dannnex

What demographic would you say this show is aimed towards?

Whats the current reasoning behind an Ash lynch? I can understand why Brooks, but I’m unclear about Ash.

I changed my mind on this once it was pointed out that it is probably better to not lynch Hem claims. Just didn't think from the POV of an Elim. I didn't do anything like this, confused by what you mean here. I haven't voted for anyone previously because 1. A lot of those votes were based on player habits which I know nothing about, and 2. I wasn't paying the closest attention during the early rounds, still just trying to get my bearings. I am considering quite a few potential votes right now, but I'm kinda under the spotlight right now (for basically no reason might I add), so I have to consider if a vote actually makes sense, and how my voting for this person will make me look. I didn't and it wouldn't. I was legitimately under the impression you had claimed already, why else would you publically display so much insider info?? Elims already tried to kill you, they think you're Hem whether you claim or not. ......what. How in the world is that implying that. Condensation had just said that Loyal Crewmates were all Regular, so I was like 'wait, what, that's not true, Crewmates can have roles, right?" Literally just clearing up some confusion. Although this exchange was what made me suspicious of Connie in the first place, and I was right, as she has since claimed Hem.

I did in fact post some reads, your only response was ‘not enough’. Why do I need a ton of reads?? Whereas you, the person with the ever-present burden of proof, has done nothing to support what is essentially a poke vote. Edit: Just gonna put these down here.

No, the goal of the Villagers is to find out who the Elims are. You could successfully lynch every single person that the Village is suspicious of and still lose if none of those people were Elims.

You’re assuming that players won’t like....do anything. People say suspicious things, vote in suspicious ways. Maybe I misspoke, I’m not playing Innocent Until Proven Guilty, I’m playing Innocent Until They Do Something Reasonably Suspicious. Want more evidence? How many Villagers have I lynched? None. How many Villagers have you lynched? From my cursory scan, it seems like every single one of your votes has been towards someone who ended up being lynched as village, with the exception of Elk, who only survived because it was a tie and was randomly chosen. (By the way, what happened with that? Wouldn’t your next action be to vote Elk again, as they just barely survived? It’s like everyone just forgot about them.) Not necessarily saying that’s suspicious enough for you to be Elim, but it’s definitely evidence that my playstyle is just as valid as yours, and that my playstyle definitely isn’t ‘evidence’ for me being Elim. Also, both you and Illwei are contradicting yourselves, you say you’re playing under the assumption that everyone is guilty, but you aren’t voting for everyone, are you? You have to choose whoever is ‘most’ guilty, which is almost the same as playing IUPG, it’s just “Less Guilty Until Proven More Guilty”. Illwei, you’re voting for me. I will once again reiterate that the Burden of Proof falls on those making a claim, and ask why you think I’m Elim. Or why you think I’m “more” guilty than someone else. It’s rather suspicious that you refuse to have any, I don’t know, reasons for voting me, don’t you think?

I’m not saying Innocent until proven guilty, I’m saying the person making a claim has the responsibility to provide evidence. I’m not citing a Civil Law, or a Right, I’m citing a Logical Rule. The same thing would be true in reverse, if everyone is Guilty until Proven innocent, and someone said ‘Dannex is Village’, it’d be up to them to provide the evidence, not me. I actually am playing Innocent until Proven guilty, so those are the only reads I have. (I think it makes more sense to play Inno Until Proven Guilty because statistically there are more Village than Elims.) Also, this is my first game, I can’t play the meta, make guesses based on player’s past behavior, as I have no idea how you guys play. Also I haven’t been paying a ton of attention.

Still a Logical Fallacy. See: Salem Witch Trials, McCarthyism, etc. I have posted reads: You are Hem. Connie is Elim. I voted for Connie, retracted because it is probably logical to wait on Hem claims, at least for now. Thats all irrelevant anyway, this is basic Logic 101, the person making the claim has to be the one to present the evidence. Basic fallacy here. Why do you think I’m Elim?

Logical Fallacy, you’re the one making a claim, you’re the one that needs to present evidence. See: Salem Witch Trials/McCarthyism

Still don’t see any evidence for me being Elim, just evidence that the comment is old news, which I already said.

I did, and I considered that, but as I said, I would be the very last person to pick up on something like this, I’m just stating the obvious here. If the Elims hadn’t already considered Illwei as a Hem, then I’m a lot better at this game than I thought. But I’m not. I consider this old and obvious news. All this ‘no, don’t say it out loud, you might tip off the Elims’ is a rather backwards way of thinking. They have a group Doc, they can communicate whenever and whatever they want. If even a single one of them had considered Illwei as a Hem, they’d all know about it. Stopping the flow of information for this reason is hindering us a lot more than it might hinder them. EDIT: Also, Illwei, if I was Elim, what would I have to gain by voicing my suspicions publicly? I’d just tell the other Elims “hey, I think Illwei is Hem” in the doc. Posting my read publicly does nothing to help Elims, but it might help village, as if we still have a protector they could know who to save.

Oh. Well, it’s pretty obvious you are, right?? I mean, If I can pick up on it, I think it’s pretty clear. You have a ton of insider Hem info, all claiming to be from PMs, but what would a Hem gain from telling you all of that?? It might make sense late-game, when they could be sure you were Village, but you cited your supposed ‘contact’ way back at the beginning of the game.

@mods, can we bring back disliking posts please i mean, I’ve seen CDs, but I definitely haven’t used one years, yes. I can just download songs from Spotify to use offline, I have a thing that’s lets me play Spotify in my car, CDs have nothing that Spotify doesn’t do for me already.

So illwei and Connie have both claimed Hem? hmmmmmmm

Alright, so I guess I’ll do Condensation. If she’s village then the Elims will have to kill her next night, and if they don’t we know she’s Elim for sure. I can wait.

Naw I think they’re still a thing.....kinda I just have different streaming services for everything. Spotify, Amazon Prime, etc. Haven’t seen a CD in years.

NOOOOOOOOOO

Yes.

I believe they said ‘chipmunks’. Also ‘Jingle bombs’. As in the parody songs. Gotta step up your game. The song. I don’t dare speak its name, less I unleash its horrible power upon all of you.

People still have those?? I enjoy Christmas music, but I prefer to wait as long as possible, because the sooner we start listening to Christmas music, the sooner THAT song comes on. You know the one. *shudders*

Is this a vote for whysper or TJ Shade?

Mmmmmmm this is tricky, but I think I’m most suspicious of Condensation right now. Too many small things that don’t make sense. Basically this ^ Also this ^ and other similar things. Connie is just sending me very sneaky vibes, too many small things aren’t adding up.

Well this isn’t good... So does this mean a Mistborn used their kill? Is there any other way for a double to happen?

First, make a blood sacrifice to summon the ancient one Vagh’nirom, eater of souls. Then, bargain with him using the classic eldritch horror bargaining techniques. (no blinking, speak in reverse, blood sacrifices every 3.14 minutes, etc. Just the basic stuff.) after that, all you have to do is [REDACTED] but be sure to not [REDACTED] the [REDACTED] or else [EXPUNGED]. Enjoy!

I got truthwatcher or something the first time I took it (I think), but this time I just got Elsecaller for #1 at 67% and Lightweaver for #2 at 66%. So im basically Jasnah+Shallan apparently