Melon Dingo Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 5 minutes ago, Amber Vulture said: This post is problematic as it's not only untrue, but it also just doesn't line up with prior posts. "I don't see how that's untrue? Someone I believed to be a town lurcher was up for possible execution, and I wanted to try and prevent that while not causing confusion about vote totals." 6 minutes ago, Amber Vulture said: I am interested if you are still willing to follow this post instead of choosing to pursue another target. "I'm still wary of Byrar, but I can follow up more than one suspicion in a day."
Indigo Weasel Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 16 minutes ago, Emerald Falcon said: Amber Vulture (2): Melon Dingo, Emerald Falcon Ivory Dragonfly (1): Mauve Crocodile Melon Dingo (1): Amber Vulture Nibbles is voting Heron still. The role reason was a joke about how Smokers have been treated in previous AGs. It's more they're the most talkative person Nibbles doesn't trust. While Nibbles was boiling water for some , he checked Vulture's cosmetic role. Nibbles thought they were RPing as afraid of the light or something, but that's not what was listed. So they're difficult to parse, especially as their habits have evolved.
Amber Vulture Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 (edited) 14 hours ago, Melon Dingo said: "I don't see how that's untrue? Someone I believed to be a town lurcher was up for possible execution, and I wanted to try and prevent that while not causing confusion about vote totals." "I'm still wary of Byrar, but I can follow up more than one suspicion in a day." Sauve Chad does not look kindly upon those who see wrongdoing but make no attempt at fixing it. 14 hours ago, Indigo Weasel said: Nibbles is voting Heron still. The role reason was a joke about how Smokers have been treated in previous AGs. It's more they're the most talkative person Nibbles doesn't trust. While Nibbles was boiling water for some , he checked Vulture's cosmetic role. Nibbles thought they were RPing as afraid of the light or something, but that's not what was listed. So they're difficult to parse, especially as their habits have evolved. A man by the name of Araris Valerian excellently portrayed the character of Sauve Chad, and the Lord Ruler with bless him for that. Edited January 18, 2025 by Araris Valerian
Indigo Weasel Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 31 minutes ago, Amber Vulture said: A man by the name of Araris Valerian vastly misportrayed the character of Sauve Chad, and the Lord Ruler with curse him for that. Nibbles had forgotten he was a GM until just recently. Nibbles will bake them an apology whatever this is And by the way, if no one else guesses hangman letters, Nibbles will make all three guesses himself
Coral Swan Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 Ivory Dragonfly I'd be down to maybe switch idk People I will not be voting this turn: Melon Dingo, Emerald Falcon, Indigo Weasel My guess for hangman is 'strength'
Mauve Crocodile Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 Yeah I won’t stop Amber Vulture from getting wagoned @Amber Vulture can you perhaps talk more about Melon Dingo? Praise the Ja
Fuchsia Ostrich Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 (edited) Can I get a vote count please? curently torn between crocodile and Dragonfly will explain more in the morning Edited January 18, 2025 by Fuchsia Ostrich
Mauve Crocodile Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 In PMs with me Ostrich feels like they’re setting up chain misexes going Dragonfly —> then me So if Dragonfly flips green I would look at Ostrich next (ironic, I know) Praise the Ja
Chartreuse Penguin Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 (edited) This game I'm finding it very hard to build any reads I feel confident about I have been asked my reads on heron and dragonfly, so I'll start with those hopefully by tomorrow Ill have time for more reads After reading through skimming others comments but focusing on their posts I'd say both their content seems pretty village, but if I had to say one is evil, I'd probably go with Dragonfly on a gut or vibe read. Next read through I will focus on croc and dingo though. Their content seemed worthwhile of a closer look. Edit: I'll leave my vote there for now, but just noticed the interaction between ostrich and Croc. My vote may change to one of them if I get back to the game. Two people specifically trying to throw each other under the bus likely means one is a bad guy and the other a good guy Edited January 18, 2025 by Chartreuse Penguin Explained
Mint Heron Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 (edited) As someone who also voted for Tuatara, I can understand Dragonfly’s vote. I can understand the suspicion, but I think that this has been one of the trickiest games for figuring out who’s guilty. I got confused, and I think Dragonfly might have as well. I’m more suspicious on how many people are jumping on Dragonfly. Swan and Ostrich feel like they’re trying to get Sew killed while also staying neutral. Swan was suspicious in on D1 and has avoided attention since. Realistically though, I argued against the majority yesterday and was wrong, so I’m not too upset if you don’t agree EDIT: forgot to add, I wanted to point out, Dragonfly was the one to point out that Tautara was a lurcher. Why would an elim do that? It would have been way easier to stay quiet and let the town continue to accuse Hayden. Edited January 18, 2025 by Mint Heron
Coral Swan Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 20 minutes ago, Mint Heron said: As someone who also voted for Tuatara, I can understand Dragonfly’s vote. I can understand the suspicion, but I think that this has been one of the trickiest games for figuring out who’s guilty. I got confused, and I think Dragonfly might have as well. I’m more suspicious on how many people are jumping on Dragonfly. Swan and Ostrich feel like they’re trying to get Sew killed while also staying neutral. Swan was suspicious in on D1 and has avoided attention since. Realistically though, I argued against the majority yesterday and was wrong, so I’m not too upset if you don’t agree EDIT: forgot to add, I wanted to point out, Dragonfly was the one to point out that Tautara was a lurcher. Why would an elim do that? It would have been way easier to stay quiet and let the town continue to accuse Hayden. uhhhhh I mean yes I did have a bunch of votes d1 but the reasoning was completely based on RP which is why they ultimately fell off
Amber Vulture Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 Quote A man by the name of Araris Valerian excellently portrayed the character of Sauve Chad, and the Lord Ruler with bless him for that. Edited 1 hour ago by Araris Valerian Sauve Chad remains unimpressed. 10 hours ago, Mauve Crocodile said: Yeah I won’t stop Amber Vulture from getting wagoned @Amber Vulture can you perhaps talk more about Melon Dingo? Praise the Ja Melon Dingo's intentions are shady and contradictory and Sauve Chad is struggling to grasp them at all.
Mauve Crocodile Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 1 hour ago, Mint Heron said: It would have been way easier to stay quiet and let the town continue to accuse Hayden. You don’t think people would’ve forced a claim out of Tuatara there anyway, given they publicly survived a kill? I’m entertaining Heron/Dragonfly v/v worlds and it’s leading me to a solve of Ostrich/Vulture/+1, or something along those lines @ tin eye, X (I’m trying to make us lose hangman) Praise the Ja
Melon Dingo Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 45 minutes ago, Amber Vulture said: Melon Dingo's intentions are shady and contradictory and Sauve Chad is struggling to grasp them at all. "Can you.. explain how?" Rind sounds exasperated. 8 minutes ago, Mauve Crocodile said: I’m entertaining Heron/Dragonfly v/v worlds and it’s leading me to a solve of Ostrich/Vulture/+1, or something along those lines Rind nods in agreement. "The Jaist has a point here. I was worried about yesterday's vote manipulation but the Soother who did it has gone and told me. I'm still a bit suspicious of them, though I'll avoid revealing any more potential town allomancers for now. Malmoc was the main person bringing up questioning the more quiet people yesterday, and now they're dead, so that might be something worth looking into?"
Coral Swan Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 @Ivory Dragonfly @Mint Heron Who did you both smoke d2?
Mint Heron Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 1 hour ago, Coral Swan said: @Ivory Dragonfly @Mint Heron Who did you both smoke d2? I can only change to smoke someone else in the night. The only person I smoked was myself, as I didn’t trust anyone very much. I’m still only smoking myself.
Indigo Weasel Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 Nibbles thinks the Dragonfly votes are (Nibbles doesn't like bobba) Why would they claim smoker if they're evil? The specific people voting that way isn't comforting either
Melon Dingo Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 "Something seems wrong with this push for Sew, maybe we should gather up the votes a little?" Dragonfly (3): Swan, Ostrich, Penguin, Crocodile Vulture (2): Dingo, Falcon Heron (1): Weasel Dingo (1): Vulture Swan (1): Heron Ostrich (1): Crocodile No Vote: Mouse, Hyena, Dragonfly
Azure Mouse Posted January 18, 2025 Posted January 18, 2025 (edited) [I'm breaking character, apologies to all but I've found keeping up a character unhelpful into solving this game.] Can someone @ me with a list of the claims? @Mauve Crocodile, can you explain quickly your explination for this dichotomy is? I'm potentially concerned about Emerald Falcon as an eliminator especially given how subtly they've been existing and the way they've been presented in the thread from prior elims. I think based on positioning that thye'd make themself out to be a BTS mafia. @Indigo Weasel Can you tell me who of the Dragonfly voters you suspect most? And which of them you think is the best ability to be town? If Dragonfly flips eliminator, how does that change your opinion there? EDIT: Of the two elim options offered I kind of think Suave Chad (Vulture) has been allowed to lurk more than should be allowed, but I don't think I've been active enough to actually have a say in what's happening which is on me. So that I have a vote down, and to encourage wagonstate; Heron Edited January 18, 2025 by Azure Mouse
Coral Swan Posted January 19, 2025 Posted January 19, 2025 Okay going to go through each player's posts, and I'll post every two or three I get through Dragonfly Votes Melon Dingo D1 Everything else D1 is RP N1 one RP post Negative read of Emerald Falcon D2 Votes Charcoal Hyena D2 to get reasons for why they voted for Magenta Albatross D1 Unvote Charcoal Hyena Votes Cream Tuatara for why the voted for they voted for Magenta Albatross D1, and lists Emerald Falcon as top suspect Gives reasoning for why vote stayed on Cream Tuatara as panicking and not making a decision in time D3 says they trust Mint Heron Heron Agrees with Emerald Falcon’s comment about how its odd that Mauve Crocodile was accusing someone of lurking, when other than the accusation that was mostly what Crocodile had been doing to. There are worms in his green apple For oog reasons votes earlier than eod, and votes for Cream Tuatara Suspicions N1 are as follows Positive: Emerald Falcon, Amethyst Scorpion, Azure Mouse, Ivory Dragonfly Slight Negative: Amber Vulture, Chartreuse Penguin, Fuchsia Ostrich, Charcoal Hyena, Melon Dingo Slighter More Negative: Cream Tuatara, Coral Swan (myself) Medium Negative: Indigo Weasel, Mauve Crocodile Biggest suspicions are on Indigo Weasel, Mauve Crocodile, and Cream Tuatara (believes wgg happened) Lists Emerald Falcon as least suspicious and Cream Tuatara as most likely to be spiked Is confused by Indigo Weasel’s voting and questions Mauve Crocodile. Votes Ivory Dragonfly because they are attacking those who voted for Cream Tuatara the previous day. Says that Coral Swan (myself) looks okay on D2 Claims that they had been smoking themselves D3 thinks that Melon Dingo is town Votes Coral Swan (myself) and also lists Fuschia Ostrich as suspicious for votes on dragonfly Questions for @Ivory Dragonfly If you had Falcon as your one suspect, in what world does it not make sense to vote for them d2? When you said you trust Heron did you mean you trusted their claim as a smoker, or you trust that they are villager, or both? Questions for @Mint Heron What are your thoughts on Indigo Weasel and Mauve Crocodile? I'm gonna keep my vote on Dragonfly atm, but will likely change it idk. Going back to my notes from before, my main reasoning for voting dragonfly d2 was dependant on tuatara flipping elim, which didn't happen. Actually you know what, Heron feels worse than Dragonfly, so gonna switch for now. I'll be back in a little bit with some more thoughts. Mint Heron.
Emerald Falcon Posted January 19, 2025 Posted January 19, 2025 I support both wagons. It's not e/e because two elims claiming the same role is unlikely imo. But it is likely e/v over it being v/v, assuming both claimed exactly Smoker.
Coral Swan Posted January 19, 2025 Posted January 19, 2025 Okay here's some more Mouse Votes for Magenta Albatross for throwing out blame first Thinks that not more than one of Coral Swan (myself), Melon Dingo, and Indigo Weasel could be elim. Comments on falcons village read of themselves Lists Emerald Falcon and Mint Heron as possible suspicions Doesn’t believe that both Ivory Dragonfly and Mint Heron are elims, and mentions that could be neither. Lists Emerald Falcon as possible suspicions, votes for Mint Heron Ostrich D1 RP Has yet to vote Lists Mauve Crocodile as a suspicion Torn between Mauve Crocodile and Ivory Dragonfly and votes for Dragonfly Hyena Votes on Chartreuse Penguin for lurking D1 Votes for Magenta Albatross to break the tie D1 Gives reasoning for voting Magenta Albatross over Cream Tuatara as less likely to have a train formed. Was fine with either a lynch of Mint Heron or Ivory Dragonfly N2 Nothing since then Question for @Azure Mouse What is your reasoning for voting Mint Heron rather than Emerald Falcon? Questions for @Fuchsia Ostrich What is your reasoning for voting Ivory Dragonfly? Why Ivory Dragonfly instead of Mauve Crocodile? Questions for @Charcoal Hyena Can you give some thoughts on today and also vote please? I am going to be switching my vote to Fuchsia Ostrich, their vote on Dragonfly kinda feels like it was just hopping on the train. 11 minutes ago, Emerald Falcon said: I support both wagons. It's not e/e because two elims claiming the same role is unlikely imo. But it is likely e/v over it being v/v, assuming both claimed exactly Smoker. What are the 'both wagons' you are referring to? I am assuming Dingo and Dragonfly? If this is the case, why aren't you voting one of them?
Melon Dingo Posted January 19, 2025 Posted January 19, 2025 1 hour ago, Azure Mouse said: Can someone @ me with a list of the claims? "I'm a soother, and Sew (Dragonfly) and Byrar (Heron) are smokers. Someone else also told me they were a soother." Heron (2): Weasel, Mouse Dragonfly (2): Ostrich, Penguin Ostrich (2): Crocodile, Swan Vulture (2): Dingo, Falcon Dingo (1): Vulture Swan (1): Heron No Vote: Dragonfly, Hyena The new votes were interesting, but Rind didn't quite know how to place them. He doubted that both the smokers were saboteurs, but it could as easily be one as neither of them, and what the other soother had done had worked out awfully well for the spiked. Suave had been unhelpful all day, but unhelpful doesn't neccesarily mean evil, and Falcon had been awfully quick to jump on that claim. Three days of this, and was there still no-one he could really trust? Rind's head hurt. Leaving the votes so close, though, especially with soothers about, didn't seem like such a good idea. With that, he decides to leave his own on Ostrich. Rind gets up to leave, tired from thinking so much. He stops at the door for a moment, then quietly shouts over to Sew (@Ivory Dragonfly) and Byrar (@Mint Heron). "Uhm, it might be a good idea to leave your copperclouds off tomorrow? If there's a seeker here then clearing you two would be really helpful right now." The door of the inn closes softly behind him.
Recommended Posts