So here's a mini analysis, as complete as one can do 1 page into D1:
xinoehp512 – Hasn't posted yet. Following the thread. Has a poke vote on them. @xinoehp512
Gears – Claimed elim, which is NAI for them. Seems as helpful and normal as I would expect. Slight Village.
Mist – Hasn't posted yet, following the thread. @Mist
Ashbringer – Hasn't posted yet, but is following the thread. I'm poke voting them. @Ashbringer
Elkanah – The most active and arguably the most helpful player thus far. Good vibes. Poked Devotary. Gut Village.
Illwei – Hasn't posted yet. @Illwei
Kings_way – Made a statement about killing the DMS, which is unhelpful early on. Sort of an elim way of thinking, but as they're a new player I'm more inclined to read it as that. Null.
Lord_Silberfarben – Hasn't posted yet. @Lord_Silberfarben
Vapor – Posted analysis without reads. Null.
Ventyl – Poke voted Gears for... doing what he himself does? I don't think Ventyl is also claiming elim, because of this wording:
But it's kinda a strange poke. Null, though, Ventyl is chaotic. And if he's trying to generate conversation by being so, look! It's working!
Lotus – RP, and that's it. Null
Butt Ad Venture – RP and a poke vote on xino to get things going. Null
TJ Shade – Seems to be pretty worried about an elim adjudicator, which makes sense to be worried about. Depends on the number of the elims. Null, with no idea which way it's leaning.
Devotary of Spontaneity – Hasn't posted yet. @Devotary of Spontaneity
So I don't have any negative reads right now. And my village reads are on the active players, which is probably... typical for D1 More updates on this as the game goes on, I'm sure.