whole honors ghost denies it ? 

The reasoning that an elim might have a tineye role comes down to that they might have stolen it because if they come up for Lynch, they can claim tineye and hold PMs blackmail. That, and my thought that they could be using cleared villagers in the morning messages of their reads to disguise elims within that pool.

The two people I've told are Alvron and Stick. Alv night 2, Stick night 3, but like an hour before rollover. 

So with all that. All my cards on the table. 

Mippo.

[Divergent He/Him]

I've mentioned my suspicions on Doc earlier and here's where I'm at currently with everyone else

Alvron - In thread, he hasn’t really said much to advance the game and has mostly voted around the last couple hours/minutes. I have seen people reference that he has talked to them in PMs and not sure what to make of that. Leaning elim atm, but I’d like to know more about their playstyle if this is typical of them regardless of alignment

 

Mippo - Hasn’t said much too. One post, in particular, stands out to me where he speculated in thread about Mippo being a Mistborn. Outside of those posts, everything has been a one-liner and I feel like an elim Mippo would have talked about that in the elim PM and then would not have made that remark in thread. Leaning v

 

IHAT - The vibes have been giving a similar vibe to the previous game we played together. I think there’s been an actual genuine effort to advance the game from him and that whole exchange about Fura lying feels real and not being fake. I think an elim IHAT would be more likely to come across with cold rationality. Leaning v

 

TUO - I don’t like the D1 analysis. It feels very much just summarizing what the votes were and I didn’t see an attempt to take something out of it. It feels like something an elim would do to look like they’re “solving”. Leaning e

 

Stick - During my initial read of everything, I thought she had a strong opening and then just kinda did not do much after seeing that she wasn’t in any trouble, which felt like elim behavior. But I looked at her posts again and the vibes are giving me villager, even with the lesser activity in the more recent days. Something I’m keeping in mind though is Doc not really giving much of a read on her and also Stick mentioning that Tineye is pretty much always going to be a village role. Leaning v

 

Ksauce - I don’t think there was any singular post that projected towniness to me, so this is going to be an odd read but I think he’s village because I don’t think elims really make remarks about needing to be replaced in public. Usually they settle that in private to avoid the potential to replace out being something that causes suspicion on them. Will need to read more of their posts to have a more definite read. Leaning v

 

Honor - Vibes are overall just giving village. I think her posting hasn’t looked like she’s involved in an elim PM and I do like that point she made about IHAT and Doc being sort of against each other the whole game and then teaming up. That’s been one of my tinfoils where I could see that this has been orchestrated and it’s rather interesting that Doc had been tunneling IHAT, but never really been pushing for it when the end of the day comes. But it’s a tinfoil and not exactly something I’m pursuing at least for today. Leaning v

 

So rn, the elim team I’m thinking of is Doc, TUO, and Alvron. There most likely is a fourth one and I’m kind of uncertain who it is between all of the rest. I think there’s an argument to be made among everyone left there

 

Also, I do feel like it’d be better for everyone to just lay out all their information. We’re at a pivotal time where this day might be the last and I don’t think there necessarily is a benefit to hiding roles or what actions people did as I think the elims already have enough information to eliminate the roles or people that would be more threatening to them

 

Lastly, what are people’s thoughts on the mechanical side of the game? Now that we have more of an idea of what the distro looks like, I do think we can also add that to analysing, especially with identifying which roles the elims most likely stole and removed

[Honors Spectral Image She/her]

Ok I’ll lay out all my info it’s not much lol

i am a village smoker, ik doc also claimed village smoker, and on the day Jo was voted out I received this message like ten min before the day ended: 

How open would you be to changing your vote to Jo? No one's coming to defend honors ghost 

 

anyways yah im rly suspicious of doc

[Myst He/Him]

Okay, after going back and looking at my previous analysis. I still think Doc is Villager.

the blackmail with Honor could be Elim but he said that was a mistake, and I don’t see why an Elim doc would do that unless he was planning killing honor in the night.

A lot of people have brought up the shift in me and doc’s opinions of each other. Yall, I’ve been saying doc is V!lean the entire time, he’s just been the one voting me.

He was the one who suggested switching to me, but we never really thought Honor was Elim. We agreed that something was weird with Mippo and Honor and the Mistborn thing, and voted Honor to see what was happening, after no one started defending her, we talked and switched to Jo. 

Also, I’m a smoker as well.( there’s a lot of us)

Edit: Vote count

Doc(2): Divergent, Honor’s Ghost 

Mippo(1): Doc

Edited December 22, 2025 by Ookla the Broken

[Honors Spectral Image She/her]

See now I feel stuck bc rn I don’t trust doc at all but IHAT I do kinda maybe trust which is weird and idk I thought they were working together but idk I’m not changing my vote off doc but for what it’s worth I don’t think IHAT is Elim

[___ He/Him]

2 hours ago, Doc12 said:

Honors ghost, I'm sorry if it felt that way, but I did not intend to blackmail you. I wasn't saying I'll unvote you if you vote with me, more that i was asking if you'd join me in a different vote, but I can understand how it came off as blackmail. I apologize, I don't want to pressure players like that. 

You know what. Screw it. I'm exposing the tineye. I'm halfway convinced they can't be trusted anyway. 

The first message they did, they said 4 players were village, 2 of which died that night and were confirmed village. Now if they were elim, they couldn't have predicted the coinshot kill, but still would know at least one of them was village. 

They claimed it was to get reactions from the four and see if any of them were working together.

They told me they were the tineye night 1, and said they would use the phrase "be careful" on day 2.

Then the next two days they just start accusing me. Be careful of Doc. Be wary of Doc. And yeah, I can understand suspicion for asking for a role. But they say they've told no one else but me. So I'm both the only person they trusted with their role but also the person they suspect most because of it. 

This plus some weird interactions with honors ghost where they claimed to IHAT honors ghost was Mistborn whole honors ghost denies it ? 

The reasoning that an elim might have a tineye role comes down to that they might have stolen it because if they come up for Lynch, they can claim tineye and hold PMs blackmail. That, and my thought that they could be using cleared villagers in the morning messages of their reads to disguise elims within that pool.

The two people I've told are Alvron and Stick. Alv night 2, Stick night 3, but like an hour before rollover. 

So with all that. All my cards on the table. 

Mippo.

First of all, that's quite interesting about telling alv night two, because he messaged me night three, thinking I was coinshot and asking me to kill IHAT or Stick.

Yes, I am tineye. Yes, that mistborn thing about honor was weird, I admit that. I honestly don't have good reason for that. I wanted to contribute with something  and that's what made the most sense to me.

In the course of the PMs between Doc and I, he has said things I take as very suspicious. First of all, he PMed me saying "can't always be lucky with our first shots", thinking I was coinshot. If anything, that just sounded a little weird to me but it doesn't really indicate anything.

Then, after that, I offered to roleswap. He told me smoker, I told him tineye. He was shocked, and asked why I gave that first message. I actually had the opposite intention with that first one, I thought Fura was elim, and hoped another one was too so that I could see their reactions. That kinda backfired because I turned out to actually be right, and now I had no leads.

After this, Doc asked me to, out of the blue, prove that I'm tineye by putting an agreed upon word into the message. This was suspicious to me because why would he care? In this game roles don't give any indication of alignment. Now, if he WAS elim, then if he knew I was tineye, he could take me out and no more PMs. This is what began my suspicions. I agreed to add the phrase "be careful", then made the message so that if I was killed it would be obvious doc did it. Or honors ghost, the only other person who I thought could be elim because of different behavior than when we normally interact.

 Another out of the blue message was asking whether I had told anyone else I'm tineye. Again, this doesn't really indicate anything.

Then I hear about Doc privately asking honor to change her vote. This increased my suspicions by great magnitude, and I gave today's message.

That's my reasoning.

So, Doc12

[Honors Spectral Image She/her]

Vote count 

doc(3):Mippo,honor,divergent

mippo(1):doc

[Myst He/Him]

I find it really weird that divergent went from, “hey, let’s share information” to “doc’s an Elim” he did say he read through the previous threads, but Idk if there’s anything that would immediately make him think that. I can get the suspicion from day 3. But that’s not an immediate, “hard Elim” so to me, this sounds like Divergent has a team coaching him on what to do.

I didn’t really have reads on wanderer, I only PMed him once. I have given V!reads for his inactivity, because he’s been clear he was busy. But that’s also means he could be hiding Elim and there’s no real way to tell.

here’s the problem, it’s a 5v4. I vote divergent, and the best we can do is tie. Making a 4vote, 1vote, and a 4vote. And if I get another person to vote Divergent, it becomes a 3vote, a 4vote, and a 2vote. So unless I can get all 4 people to vote Divergent, me doing so only hurts us. The best thing I think I can do is not vote doc, which is what Dive’s doing, and so that leaves me with voting Mippo because we have to be very intentional and unified in our votes, otherwise the Elims can just take control.

Does that make sense? We need to all be very conscious of who we’re voting and what that does.

Edit: hopefully this makes sense, we need to vote an Elim here. And all 5 villagers have to do in order for the Elims to not just take over the vote in the last 10 min… I really hope the soother does something today 

Edited December 22, 2025 by Ookla the Broken

[Honors Spectral Image She/her]

Mippo(2):doc,IHAT……

doc(3):divergent,honor,mippo

[Myst He/Him]

3 minutes ago, Honors Ghost said:

Mippo(2):doc,IHAT……

doc(3):divergent,honor,mippo

Unknown, Alvron, Ksauce, Stick, if your a villager, please vote, if you’re an Elim, please don’t.

I should probably tag them: @The Unknown Ookla@Alvron@Ookla the Wallfacer@Stick.

[Stick. she/her]

ok idk about everyone else but i am already a HUGE divergent fan 

 

they are just not playing this like an elim in lylo, i think they are here to solve and are bringing in an outsider perspective which personally i find very refreshing and am choosing to v read bc i think the elim strat post-subbing in would typically just be "hard push random villa to death and ignore p much everything else and instantly win". or at least that's how i wouldve done it. but i like the nuance in their posts at this stage which indicates an actual willingness to solve. 10/10 if ur e imma just let u win

 

(also I had secretly began to lose a bit of faith in my IHAT townread at times during the last cycle but i think im comfy with it again now after some PMs but if the game ends here & we lose to e!IHAT i am still claiming cred points for having this thought ) @Ookla the Broken (edit: tagged u here but forgor to add: idt mippo is e so pls maybe switch votes? consider ksauce)

 

regarding doc: there's been a few instances of of me going ?? with my read on him more recently, like him being weirdly curious about hunting down the coinshot in PMs and the whole honor claiming mistborn conundrum which ive been trying to make sense of in various pms between all involved parties for like the past cycle and while i think i get it now (appears to be mostly a misunderstanding?) it's still making me go ok there's something in there right? ive had some micro villa pings from his posts too, but the tj and jo votes are kinda hard to ignore and now i feel like he may be trying to strongarm the game into an e win cuz idt mippo is e. mippo claimed their role to me earlier in the game too and they know mine and im kinda also reading IHAT's vote switch to mippo as a request from doc via pms (i might be cooking too hard here)

 

BUT:

 

i would like to put Ksauce on the table as an option. ive spoken about them already, i saw their response to my post too and it's ok but doesnt resolve my suspicion much. i know theyre likely not around to defend themself but it's lylo so we cant just afford to wait and if im going by sheer level of townleans, ksauce is the player ive had the least town pings from out of everyone alive. or well, i guess he'd be in a tie with Alvron but im sure we would all feel rly frickin dumb if tj scanned this guy red n1 and went to bed without claiming it, i dont think he anticipated dying to the exe that cycle, and typically the seeker plan would be to stay on the down low, scan a villager and then share all their scans with them which they communicate to the thread for the seeker. that way they live long enough to get max utility out of their role. tj voted ksauce which is not an uncommon way for a seeker to breadcrumb their scans. 

 

i will vote doc over mippo if i have to do it to save mippo

Edited December 22, 2025 by Stick.

[Doc12]

I did not ask IHAT to do anything. To be honest, it's kind of funny that the person I'm tunneling on is actually still V!reading me.

I'm willing to switch my vote to KSOS . I mean, I think mippo is a strong candidate, but the village really needs unity. And at the end of the day all I have on mippo is the elim tineye theory and really nothing that they actually did. 

The thing thats making me trust stick right now is how she's really trying to investigate the honors ghost/mippo claims as well. I feel an elim wouldn't be that diligent. 

[___ He/Him]

Sigh I'm tired today

I don't really care who everybody votes for, just please everybody be very careful

We need to win this

[Alvron]

6 hours ago, Divergent said:

Alvron - In thread, he hasn’t really said much to advance the game and has mostly voted around the last couple hours/minutes. I have seen people reference that he has talked to them in PMs and not sure what to make of that. Leaning elim atm, but I’d like to know more about their playstyle if this is typical of them regardless of alignment

Yeah, I don't really ever say much in thread.  In order for me to do my style of analysis I need a dead elim and a dead village.  I have plenty of dead villagers but no dead elims.

The only other way I contribute to thread is by rolling dice or making ties and seeing what they come up with but I haven't been rolling the dice myself this game as many players don't know my style and to them it would seem disruptive and get me killed.  Not that I publicly disclose my dice rolls but I do use them sometimes to decide who to vote for if a tie isn't possible.

[KaladinsSenseOfHumourSpren He/Him]

2 hours ago, Ookla the Broken said:

Unknown, Alvron, Ksauce, Stick, if your a villager, please vote, if you’re an Elim, please don’t.

I should probably tag them: @The Unknown Ookla@Alvron@Ookla the Wallfacer@Stick.

I WAS ASLEEP

44 minutes ago, Stick. said:

ok idk about everyone else but i am already a HUGE divergent fan 

 

they are just not playing this like an elim in lylo, i think they are here to solve and are bringing in an outsider perspective which personally i find very refreshing and am choosing to v read bc i think the elim strat post-subbing in would typically just be "hard push random villa to death and ignore p much everything else and instantly win". or at least that's how i wouldve done it. but i like the nuance in their posts at this stage which indicates an actual willingness to solve. 10/10 if ur e imma just let u win

 

(also I had secretly began to lose a bit of faith in my IHAT townread at times during the last cycle but i think im comfy with it again now after some PMs but if the game ends here & we lose to e!IHAT i am still claiming cred points for having this thought ) @Ookla the Broken (edit: tagged u here but forgor to add: idt mippo is e so pls maybe switch votes? consider ksauce)

 

regarding doc: there's been a few instances of of me going ?? with my read on him more recently, like him being weirdly curious about hunting down the coinshot in PMs and the whole honor claiming mistborn conundrum which ive been trying to make sense of in various pms between all involved parties for like the past cycle and while i think i get it now (appears to be mostly a misunderstanding?) it's still making me go ok there's something in there right? ive had some micro villa pings from his posts too, but the tj and jo votes are kinda hard to ignore and now i feel like he may be trying to strongarm the game into an e win cuz idt mippo is e. mippo claimed their role to me earlier in the game too and they know mine and im kinda also reading IHAT's vote switch to mippo as a request from doc via pms (i might be cooking too hard here)

 

BUT:

 

i would like to put Ksauce on the table as an option. ive spoken about them already, i saw their response to my post too and it's ok but doesnt resolve my suspicion much. i know theyre likely not around to defend themself but it's lylo so we cant just afford to wait and if im going by sheer level of townleans, ksauce is the player ive had the least town pings from out of everyone alive. or well, i guess he'd be in a tie with Alvron but im sure we would all feel rly frickin dumb if tj scanned this guy red n1 and went to bed without claiming it, i dont think he anticipated dying to the exe that cycle, and typically the seeker plan would be to stay on the down low, scan a villager and then share all their scans with them which they communicate to the thread for the seeker. that way they live long enough to get max utility out of their role. tj voted ksauce which is not an uncommon way for a seeker to breadcrumb their scans. 

 

i will vote doc over mippo if i have to do it to save mippo

26 minutes ago, Doc12 said:

I did not ask IHAT to do anything. To be honest, it's kind of funny that the person I'm tunneling on is actually still V!reading me.

I'm willing to switch my vote to KSOS . I mean, I think mippo is a strong candidate, but the village really needs unity. And at the end of the day all I have on mippo is the elim tineye theory and really nothing that they actually did. 

The thing thats making me trust stick right now is how she's really trying to investigate the honors ghost/mippo claims as well. I feel an elim wouldn't be that diligent. 

I WAS ASLEEP

Mippo (1): IHAT

Doc (3): Divergent, Honor, Mippo

KSauce (2): Doc, Stick

 

I skimmed over everything. I don't like the elim tineye theory much, so Doc.

[Myst He/Him]

59 minutes ago, Doc12 said:

I did not ask IHAT to do anything. To be honest, it's kind of funny that the person I'm tunneling on is actually still V!reading me. 

Well of course, you can be village and still be wrong. You’re also trying to figure this out. Besides, you’ve been consistent about it.

1 hour ago, Stick. said:

ok idk about everyone else but i am already a HUGE divergent fan 

 

they are just not playing this like an elim in lylo, i think they are here to solve and are bringing in an outsider perspective which personally i find very refreshing and am choosing to v read bc i think the elim strat post-subbing in would typically just be "hard push random villa to death and ignore p much everything else and instantly win". or at least that's how i wouldve done it. but i like the nuance in their posts at this stage which indicates an actual willingness to solve. 10/10 if ur e imma just let u win

 

(also I had secretly began to lose a bit of faith in my IHAT townread at times during the last cycle but i think im comfy with it again now after some PMs but if the game ends here & we lose to e!IHAT i am still claiming cred points for having this thought ) @Ookla the Broken (edit: tagged u here but forgor to add: idt mippo is e so pls maybe switch votes? consider ksauce)

 

regarding doc: there's been a few instances of of me going ?? with my read on him more recently, like him being weirdly curious about hunting down the coinshot in PMs and the whole honor claiming mistborn conundrum which ive been trying to make sense of in various pms between all involved parties for like the past cycle and while i think i get it now (appears to be mostly a misunderstanding?) it's still making me go ok there's something in there right? ive had some micro villa pings from his posts too, but the tj and jo votes are kinda hard to ignore and now i feel like he may be trying to strongarm the game into an e win cuz idt mippo is e. mippo claimed their role to me earlier in the game too and they know mine and im kinda also reading IHAT's vote switch to mippo as a request from doc via pms (i might be cooking too hard here)

 

BUT:

 

i would like to put Ksauce on the table as an option. ive spoken about them already, i saw their response to my post too and it's ok but doesnt resolve my suspicion much. i know theyre likely not around to defend themself but it's lylo so we cant just afford to wait and if im going by sheer level of townleans, ksauce is the player ive had the least town pings from out of everyone alive. or well, i guess he'd be in a tie with Alvron but im sure we would all feel rly frickin dumb if tj scanned this guy red n1 and went to bed without claiming it, i dont think he anticipated dying to the exe that cycle, and typically the seeker plan would be to stay on the down low, scan a villager and then share all their scans with them which they communicate to the thread for the seeker. that way they live long enough to get max utility out of their role. tj voted ksauce which is not an uncommon way for a seeker to breadcrumb their scans. 

 

i will vote doc over mippo if i have to do it to save mippo

Unfortunately Im in the same position as I was when I voted Mippo. If we don’t have a train, whoever the Elims are can just take over the vote.

Also, no, I did not talk to Doc about voting Mippo. I don’t know much about Ksauce, I haven’t read much on him. But Doc is right about needing unity, and I think Doc’s village, so Ksauce 

I hate that I keep having to switch my vote for this

[Divergent He/Him]

I just woke up a couple minutes ago. I'll catch up on things in an hour or so

[___ He/Him]

1 hour ago, Ookla the Broken said:

Well of course, you can be village and still be wrong. You’re also trying to figure this out. Besides, you’ve been consistent about it.

Unfortunately Im in the same position as I was when I voted Mippo. If we don’t have a train, whoever the Elims are can just take over the vote.

Also, no, I did not talk to Doc about voting Mippo. I don’t know much about Ksauce, I haven’t read much on him. But Doc is right about needing unity, and I think Doc’s village, so Ksauce 

I hate that I keep having to switch my vote for this

Why is the "unity" just you and doc?

There's more unity against doc than with

[KaladinsSenseOfHumourSpren He/Him]

6 minutes ago, Ookla the Broken said:

Well of course, you can be village and still be wrong. You’re also trying to figure this out. Besides, you’ve been consistent about it.

Unfortunately Im in the same position as I was when I voted Mippo. If we don’t have a train, whoever the Elims are can just take over the vote.

Also, no, I did not talk to Doc about voting Mippo. I don’t know much about Ksauce, I haven’t read much on him. But Doc is right about needing unity, and I think Doc’s village, so Ksauce 

I hate that I keep having to switch my vote for this

Doc (4): Divergent, Honor, Mippo, KSauce

KSauce (3): Doc, Stick, IHAT

Here, I feel like IHAT and Doc are evil together from how they went from complete opposition to village unity. I'm also feeling like either Alvron or TUO or both are elim, just from vibes.

Smokers, smoke!

[Myst He/Him]

13 minutes ago, mippo said:

Why is the "unity" just you and doc?

There's more unity against doc than with

Because I believe doc is a villager, and if we vote a villager we lose. So it’s not that you aren’t included in the unity. It’s that if we do it wrong we’re screwed. And I think that voting doc is doing it wrong.

 

3 minutes ago, Ookla the Wallfacer said:

Doc (4): Divergent, Honor, Mippo, KSauce

KSauce (3): Doc, Stick, IHAT

Here, I feel like IHAT and Doc are evil together from how they went from complete opposition to village unity. I'm also feeling like either Alvron or TUO or both are elim, just from vibes.

Smokers, smoke!

I’ve been saying doc was Villager since the beginning! 
Edit: this isn’t a switch. Now yes, doc hasn’t voted me today, which is different from usual, but he admitted he was tunneling, so that makes sense

Edited December 23, 2025 by Ookla the Broken

[KaladinsSenseOfHumourSpren He/Him]

5 minutes ago, Ookla the Broken said:

Because I believe doc is a villager, and if we vote a villager we lose. So it’s not that you aren’t included in the unity. It’s that if we do it wrong we’re screwed. And I think that voting doc is doing it wrong.

 

I’ve been saying doc was Villager since the beginning! 
Edit: this isn’t a switch. Now yes, doc hasn’t voted me today, which is different from usual, but he admitted he was tunneling, so that makes sense

Alright.

Well, I know I'm village, so if I want to live I don't really have another option here.

[Divergent He/Him]

5 hours ago, Ookla the Broken said:

I find it really weird that divergent went from, “hey, let’s share information” to “doc’s an Elim” he did say he read through the previous threads, but Idk if there’s anything that would immediately make him think that. I can get the suspicion from day 3. But that’s not an immediate, “hard Elim” so to me, this sounds like Divergent has a team coaching him on what to do.

I didn’t really have reads on wanderer, I only PMed him once. I have given V!reads for his inactivity, because he’s been clear he was busy. But that’s also means he could be hiding Elim and there’s no real way to tell.

here’s the problem, it’s a 5v4. I vote divergent, and the best we can do is tie. Making a 4vote, 1vote, and a 4vote. And if I get another person to vote Divergent, it becomes a 3vote, a 4vote, and a 2vote. So unless I can get all 4 people to vote Divergent, me doing so only hurts us. The best thing I think I can do is not vote doc, which is what Dive’s doing, and so that leaves me with voting Mippo because we have to be very intentional and unified in our votes, otherwise the Elims can just take control.

Does that make sense? We need to all be very conscious of who we’re voting and what that does.

Edit: hopefully this makes sense, we need to vote an Elim here. And all 5 villagers have to do in order for the Elims to not just take over the vote in the last 10 min… I really hope the soother does something today 

I'm finding this super suspicious, like seriously, you've had 3 days of interaction with everyone else and then you try to cast suspicion on the person who's only been here for about 24 hrs. This feels like a very elim move, especially with how you and Doc seem to be very coordinated with your thoughts and actions, and is making me think that my tinfoil may not necessarily be off the mark

It seems like you're mostly voting Mippo here because you think Doc is village. But other than that, is there anything that makes you suspicious of them?

3 hours ago, Alvron said:

Yeah, I don't really ever say much in thread.  In order for me to do my style of analysis I need a dead elim and a dead village.  I have plenty of dead villagers but no dead elims.

The only other way I contribute to thread is by rolling dice or making ties and seeing what they come up with but I haven't been rolling the dice myself this game as many players don't know my style and to them it would seem disruptive and get me killed.  Not that I publicly disclose my dice rolls but I do use them sometimes to decide who to vote for if a tie isn't possible.

That's fair and I think I also find it easier to analyze if there's both a dead elim and dead village. That said, I'd like to ask, is there anyone in this group of alive people that you would never vote (because you think they're village or some other reason)?

Also @Ookla the Broken, I'd like to ask more, what makes you so strongly village reading Doc?

And @Stick. was there anything that Ksauce said during D1 that might have pushed TJ to scan them on N1?

[Myst He/Him]

28 minutes ago, Divergent said:

I'm finding this super suspicious, like seriously, you've had 3 days of interaction with everyone else and then you try to cast suspicion on the person who's only been here for about 24 hrs. This feels like a very elim move, especially with how you and Doc seem to be very coordinated with your thoughts and actions, and is making me think that my tinfoil may not necessarily be off the mark

It seems like you're mostly voting Mippo here because you think Doc is village. But other than that, is there anything that makes you suspicious of them?

That's fair and I think I also find it easier to analyze if there's both a dead elim and dead village. That said, I'd like to ask, is there anyone in this group of alive people that you would never vote (because you think they're village or some other reason)?

Also @Ookla the Broken, I'd like to ask more, what makes you so strongly village reading Doc?

And @Stick. was there anything that Ksauce said during D1 that might have pushed TJ to scan them on N1?

Yes, I’m voting who I’m voting because if the villagers aren’t all in agreement, we’re screwed. So yeah, pretty much.

As for casting suspicion on you, that’s fair. I do believe you formed an opinion too quickly, which leads me to believe you’re being told who to vote. Also, my votes on Ksauce right now. 

As for why I think doc is village. He’s been very thorough in looking into things like the Mistborn thing, he’s been cooperative, analytical, and while I disagree with his analysis on myself, he’s also been consistent, no suddenly defending people, or voting people for no reason.

As for who I wouldn’t be willing to vote, idk, at this point, we just have to hit an Elim, and we have to all vote them. If someone convinced me Doc was Elim, I’d vote him, but right now I don’t have that.(edit: I just realized you meant this for Alvron and not for all of us, lol)

I’ve been off with my reads, I labeled WorldHopper as Elim. But this is the most important vote, if you can convince me and everyone else to do it, then let’s get an Elim out. But we need a train. And currently between Ksauce and Doc, I trust doc more

Edited December 23, 2025 by Ookla the Broken

[Divergent He/Him]

Another angle I wanted to consider was that a person who has more experience with Tyrian roles would be the one who would have initiated the idea to give Smokers to everyone and at least one other person with a similar level of experience would agree with that. I'm aware Jo posted an idea that opened that possibility on the sign-ups thread, but I'm thinking only more ballsy experienced players would actually do that, and that's another thing that makes me think Doc and TUO are on this team 

9 minutes ago, Ookla the Broken said:

Yes, I’m voting who I’m voting because if the villagers aren’t all in agreement, we’re screwed. So yeah, pretty much.

As for casting suspicion on you, that’s fair. I do believe you formed an opinion too quickly, which leads me to believe you’re being told who to vote. Also, my votes on Ksauce right now. 

As for why I think doc is village. He’s been very thorough in looking into things like the Mistborn thing, he’s been cooperative, analytical, and while I disagree with his analysis on myself, he’s also been consistent, no suddenly defending people, or voting people for no reason.

As for who I wouldn’t be willing to vote, idk, at this point, we just have to hit an Elim, and we have to all vote them. If someone convinced me Doc was Elim, I’d vote him, but right now I don’t have that.(edit: I just realized you meant this for Alvron and not for all of us, lol)

I’ve been off with my reads, I labeled WorldHopper as Elim. But this is the most important vote, if you can convince me and everyone else to do it, then let’s get an Elim out. But we need a train. And currently between Ksauce and Doc, I trust doc more

What are your thoughts on TwinStorm and what he did or said in the past three days before I subbed in?

Would you not describe the vote on Jo as sudden?

@Doc12 what are your thoughts on IHAT now? Do you still read them as elim or has that changed?