Jump to content

yafeshan

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    84

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by yafeshan

  1. yafeshan
    I think its good to hold information. There is no reason to give eliminators any specific target.
  2. yafeshan
    I was in scadrial around terris mountains last 2 days, now back to roshar. I do not like throwing away random votes. As people said, random votes for 1st day is to poke people. Eliminators do not collectively try to remove that accidental vote because 1 post from the guy is enough to remove it. I hope artifabrians make spranreeds and give to experienced players so the game can really begin with lots of PMs flying around.
  3. yafeshan
    I will vote on Elodin but I still want to learn how Mailiw found about him. I can understand that the way you talk in thread/pm some people are able to make good guess with experience. If Mailiw is that good as you say, I can believe but need a little more than that. I want to say a little more about previous discussion since it is also related to Elodin. Pewter is completely aggressive power and do not provide any defensive benefit as far as I understand from rules. Any person storing it can not have any benevolent intent. I can understand random lynch to find about people because people discuss on that but I believe random kills do not help loyals most of the time. May be this is base of Mailiw's reasoning. This cycle is also a good opportunity for eliminators to attack without any counter, I expect most people will be using up their action to tap brass. Is it really takes an action point so we can not do anything else?
  4. yafeshan
    sorry Strawman
  5. yafeshan
    This game is difficult to understand and I am new. I just wanted to hear peoples opinions first few cycles. I am reporting to companion every cycle.
  6. yafeshan
    Waiting for people's discussions to vote this cycle.
  7. yafeshan
    Sorry for asking, can companions answer our PM, I did not understand no pm rule for them.
  8. yafeshan
    I think I will sign up. I am Geran, member of an old house which was founded by a hero who was darkeye and killed a shardbearer.
  9. yafeshan
    I want to sign up but looks pretty complicated for my old eyes.
  10. yafeshan
    I want to sign up as Meardih
  11. yafeshan
    There is no reason to hide it now. The explanation is the honesty I had with wonko and honesty I had with lopen after wonko's death. Everytime I was truthful in our pm together. Wonko knows it while watching in spiritual realm now and lopen will understand it, if I die. The main clue he is talking about is hemalurgical tin scan from his seeker. If I knew about the scan and If I am eliminator why would I let such result to be found while knowing he will be killed that same night. I did what wonko asked me to do last night. That's the only thing I can say.
  12. yafeshan
    As I told before, honesty indeed has punishment. Lopen knows what I am talking about.
  13. yafeshan
    if Lopen is not confirmed by wonko's group, I assume they can just kill him which they seem capable after we saw last night. They can simply lynch him too. If he is truthful, that means he is continuing a loyal villagers own plan which seems to be only working plan right now.
  14. yafeshan
    Lopen was first person contacted by wonko and after wonkos death i assume what he says will continue the plan. Because he assumes being cleared by wonkos trusted group. If it was clear lie, trust group can lynch him or kill silently. If a trust group is out there which was formed by a death loyal villager shouldn't we listen what they are saying?
  15. yafeshan
    I belive i had very legit concerns about it. I do not have any problem with the idea of this plan. I mentioned that this forced silence between villagers gives more time to eliminators. Here we are on 3rd night. 2 villagers are already killed and 1 lucky kill for the good guys. 2 days and no one was lynched because people can no be sure who to vote. It takes very long time to organize with this method. I know it is effective but it gives far too many advantages to eliminators too. Almost everyone declared no-pm since start so I assume eliminatirs are quite fine with this plan. Because time is what they need most. If voicing these concerns are reason for suspicion, so be it. Truth always have a punishment. I wish I had the ability to speed up process for the plan
  16. yafeshan
    Throwing random votes around found an eliminator in lg11 If i read correctly, and people defending the person also lynched later and found to be spiked.
  17. yafeshan
    Can someone please explain me why would anyone believe someone saying he is windwhisperer and scanned him clear.
  18. yafeshan
    Wonko has a good plan to pinpoint dangerous people. However, scanning enough people will take time, and in this time most villagers will not be able to communicate by pm. This is a great disadvantage. I am new in this, rule does not say windwhispers can target multiple people at the same time. If that's the case scanning can take many nights. There is also another scary possibility, wonko can be a spiked and they have this windwhisperer, they may be using this plan to limit villager interaction and find kandra. I want to believe this is not the case we have here.
  19. yafeshan
    Thanks raven only 3 cosmere questions? what a waste.
  20. yafeshan
    How long will this scanning operation continue. We still do not know how many windwhispers out there or do they exist at all. How many people can they scan in 1 night anyways.
  21. yafeshan
    revealing positions sounds nice but there is also possibility for spiked to have bronze / enhanced bronze and pinpoint twinborns to charge spikes, That can lead to a op spiked group
  22. yafeshan
    I guess similar things happened in other games. Someone lure an innocent soul to certain location and kill, and tineye can be a quite good target if you are eliminator. Also confirming your metal here will not convince most people since such things require some sort of proof before trusting. You can still tap identity without relocating to another room and tineye can identify you, since you announced it here.
  23. yafeshan
    I don't have pm but I had too many questions I wanted to ask GM concerning my powers. Do we have a confirmation that PMs sent to GM can not be read?
  24. yafeshan
    Please no cadmium. I know people want to play with shiny powers but please pulsers stay away from it at least 1 night. Wonko has a very good idea but I believe many people started sending out pm already.
  25. yafeshan
    It will be hard to resist. I am a cookie monster
×
×
  • Create New...