Jump to content

Bejarden

Members
  • Posts

    1158
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Bejarden

  1. 22 minutes ago, ElMonoEstupendo said:

    Shallan's mother? Was she never seen on-screen?

    Nope

     

    7 minutes ago, Marukka said:

    Wait a minute... did we ever really see Mare? Kells memory is full of her, but I can't recall reading a real scene with her...

    Storms, missed the bonus clue...

    Siri's Mother?

    we did see kels mother in a small scene and Shallans

    Nope

    second Bonus clue and this one should give it away since I don’t got any more time for this

    This Character is from Sel

     

  2. 11 minutes ago, Honorless said:

    Granted, the Nightwatcher gives you a little in-game cash in Life - the game.

    This was what I was going for actually…

    9 minutes ago, Szeth_Pancakes said:

    I wish for some candy that makes my reading speed exponentially faster.

    Granted but you need to eat 100 pieces for it to work so good luck to your teeth

    Your bane is that your processing speed stays the same

    I wish for a good job

  3. 46 minutes ago, Honorless said:

    Shashara?

     

    10 minutes ago, Szeth_Pancakes said:

    Already guessed

    Vin's little sister

    No but good guesses

    1; This Character was never seen onscreen

     

    2: This Character is dead

     

    3: This Character death was beneficial to a certain group

     

    4: This Characters death caused great grief to an important person

    5; This Character was married

    I’ll let a few people guess and see if they get it; if not I have a bonus clue…

     

  4. 3 minutes ago, AquaRegia said:

    CONSIDERABLE speculation.

    I freely admit I'm still not clear on how the "deadeye in Shadesmar vs Blade in Physical" idea is supposed to work.  Isn't it one or the other, but not both?  In other words, an unbonded Shardblade, hidden somewhere in the Physical Realm, cannot ALSO be a deadeye wandering Shadesmar.  Am I confused?

    That is correct

    But when the bond was broken all Blades could not be dismissed without gemstones so how would there be so many deadeyes? 

    But it seems from Shallan that if you break an Oath while the blade is dismissed it stays dismissed which may explain the vast majority of all the Blades

    But we are still missing 100 or so at the very best

  5. 3 minutes ago, DougTheRug said:

    I don't think this is the case. I would say that we do get a predominance of blades in actuality but an equal number in people's memory. I have few reasons to support this:

    1. Plate sticks out more inherently because it can't go away like blades do.
    2. It's easier to get a blade once you have plate (see Dalinar).
    3. People with Plate and Blade are at the forefront of things so they get talked about more. 
    4. Under certain circumstances there's an advantage to keeping the fact that you have a blade hidden. 

    Let’s put it this way

    In Feverstone Keep, where a small contingent of Radients broke their oaths, there were more blades there than known to exist in the entirety of Roshar (Alethkar has around 25 and they have the most)

    Now every single Radiant broke their oaths, supposedly. That would equate to 9/10 of blades being hidden, which doesn’t make a lot of sense seing as you can make a lot of money from selling a blade and you would think it would have been done in the past 2000 years, and from Taln (I think)  we see it’s very very uncommon for a new blade to be found

  6. 17 minutes ago, Lesser spren said:

    I accept the WOB. But I have never seen any indictation that Kandra don't have blood, do you have any evidence to that wise?

    From the description we get from Mistwraiths I assumed there was no blood. Also True bodies don’t seem to have any either

  7. 7 minutes ago, Use the Falchion said:

    Who said anything about who TOD picking someone who wants to lose

    Well that was the OP was going on and general assumption is always what the OP says

    And what are you basing on that Odium can’t either manipulate Connections himself or stop Connection manipulation. Honor is the Shard of Oaths not Spirtual Connections 

     

  8. 13 minutes ago, Use the Falchion said:

    Taln became sane again when Dalinar swore an Oath, not unlike Ishar and Navani. I can easily see Dalinar swearing an Ideal during the Contest (depending on the moral dilemma the Contest itself has in store for him - which is why Odium's Champion being someone that causes a moral dilemma to Dalinar matters), and having that bring enough sanity to Taln to do what needs to be done for the sake of Honor and humanity. 

    Why would TOD let this happen? Why pick someone who wants to lose and won’t try to win over literally anyone else

    3 minutes ago, Harrycrapper said:

    Interestingly, if the champion is a Herald and that child epigraph really does pertain to the contest of champions, then technically anyone who isn't a Herald or a Fused would be a child from the Herald's perspective. 

    I don’t see Taln as a man that would be conflicted in killing for the greater good. If killing Dalinar meant saving Roshar he would do it in a heartbeat, at least that’s my read of him. And the DR connotates conflict

  9. 8 minutes ago, Maverick Mistborn said:

    I know there are lots of threads about who will be Odium's champion and apologies if this has been covered, i did a quick search and someone briefly mentioned Taln, as Odium could take away his pain.

    I was struck towards the end of the RoW when they are fighting Ishar how impressed Dalinar is with his fighting skill "he is a duelist" Dalinar thought. "storms, and a good one" and the Storm Father told him "Among the Heralds, Ishar was average in skill" 

    "He is average among them?" Dalinar asked. "Then ..... who was the best?"

    "Taln," is the Storm Fathers response and he later states "there is no dispute"

    So my theory is either ToDium learns this info and is will to remove his pain if he fights for him- pretty standard- or Kalidan helps him recover and Dalinar believing he has an unbeatable champion names him and leaves himself open to being Odium's champion. Then the belief he would be Odiums champion comes to be.

    Either way it would be great to have the best duelist of all time in the fight

    Thoughts???- please be kind. 

    The pain is not the only problem with Taln, he is also completely insane magically. And even if it would work why would he do it? He has expressed that he cares about humanity and I doubt he would fight against them to become a brainless drone

×
×
  • Create New...