Voidus

I value objective truth and assume others do too, so when I state that Vin is objectively the best character and therefore wins all fights and other people don't understand that, I feel that I should explain until they do.

I gain sustenance from banning spambots. I have no need for sleep.

So if you severely hamper Vin and restrict what she can bring then Huan maybe wins? Not a really convincing argument. But also, no. Vin still wins. Because Vin is awesome and rule of cool trumps your logic.

Neverthere applauded softly, stepping out of a wall as Amethyst rounded a corner. The girl had moved through the border and into the city proper, and with much less of an interruption than some other recent arrivals in the city had caused. Seemed like she'd be useful after all. "You left the one that touched you alive." Neverthere noted. "But I suppose we can overlook that given that you don't know what the power balance in the city is like. You never know if the Epics here are the kind to have unreasonable attachment to their pets." She dissipated into mist momentarily, reappearing at Amethyst's side a moment later and beginning to walk in step with her. "Well you've managed to get into the city now, I'm sure you'll be able to figure all of that out for yourself. And if not, well, I might drop by to give you a hint from time to time." Would Amethyst manage to keep herself alive long enough to be worth the trouble of looking after her? Neverthere wasn't entirely convinced but the city had seemed more stable than those of Oregon so far, which didn't exactly count for much, but it was something. For now, best to treat the girl as though she would be a useful tool, if needed she could always dispose of her later. But what to do with her now? "I'm going to be busy for a while, I would just hate for you to get bored without me though." Neverthere said with another too-sweet smile. "Tell you what, there's a meeting not too far away. See if you can make some new friends there." She gave Amethyst directions, steering her clear of the hotspots of Epic activity occurring throughout the city. "I'll catch up with you later to see how it goes, just don't be too taken in by any of the others there." She concluded. "I want to have you to myself for a while so don't make me regret helping you." Without waiting for a reply, Neverthere vanished once more.

I believe this is accurate, from previous experience with the Reckoners RP.

Sure. I didn't say I was listing all 5 of them though did I?

Or can they?

There are if you take them outside Scadrial.

Given that only around 5 people in the Alleyverse would know anything about the Guardian (One of whom is Voidus, one is the Stranger, one is dead and one is Mac) I won't provide any information here about whether any plans will work or not. If anyone would have any reasonable way of gaining information then I'll provide some feedback.

So then she burns the mists instead and vaporizes him under the force of a steelpush.

Actually a thought: If we're basing this off of pokemon then the fight is simply to unconsciousness, Vin has shown to be amply capable of knocking out a giant wold, Vin wins. :D

Agreed.

Vin burned the mists and killed multiple inquisitors then tore down a building with her mind. Vin wins.

Vin punched a giant wolf to unconsciousness. Vin is the manliest of all, and as has been confirmed. Therefore Vin wins. QED.

And Vin can't die until she defeats Ruin. But also you don't need to slay something to win a fight.

If you want to count prophecy as a reason someone won't lose then Vins death is also already prophesied so stalemate at worst.

Brandon has already won.

Vin burns the Mists, Vin wins.

It's always going to come down to something like that though and honestly it's going to be personal opinion. Personally, I think TLR is nigh impossible to beat without divine assistance. But it's going to come down to who has the most powerful character, because if Ungoliant can beat TLR and Nightblood, etc. then Tolkien wins, if TLR and Nightblood beat Ungoliant, Galadriel, etc. then Brandon wins. Because once you beat the OP characters then you can just use your OP character to insta-kill everything else. Ungoliant could eat a million chasmfiends and TLR could decapitate a million random elves. Personally I think TLR probably wins, super speed and rapid regeneration are hard to beat, barring removing his Investiture entirely (And then we have to deal with all the ways the cosmere has to combat magic). But I can also understand why someone would say Ungoliant would win that fight, because giant, all-devouring spiders are cool and not exactly easy to kill. Rather than a full universe vs. universe fight (Which would also just take forever) I think specific match ups would be more interesting.

I mean she could try, he could explode her from the inside by pushing on trace metals though. TLR is hard, you really need cosmere knowledge to be able to beat him and even then it's not easy. Vin won solely because he didn't consider her any kind of threat at all and because she had literal divine intervention. Against a giant mountain-sized spider he's not likely to let his guard down. Which means super speed, super strength, super weight, super allomancy and also probably foresight. That's going to be another problem on the Tolkien side, for the most part the biggest threats are all pretty obvious. Balrogs, giant spiders and dragons aren't likely to be underestimated.

Yeah, but it does mean Ungoliant starts eating everyone.

I mean you could try that, but you're also up against a bunch of people with emotional manipulation capabilities.

If all of Tolkiens characters were off to the sidelines and aren't being controlled then they all start murdering each other. Just saying.

Define 'featured' Burning is a process, process means it takes time, which means healing is possible. Only sure fire way to kill a KR is to kill them instantaneously and completely. But again, plenty of options even if they don't heal. Dragons are just not a great match against a full KR. Windrunners are agile enough to avoid fire, can heal from it even if they can't, can negate a dragons advantage of flight and can use a Shardweapon to negate their defenses. Then elven archers can't try to surprise TLR with wooden arrows because they have no idea what he is or can do. Almost inevitably going to end badly for Tolkien.

Unless you want to limit to literally only named characters then the hundreds of on-screen characters still count. And since you've been mentioning plenty of unnamed characters I was assuming that's what you wanted to go with. So no, not inaccurate. Did you say the dragon deaths the Knight Radiants? Or did you say it breaths fire on them. Because while fire might cause death, it is not in itself death. And they can definitely heal from burns. So no, not inaccurate. So just all of Sandersons characters since he's the one controlling them? I can live with that. Also this is more of an addendum, not a claim that it was inaccurate. Shards aren't pantheons, they're three levels down from the actual god of the cosmere. But sure, as mentioned that was only one option. But I should point out that you are just disagreeing that they should be allowed, not stating that my claim that Shards can read minds is inaccurate. When was that ever agreed on? Why would that ever be a thing? But sure, TLR goes first, kills everyone in a 1 vs 1 battle. Cosmere wins. Again though, this is just an additional rule you want to stipulate, not an inaccuracy. Having summarised, I feel now obligated to point out that this sentence is itself inaccurate.