Mint Heron

Yeah that's my bad for not specifically stating that. And ig it makes sense you thought that way if that's what you would normally do as elim. Shrug.

I never said mouse isn't the elim kill my goodness. I'm not saying I believe it was a WGG. I feel like the fact that I brought up the possibility that an elim mistborn did a WGG should not be receiving anywhere near as much backlash. That has nothing to do with the fact that Mouse was the elim kill if the WGG was done through other means. Of course it's likely that it wasn't a WGG, but I really don't like that your are so adamantly against even the possibility of it. Misunderstanding of what you meant I guess. So your strongest reason for voting me is because of the WGG stuff? That feels really off. Like really that's the most suspicious thing you can find from anyone during the entire game? Like I don't mind people voting me, it's part of the game. But what is sightly annoying is when the reasoning would not normally be used to vote on someone. Like I'm very confused why you thought I was trying to muddle the possibilities of who the elim kill was. Vote me if you wish, but I implore you to look deeper and if you're going to vote me have a better reason and frankly something that is actually alignment indicative.

I fail to see how I am muddling the possibility of mouse kill being elim kill, or even how that's e!indicative. Even with mouse being the elim kill that doesn't mean the elims couldn't have attempted to kill vulture as well with a mistborn roll. Ofc it could have just been a village mistborn shooting at a thug/lurched vulture, but I believe not looking at all the options is actually what would be worse for the village. All good wisdom teeth removal is no fun. Though I will note now that the reason I had two types of reads is because something in real life came up (which I did say in one of my previous posts) which meant I didn't have the time to continue in that format. Disagreeing with my reads is a much better reason to vote me imo than the other reasons you've listed.

How does noting the possiblity of a WGG (which is not out of the ordinary to state) me trying to make the kills ambiguous? Do you mind sharing these other things? Do they exist?

Mouse was tineye...

I don't understand what you're saying here... The fact that I suspected PM shenanigans is your reason for voting me? Or am I reading it wrong? Also vulture could def be a WWG. Or is it WGG? I don't remember.

Hi :). Other than myself, what reads do you have for all the players at this point?

e!penguin reading this y u do this bro anyways good: mouse, penguin, ostrich (probably) bad: iguana, vulture weird (might be bad but idk): cham, scorp, meerkat idk: everyone else EDIT: added meerkat to weird

I know you had reasons xD I was asking them why they joined the train instead of one of the other wagons.

So...?

What about the Hyena train made more sense than the scorp and iguana wagons? I'm struggling to see why a villager would ever say this.

Well, Mouse and Albatross obviously had some type of PM thing going on. Unless they pulled off some weird gambit where they are both elim and trying to make it seem like they are PMing (which I doubt). Then people starting just voting with no reasoning, which has happened due to PM stuffs in past games. I might ask you why you decided to jump onto the hyena train? I don't recall specific reasoning. I'm pretty sure it was the way you took your vote off of Rhino, but still didn't feel good about them. So I think it was the fact that you didn't feel good about Rhino but still took your vote off of them. Do note that I still haven't read in depth the later end of D1 so that read was purely based off the first half.

Really?

Nah, just didn't have time until the last couple hours or

I sense that there are pm shenanigans that I am not part of. I also sense a train will form on Iguana, which I'm fine with. Iguana

I read posts as they came so I wouldn't have to do catch up work when I did have the time to start posting. True true. Your vote your rules.

Took me three hours cuz real life comes before this. I mean, to an extent. Jumping votes around all the time doesn't really achieve anything though... But I do that too sometimes so eh Idk who of the train are elim, I simply stated that it is very likely at least one is. And my vote should point to who my feelings are pointing to. Bideo bame. ?

Yeah, I can see how you can read into it that way. ...night kill...? So would you be willing to vote anyone? Myself? Mouse? Chameleon? Or just scorp?

What does that even mean?

I did have elim read on scorp before. Closer to null now. Swan claimed smoker not seeker. I was just noting that I'm not not voting Hyena because I think he's village, I just don't have thoughts about them. How? If anything it would be the other way around, as I'm not voting for them? Meh. This does not sit right at all with me. If you're maybe planning to switch your vote later, why is it even on rhino in the first place? Bruh. It's almost never the case (in my experience at least) that there isn't at least one Elim on trains like this. There's obviously going to be villagers on the train to, but I was just pointing that out. If a villager is too afraid to vote on someone they actually think is elim because they think it'll make them look elim that's just silly. Villagers don't worry about their votes looking elimy. They just vote who they think is more suspicious. Bruh what? Do you have any thoughts about anyone more than just vibes? And why vote scorp only after I unvote them? Anyway I'm down to switch vote to iguana or meerkat if people want to go that way.

Yesterday I went on a 6 mile hike and we took a wrong turn, making it a 14 mile hike so I didn't have the time planned last night to contribute. So for now I'm just going to quick read day 2, give my thoughts, and go from there as it's much better to have discussion. Thoughts: I can't decide if iguanas reaction to my post feels weird good or weird bad. To anyone refuting my large reads post, I did say that it was only up to page 4, so it wasn't exactly conclusive of the entire game… Idk how I feel about zebra either Beagle feels fine based on response ig? Cham feels vil I'm sure mouse is vil I don't understand iguanas rhino vote Something feels off about swan I feel like I had gut Elim read on scorp earlier on and it hasn't faded. Trying to decide if it's tunneling or not. They are talking quite a bit which is always good. Vil reading penguin Can someone explain to me the Hyena votes? It seems like there's a train there and likely at least one Elim who hopped on later. That includes swan, vulture, and scorp, mouse, penguin and ostrich on hyena. Swan and vulture are the latest on that train. I'm going to vote on Swan for now, as their reasoning is simply because Hyena was up to die before but didn't. @Coral Swan Note, I'm not necessarily reading Hyena as village (null, really) but the train is obviously leading on them so me adding a vote there will do nothing.

Ok people are pinging me. Im still working on my mega post (fell asleep last night) currently on page 5 of day 1. But ig I can post my thoughts thus far to show that I actually am working on the post. (I won't get to responding to people until I get to that point in my analysis of the thread. If your message is urgent, feel free to PM me :).) so here goes with what I have this far (first four pages of day 1) The votes in order: Vote count at this point (end of page 4) Now my reads thus far. Note: this is only till page 4 of day 1, so reads may change as I continue my analysis. + means leaning slight vil - means leaving slight elim Elim+ or vil- means unsure Okay, so elim reads UP TO THIS POINT are scorpion, beagle, and iguana in no particular order. My feelings are strongest about scorpion as of now. I will be continuing to work on my reads to get caught up to present time. If you have wishes to communicate with me while I do so, feel free to send me a PM. Unless you don't care if I respond in a timely manner. Then just post it in here xD Heron out

Sorry, got really busy yesterday and missed EoD. I'm going to read through everything and make my reads list now :). Edit: I've gotten through about a third of day one and now need to go coach a rugby game. I shall complete my quest upon my return (later tonight)

Imma place a vote on Beagle for now. Just gut, as I still need to do more than skim over the thread to get somewhat better reads/feels

Dragon would have laughed if he wasn't stuck in a dog's body. That is exactly what evil would want you to think when writing that, the stray thought. He wasn't sure if the person in question was bad or not, but knew that jumping to conclusions especially the day after his best friend was killed probably wasn't the best idea.