Jump to content

Mags

Members
  • Posts

    6797
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    41

Mags last won the day on July 17 2025

Mags had the most liked content!

About Mags

  • Birthday April 7

Contact Methods

  • Discord
    Mag

Profile Information

  • Member Title
    God's Silliest
  • Pronouns
    she/they
  • Location
    Inside the Moon
  • Interests
    Creating nigh incomprehensible lore for HG
    Constantly changing my pfp because I'm mean like that
    (PLEASE ASK ME ABOUT) Silly little FinwΓ«an guys

Mags's Achievements

5.7k

Reputation

1

Community Answers

Single Status Update

See all updates by Mags

  1. Wait I haven't been following the Shard for a while when did you become a Tauriel defender?

    1. Show previous comments  3 more
    2. Mags

      Mags

      I do

      i really do

      out of spite

    3. TwinStorm

      TwinStorm

      no

      you don't

      name one good thing abt her in the films

    4. Mags

      Mags

      1-was silly

      2-was cool

      3-this is a hot take but I didn't hate the romance

      4-it's contextually hilarious for her to be ginger if you know the wider Tolkien lore

      5-I really like elves

      6-she gave thranduil a reason to have more screentime, and I'm obsessed with him.

      (rant warning for more serious thoughts)

      Spoiler

      I have spite for (intentional and unintentional) misogynists who use critique of her character as a platform for misogyny. I could go on an angry rant about this, but I hope it's not necessary. No, Tauriel is not a very well written character, but including a named female character in an adaptation of a book that doesn't have ANY is a good, if not necessary, thing. We can change stuff in adaptation if the og has flaws from being a product of it's time.

      In the end I don't even like her that much, I just find myself alone in the fact that I didn't think she was terrible. I liked some of her scenes. I didn't like some of the others. People view media with such a black and white lens these days and it's really frustrating. Media exists that isn't garbage and that isn't a masterpiece, and it's okay to enjoy it and appreciate the good parts. I find myself defending her on principle, for the sake of defending having a nuanced opinion on mediocre pieces of media in general.

×
×
  • Create New...