Mat

I currently mildly distrust Mage for some reason unbeknownst to me. After Gears’ lynch it will greatly depend on his flip who to lynch next. If he flips village then I’d be fine with TJ. But if he flips elim then that would be a bad idea and we’d have to find another target. Why inactives?

@Magestar, you said you’d ‘throw a vote on Gears for now’ but there is no red text Was this accidental? I’m leaning on trusting TJ, partly because an elim wouldn’t have known Eternum was an KR any more than a villager would’ve, and because his posts seem the same as his other games to me and he was village in both of those, and I read him elim in both of those wrongly. I don’t want to repeat that.

@Araris Valerian I will take that opinion into account in later cycles. It’s nice to get an outside voice other than myself on El, who I mainly suspected for their votes on me Thanks

I saw that and disregarded it as a setup, which is what it was, or a when/if typo. Nice try, though That would’ve been good. Yes, I’m being paranoid. But I’ve mostly been relying on my gut more than anything else this game. The MR was a special case of it being my first game, and like you said, the fate of the game was on my shoulders. At this point I’m going with my first impressions, and pushing them hard. Illwei seems pretty new player village to me. Like their questions in thread and stuff, though I don’t think they’ve voted at all? Might be wrong about that.

Or they killed Joe, then started a mislynch on me. It’s the same result.

That’s... out of the blue. I think I wasn’t attacked because I could’ve been protected, and because I’m a possible mislynch- what you’re trying to do right now. Joe, on the other hand, was village read by literally everyone and would be nearly impossible to mislynch.

Fair kill, I guess. Relieved I didn’t die, and I finally have Stormlight! Gears, I’m wasting no time. It is my hope that many villagers join me in this endeavor. Edit: And I noticed PMs are open. Cheers!

Actually, if you are village, the elims would probably keep me alive so they could get a mislynch on you, not kill me. Doubt it though, that whole scenario.

I don’t see why I need to. So many times people have posted reasons for suspecting you. I agree with all that stuff, plus my gut just hates your posts. :/ Sorry... but like you ask a bunch of questions like this one that just seem like stalling, asking for other lynch targets multiple times and other things like that. You are sort of contradictory, like reading someone as village and then voting on them either the cycle you read them as village or after. I don’t know much to write beyond that. I think there has been plenty enough reason to lynch you, for quite some time now. If I get NKd I would very much like to see a Gears lynch from the grave.

I sort of changed my mind, I decided I don’t agree with Ventyl. Gears is so evil...

This I don’t like... We should be able to clear people without lynching them first. Its kinda true, and pretty stupid

@The Young Pyromancer, Ashbringer was NKd. They were village. I suppose this could give Pyro a slight village read...

I don’t like the idea of voting for inactives. It feels like a game of chance if we do that, which was one of the reasons I disliked the Eternum swing. We can’t rely on D1 posts for analysis because they were all made in the air of not knowing anything, so voting for semi-active players has a better chance of success.

Can people listen to me for once? Seriously. I don’t care who, but next cycle I want Gears or El gone. Whichever more people prefer. I don’t expect to be around, and would like someone to trust me. I was right about Striker, Ventyl, and Eternum. Can we try my suspects? Again I ask for possible protection. Pretty sure I’ll be NKd this turn, though I might be overestimating my worth. I feel like the elims are controlling the lynch and that shouldn’t be happening this early in the game.

Yes, a bit over 3. I suppose I’d go back to Gears if more people went there over El.

You know, my strong gut feeling against them has gone down, but I would still be fine lynching them. Maybe later, if something else goes wrong. What I don’t like is the switch to Eternum. I find them village, and honestly, their suspicion of me early on seemed genuine. I’m worried half of our active players are elims. This will not go well if that’s true.

Yes, but it also is largely myself and Ventyl's fault. I still have a bad gut read on you right now, FYI This feels like an excuse to vote to me. I've got an increasingly bad gut feeling about you as the game progressed, and this doesn't help. Your defense of El and condemnation of Gears feels like defense and bussing respectively, but my analysis style is based largely on gut reads and other players' relation to those gut reads. So I could be very wrong. If I were to 'call' an elim team, I'd say Striker, Elbereth, Gears, Magestar, and shanerockes. shane because I'm assuming the elim vote manip has been inactive, and they just subbed in for Fifth. Not my strongest read by any means, but we should still watch to see if more vote manip pops up.

I cannot say how relieved I am there is only 1 page xD I’ll multiquote in a bit, but for now, @Straw, vote count please.

Going dark. Elbereth for now.

On the other hand, if you roleblocked someone you thought was an elim, consider claiming as they could have submitted the elim kill. Though think about it first. A lot.

That was highly beneficial. Much thanks to the elim team for clearing Ash, and sorry to their dead soul that I suspected them. Awesome pun Straw. Now I’ll go rework my suspect list. Back later, but I’m going camping with no reception so I’ll be gone for about 24 hours starting in about 2

2. Dunno. It aligns with my own suspicions, though. 3. I am aware of this, but I still... suspect. I don’t think anyone has a good idea of what this game is

Honestly don’t care. Yesterday I definitely would’ve said you, but Ventyl’s hesitance makes it about even.

Let’s see. 1. She voted me last cycle, completely avoiding the Gears/Ventyl debate and giving virtually no reason for voting on me. I would think I’m at least soft-cleared by now and there are definitely better lynch targets than me, especially then 2. Orlok heavily suspects her 3. She would work with a Gears/Ash/Elbereth/Possibly Pyro elim team, something I’ve suspected for awhile now. 4. Gut read. If I get NK’d, refer back to this post please

Probably just the names of two piano students, but still a specific coincidence