cloudjumper

K. First off I would to make clear that I firmly believe that Meta is an Elim, and my logic wouldn't make sense without this being true. So since there are very few votes this cycle, I think that Meta wouldn't vote on another Elim and give solid, seemingly legitimate reasons why they should lynch them that could potentially start a bandwagon and kill the Elim. However, assuming that Cluny is innocent, reasons that Meta would try to lynch him is that he claims to be a seeker, a very dangerous weapon to use against the Elims. This is indeed all if you're right. If you're wrong and the Elims are active, then we'll be killing a bunch of villagers and wasting our lynch, and we'll be doing the work of the elims for them. I think that instead we shouldn't rely on the chances of this happening, and instead focus on killing active elims. Based on your theory, there will be one more. We can't afford to stall for time killing inactives, as the Elims will still have a kill. If we kill an Elim and the kills stop coming, then we can think this through then, as we'll have infinite time to find a strategy. Until then, however, we are on a timer.

I forgot to mention this in my post for some reason. I wanted to lynch Meta, so I edited it in.

Why? Wait, why does taking out inactives help at all? If Cluny is innocent, which I do believe he is, then I think that we should be focusing on killing active Ventures, because they're the ones who are putting in the kill orders. If an active Venture is killed, then we can just wait and see if Venture kills are still coming. What's the point of killing an inactive Elim if you could take out an active one? Honestly I feel like this whole lynching inactives thing is just a play by an Elim to have an excuse to lynch people that cannot defend themselves with no reasoning required. Meta.

Honestly I doubt that the Elims would waste a night kill and a pewter vial just to clear Flash. If Flash was really a mistborn Elim, then the Elims would have two night kills and Flash probably wouldn't even have claimed mistborn at all.

How big exactly is Tenov?

I can work with you.

1. Plenty of people have made just one post this cycle, or even no posts. 2. If you're talking about this post, then frankly, Flash tried to guess a lot more about the Elims' strategy and roles than I did. I just deduced something that I thought was the case through logic. Admittedly the logic was slightly faulty, as you pointed out in your argument 4, but it was what I thought at the time. 3. Honestly I just posted my reaction to seeing the writeup. I didn't read any of the posts until after I submitted it, and missed Cluny's roleclaim in my thread-skimming. 4. I guess you're right on that one. I forgot to take that into account when I wrote that post. That pretty much destroys my whole argument, huh. But does that really mean I'm an Elim?

Yeah, you can mix investitures. It's definitely possible, and there's a couple WoBs out there somewhere.

Welcome to the Shard Ivory! Looking forward to seeing you around! Have a cookie and a nice day!

I think that the Elims are just hunting down every village misting now, or any role that could be dangerous to them. Considering what we've seen in the past few turns with the Elim kill, it's possible that they have a seeker and are finding and killing people who might have powers that are dangerous to them or helpful to the village, or they're just getting lucky three times in a row, which I find highly unlikely.

Hey! I'd be interested in doing this! Can I join? If I can, then can I take the ocean between regions 1 and 3, or is that not allowed?

Vote Count: Orlok (1): Sart Stick (3): Araris, Ecth III, Meta Flash (1): Cluny Ecth(1): Elenion Jondesu(1): Flash

Orlok could be Elim or Village and still confirm that Flash is Mistborn. Flash basically forced Orlok to confirm his role by putting his trust on him. If Orlok was an Elim and denied Flash's role, then Orlok would possibly be lynched because why would Flash ask Orlok to confirm something that he doesn't believe is true? However, people might think that was also a ploy to kill Orlok by Flash, so it could really go either way depending on who is trusted more. Why would Orlok risk his life for a possible lynch on Flash? It would probably be a better play to just wait it out and avoid suspicion. Let me know if this doesn't make any sense. Honestly right now Flash is pretty much invulnerable to the lynch. The Elims will probably kill Flash tonight because he's been detained and can't burn pewter. I wouldn't be surprised if they instead chose to just kill someone else, just to let the shenanigans continue and let us waste another lynch on Flash, because we'll be forced to kill him. Either way, great play for Elims, unless we get a lead now and start killing them. Those are my unorganized thoughts for now. See you in the morning.

Yeah, you mentioned the farming; I don't think that the Parshendi would have farms if they had Soulcasters. Like you said, no soulcasters are mentioned either, so I think that the Parshendi do not have soulcasters.

I think it would be a collection of different series because all of the series are separate, you could read them individually instead of all of the cosmere as a whole.

What? Can you explain this to me? Why vote on himself then? If one of his comrades was a Rioter, then he could actually move to lynch someone else right now by voting on someone else so it would change from this. to this. Of course we would kill him right after, but at least he would survive one more turn. Edit: Sorry, didn't see that he changed it. Also as for the changing tack thing the for the first thing I wrote I just was trying to point out something, and the second thing was my vote, If that makes sense.

Wait, you can vote twice? Did I read the rules wrong? Also, Orlok's arguments did make sense, so I'm voting for PK.

That's great! I look forward to seeing you around the forums.

Hello! Nice to meet you! Have you read any other books besides Stormlight Archive? On a completely unrelated note, have a cookie!

Welcome to the Shard! Have a cookie!

I will join as Ribis, a bored second son of a noble from the Remote Dominance.

I'm pretty sure we do see that, with Bleeder. I haven't read Era 2 Mistborn in a while, but we see Bleeder use both feruchemy and allomancy. I think she does this with Trellium or something, but I don't know.

Assuming you've read all of the Stormlight Books, 1. I think it's part of the Oathpact 2. Yes, they just roamed Roshar. 3. The Heralds as we see them now are all greatly altered from their previous state when we see them in the prologue to WoK. The Heralds now see the world a little differently, and while some might still cling to the same goal they once started out with, like Nale, they go about them different ways. Nale wants to stop the Voidbringers from returning by destroying the proto-radiants, an effort that ultimately does not work. The Heralds aren't really "good", but they're "broken", as Kalak put it in the prologue. Breaking and reforging plays a big role in Stormlight, and you could consider the Heralds similar to proto-radiants before speaking oaths or Radiants after abandoning their oaths.

Found some WoBs

I'll join as Fodder.