Jump to content

bmcclure7

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    1738

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by bmcclure7

  1. bmcclure7
    We don't know he was alone, or in a group or just indirectly responsible, or that he used connection to destroy ashyn.
  2. bmcclure7
    We don't have enough information to say that yet.
  3. bmcclure7
    He is book 5 I think.
  4. bmcclure7
    Fixed
  5. bmcclure7
    1. Not being able to feel guilt or pain for his actions does not Justify or excuse moashes actions. Even if he can't Feel the wrong this emotionally He should still have been able to grasp intellectually that "Hey, Murdering my Friend in front of my best friend in order to drive him to suicide is wrong. " 2. I'm not sure guilt or pain counts as a Passions, There are emotions for sure but not all emotions are passionate.
  6. bmcclure7
    You're not choosing understanding. Your choosing to deflect Accountability. This is odium's 101. The main thing he urges his followers to do. But speaking of understanding let me correct some of your misunderstandings. 1. Being an addict it does not absolve you Of any responsibility for your actions. 2. Moash is not an addict. He embraces odium's gift because he wants To be free of accountability, Not because he is chemically enslaved. These are to very different things.
  7. bmcclure7
    You sound like a true servant of odium.
  8. bmcclure7
    Were are more then just individuals so a certain amount of our individuality we always have to be sacrificed. This is not a bad thing.
  9. bmcclure7
    Ferechumist I think the powers would be more practical and you'd be more able to use it in your everyday life.
  10. bmcclure7
    Which one is ishar's?
  11. bmcclure7
    Unfortunately the wob you posted clearly States that lift is something never seen before. Meaning she cannot be the night watcher bondsmith.
  12. bmcclure7
    Gravitation: flight without stormlight. Personally effecting your own gravity. Soulcasting: spitting acid? Raboniel did something like that if I remember correctly? Maybe some kind of soulcast of your own body. Regrowth: manipulating the growth of carapace. Faster more controlled regeneration? Cohesion: swimming through stone. dose anyone know if any others have been revealed? If not what is your best guess on what the others our?
  13. bmcclure7
    Personality i like the theory that it refers to dustbringers.
  14. bmcclure7
    Guess what the stormfather meant by "something more " is just speculation. No other wielder of an honnor blade has become "something more" . Remember also that the stormfather is a lier we have no reason to trust him. 1. Is there anyone he kills for the fun of it even like this that is in any kindof position to steal a honnor blade? 2. The shin kept the honnor blades safe for thousands of years so there has to be a way to keep them safe and in the right hands. 3. There are other ways to put check on someone with power. 4. You contradict yourself. You say that the honnor blades our to powerful yet your worried that a powerless soldier is going to kill the wielder and take the blade? 5. Thats kind of the point There are a lot of indecent jobs in war. Assasination for one, and there is undercover sabotage, ordering airal numbering ww2 style
  15. bmcclure7
    6. Nalan Has an honor blade, But he doesn't use it because he has a bond with a Spren. Having this bond hasn't stopped him from siding with odium, Is or from killing children for that matter. YesI know that Nale is insane and thinks hes doing good But I don't see how this makes a difference. 3. The reasons why they're killing people are Irrelevant. I don't understand how you think it changes anything their reasons. A dangerous evil person is As dangerous as a dangerous deluded person. If anything the dangerous deluded person is more dangerous. 2. To be fair it's not the same level of power not even close it is At best 3rd ideal. As the nights radiance expands it'll become less and less relevant as we get more 4th and 5th ideal knights radiance. 4. True but then again as we see if the skybrakers It's also possible for them to Delude themselves into thinking that they're right. Truth is giving anyone the power of any kind comes with considerable risk. 1. I mean we don't know his definition of great doesn't necessarily mean destructive. I would say that feruchemy abilities are Great than alomantic ones Even though the latter is far more destructive. I think we have enough knight radiance now that we could distribute the honor blades to them. Alternatively I thought about maybe giving the honor blades to Squires. Right now there's a shortage of right knight's radiance So using the armor blades to augment the ranks might be the best option at least for now. An argument could also be made that having an unbound surge binder Might be useful in a time of war. Especially since the bond the honor blame can be severed without killing a Spren.
  16. bmcclure7
    And there's an easy fix simply give your honor blades to the heads of the knights radiance orders.
  17. bmcclure7
    1.Why dosnt it matter 2.your guessing 3. No but it doesn't make him more knowledgeable. 4. If it's his intelligence you're disappointed in. Just look at what he achieved. Created his own nation, Defeated the high princes, Manipulated Dalinar for years, Manipulated a literal Herald for years, Manipulated the stormfacker, Was steps away from becoming immortal, Are you saying all this means hes not smart?
  18. bmcclure7
    2. Are characters don't. 3. No we don't know how to sumone void light. 4. Why wouldn't his thoughts count?
  19. bmcclure7
    1. Could you explain your logic here cause I don't see it. 2. No more than any rogue surge binder. 4. As I've already said oaths don't really provide much checks on a radiance behavior. And even if it was than you could easily just give them to people that already sworn oaths. ( Honestly this is what I would do, Would give them back to the heralds but there are little insane right now. So for the time being if I had the honor blades I would give them to the head of each order. Imagine how awesome it would be if Kaliden also had the surge of regrowth). Alternatively just find really honorable people that you trust to give it to. I mean that's what the shin did for millennias without problems. Jumping to the decision to destroy them is extreme. 3. Tell that to the skybreakers, Or the dust bringers. 4. I have already made several post on why this is not so. 5. Fair point on the archers. 6. So, How is dangerously insaneSomehow less dangerous than someone who is dangerously evil? A criminally insane schizophrenic, Who thinks hes buying people presents, but In actuality is blowing people up, It's not evil it doesn't mean hes Any less dangerous.
  20. bmcclure7
    It also gave off light which Ishar's didn't.
  21. bmcclure7
    Because it would have literally supercharged all the radiance in the area. I'm pretty sure Brandon Sanderson would have mentioned that if it did. It also isn't described as glowing I'm pretty sure.
  22. bmcclure7
    1. In that cause then what ishar created wasn't a perpendicularity in the first place. 2. He also had never seen any fly except Szeth and that was in extremely stressful circumstances. 3.then that is a quality of the Heralds not the honor blades.
  23. bmcclure7
    Because 1. He cross through it in to the cognitive realm and 2. It didn't produce stormlight lik ed Dalinar's dose.
  24. bmcclure7
    1. Fair point 2.Never said it was the only dangerous one. Only that it was the one used to destroy Ashyn. 3. The skybreakers were not trying to stop him so. Effectively he was the only one. If the people he had been trying to kill had surge binders of there own he would have been killed probably is his first or second assasination. 4. That's an argument to destroy all surge binding not just Honnorblades. 5. Again I addressed this in several earlier post. 6. Fair point. 7. You could say the same thing for soul casters, and fabrials in general should we destroy those also? 8. It not like have others in real much of a restraint on a evil surge binders (Look at Nale or the dustbringers). Should we be destroying all surge binders as well?
  25. bmcclure7
    1. There is a way to ascend and become a Herald. 2. Is that The Secret of how to become a Herald is within the way of kings. 3. There is a way to get to damnation from roshar. 4. How to summon void light. 5. Whatever his unspoken plan B was. Not to mention all the stuff that he knew that we only just found out about in rhythm of war. Like anti light.
×
×
  • Create New...