Mat
-
Posts
7773 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
10
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Mat
-
I guess that's true. Seems like a decent explanation for the amount of KP and scan power we have though. It suits blackout well but would be a risky GM play so idk Considering you're in a PoE of like three other people with at least two possible coinshots tonight, I'd say pretty afraid :P.
-
It's also Night, so currently everyone can equally not be exed (And I added in the rest of my post, btw)
-
I thought UPS was maybe you, tbh. Guess not. Also, anyone paying really close attention who also has a good memory could totally figure out what I am I wouldn't say no chance. This is blackout, and do you know Kas and Fifth? Plus we started with maybe three Coinshots and multiple scans with a whole lot of role copying that essentially doubles/triples that potential, so yeah, I could see that role being given to an elim. Maybe not as likely as to a villager though. Kinda hard not to see this as you lying but that's me in an old tunnel and you're right that your TWTBAW play makes more sense in this light.
-
...Oh, right Fair point, fair point.
-
EDIT: Posted without thinking. Sorry >> We may not have flips, but we have numbers! Two of the above (non-bolded) names are elim. We also have clears! Drake is clear for killing Tani (or, sorry Mr Pacifist, Stick killed Tani ). TUN is clear for being killed by the elims (I think? That's what Drake said, yeah xD). I'm clear for being scanned by AnonPMSpider (and also my GM PM). So our two are in (Archer, Ash, Shining, Steel, TJ) e!Steel and e!Walin worlds compared to v/v worlds are very different. Obviously. As I think has already been said, e!Walin points to Archer/Ash and e!Steel points to one in TJ/Shining, plus Steel. Actually, though, due to the lack of a Tani interference and a lack of resistance to the tie in general, I'm inclined to lean v/v. Walin didn't seem very invested in his survival and I still read Steel as pure just based on posts. Counterargument: If the trains are v/v, why would elims join the trains at all? Either they're in the more trusted group (TJ, Archer) and joined to cast shade on the less trusted (Ash, Shining, Steel) or it's as simple as they were online when the idea was proposed and couldn't get out of it for fear of being caught that way. Which I think could be anyone but I don't remember exactly. I guess I don't have anything else to add other than agreement of the general PoE this gives us. Though I do think it's hilarious that people are forgetting I was scanned. Whether willfully or not. I can agree with a Shining kill tonight if Drake would be so bloodthirsty and I'm reconsidering my read on TJ just out of PoE. Archer... I keep forgetting is in this game xD I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing. His posts haven't stood out in any special way, and the last time I strongly village read him he was evil so maybe that just points to village :P.
-
I believe the answer to that would be 'no' It is a TC, though. Working on an analysis post, hopefully someone beats me to finishing that.
-
Personally, I’d rather not discourage activity. I far prefer this to 1-2 page turn threads. I agree there’s a line to walk here though. Analysis post to come in a few hours when I’m off mobile— I know a few other players have done that already but I still want to
-
Yes please :D. I’ve been sad without a PM this game. I feel isolated :P. Speaking of which, sorry I kinda checked out completely last turn. Mech discussion isn’t my thing and there really wasn’t any non mech stuff last turn; when I saw that I wouldn’t need to move for the tie thing to work I just… didn’t do anything else :P. Dunno in what state my reads are in. I would say they haven’t changed but that’s a product of flipless more than anything else xD Hopefully Orlok has something useful, that’d help me with that. As I’m sure it would most people.
-
This depends on what Orlok's role actually does, I think. @dannnnnex @Orlok Tsubodai --- Any more specifics you can give us on the mechanics of the clears? Does it give ratios within? A yes/no on whether there are elims? Something else?
-
Wizard is confirmed village if you trust Fae's role, and Walin already had votes for a reason :P.
-
Probably because he already had votes. What does 'net alignment' mean in this case?
-
I mean, you can if you want, but I’d prefer someone else since I’ve already been scanned by someone. Allegedly.
-
Unpopular opinion: I village read Steel’s posts and general vibe. The Lynchbait thing is weird, though idk how likely it is that the elim rolescanner claimed right away. I kinda sympathize with his explanation and it seems like a waste of a good role if he’s village. Then again, the role’s kinda already been wasted :P.
-
Unless you actually think Shining is an elim it’s not super helpful to be voting him btw (Ninja’d by Aman :P)
-
Interestingly, I have not voted you this turn and am not currently. I would like to know why you keep ignoring me when I ask for reads from you though-- you've done it at least three times recently. It's getting to the point where it feels TWTBAW but I dislike having to judge something on that >> Edit: Do you want this subforum to be lost??? :0
-
Status: Not a bot. Fae, can't help but notice you didn't actually answer that question :eyes:
-
I've also been asking for Ash to make a reads list since D1 and it hasn't happened yet :P.
-
Fadran already claimed to have trolled Randby I think
-
That would mean a troll target is elim, yeah? You were RBd, Fadran hit Randby, and did Walin even do anything? Are there other troll claims?
-
Huh. Fadran's probably village for claiming that, unless he's just an elim genius xD I'm with Drake, we shouldn't self-cannibalize within confirmed circles unless we need to. 'Need to' gets to be in quotes though :P.
-
So... why? Randby is near confirmed iirc.
-
I feel way more lost this turn than any of the previous ones lol Fadran-- did you Troll Randby, and why, if so? I think I saw someone say that.
-
I didn't. My role is a Day action. Not vote manip though.
-
Oh sorry I misremembered your post (the last one on the previous page) to be the one where you voted in, even though continuity wise that makes no sense xD I understand now
-
Troll claims are what, Aman, Walin, Fadran? The Fadran claim is kind of weird and almost gives the feeling a teammate prompted him to do it so he wouldn't have to reveal much later when it'd look worse for him, but idk, I'm voting Walin :P. Oh sweet That was TJ, I guess? I would disagree with that statement under the precedence that you felt pressured enough to retaliation vote :P. Do we know xino was RBd by the elims? I guess a village one probably could have claimed by now.
