Stick.
-
Posts
3863 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Stick.
-
It’s not really that big though is it. If the latest kill order takes precedence then none of the elims attempted to change the kill order once it was placed on Coda. If we assume that the whole elim team was not online when and after the lynch on Coda got going for real, then we’re left with the team being CadCom, Kidpen, and Elkanah. However I have problems with that team cuz I believe I know (through some trusted sources) that one of them possessed an item last cycle that I wouldn’t really expect an elim to have...I know GMs can sometimes be troll-y with item distribution and that kinda thing but still... I just, still struggle to understand why the elims would decide to NK Coda of all people. I’m beginning to wonder if there’s some kinda secret item that redirects actions. That would explain everything. Would also out an elim right about now. Pretty nifty.
-
Did you mean to say that the other way around? Also this whole thing going on isn't sitting well with me and I'm not buying it lol. Why would the elim team assign the kill to a player who they knew won't be online near rollover? I'm sure they wouldve discussed timezones and availability and all that. Plus, as DeTess pointed out last cycle, it doesn't matter to the elims whether there's a C1 lynch. This wouldve been a good course of action for the elims to take C1 so as to direct all suspicion on people who weren't online at rollover. Idk but the fact that the elims chose to NK the very player we ended up lynching is too convenient of a coincidence. But assuming that this wasn't intentional on the elim's part, I'd say Elkanah is probably an elim, going off by Tinu's analysis of when all of us were last online.
-
I would pick coda over sart for the lynch It seems the lynch is untied now? edit: yes, it is. 3 ninjas.
-
What I mean is that out of all the possible ways to use their votes, I don’t expect the elims to immediately sheep the first vote casted in such a blatant manner, yknow? That (evidently) attracts attention. I’m not clear on what you’re asking here But um I don’t think at the moment that either of them are elims. Assuming elim!sart has a teammate who could be a possible lynch target - From the top of my head, the only other person anybody expressed suspicion of before you voted Venture was Striker, and there were no signs of a lynch forming on him because of his tendency to get lynched early, so I don’t see why elim!sart would feel obligated to place his vote on Venture. im beginning to feel unsure of my vote on Coda, but I guess it was sort of baseless to begin with. (Mostly they just felt off) I might take it off depending on whether there’s anybody else proves to be more worthy of the vote
-
Not feeling the Sart lynch, DeTess, ngl. Sheeping like that would be suspicious under normal circumstances but I don't really see an elim doing that C1. Cycle 1 is where you can almost always get away with voting on anyone with minimal reasoning - so elims usually tend to just stick a vote anywhere that isnt on one of their own. So why would elim!Sart choose to vote Venture immediately after Tinu when he could literally start any other lynch without attracting attention? Surely waiting for the lynch to form at least a bit would be less incriminating. I actually think Lemon's village too, for PM reasons. I'm beginning to suspect you just a little bit only because your reads are super conflicting to mine Irrelevant thought but Kidpen seems pretty village to me as well, partly because of this post. And partly because of my gut. Elkanah seems pretty okay too. Lol, here I thought I was onto something what with soft clearing so many people only to go to the player list for some PoE and realise I don't nearly have enough info on everybody for that yet. I'm a bit wary of Elandera because she's posted about three times I think (?) but notably has not given much substantial opinions. That isn't very suspicious at C1, but worth noting. I'm more concerned about Coda. I know they're a relatively new player but yet their posts sound very odd to me. This bit in particular: After which they post RP, gaining points. I don't know, there's nothing really wrong with that but it feels off. EDIT: forgot to talk about Venture. I have a tentative village read on them - I would expect an elim to defend themself a bit more than that, especially when there's two votes on them with no alternate lynch.
-
Fair. IMO all that’s almost always non alignment indicative. Not meaning to discourage anybody from posting, but such analyses are perfect for the elims to blend in by seeming helpful while rarely providing any of their own insight. I doubt anybody stated with more than one, but you can certainly hold up to how many items as you can get.
-
Heyo I see y'all already workin hard collecting them good ol' contribution points Couple of thoughts in no particular order: Apart from what Kynedath said, there doesn't necessarily need to be a reason I think. It's entirely possible for the GM to have a villager to possess an item such as a smoke bomb if only to mess with our reads. Forgive me if im reading too much into this but these two posts really vibe the wrong way to me. They sound way too overly unsure and something I can see elim!Striker saying. I'd love to honour your request and not lynch you C1, but just making a quick note here. I doubt it. I think the elims would rather go after players with items cuz that's basically killing two birds with one stone - you cut down the village size while also getting permanently rid of some useful assets to the village. If a player uses a gun from the black market they're not really much of a threat to the elims anymore.
-
What makes you believe I was responsible? Besides, Araris did not wish to take our House's invaluable friendship till the end and was malevolently scheming. We know this. So it is not favourable that he just happened to get stabbed?
-
Interesting... but you can’t vote for me stink We’re in the same faction and you can only cast votes on people from other factions #friendship
-
Signing up as Stick!
-
I share reciprocal sentiments And fair. you mean first person to get rid of somebody outside of their faction @Straw last time there was a no lynch vote iirc - do we get one now too?
-
Hello everyone ~ It's been more than 14 hours since the game started and there hasn't really been any game talk yet (understandable - the docs and PMs are booming with conversation, I'm sure) so I guess I'll be the one to bring up the lynch here Should we have a D1 lynch? Technically it shouldn't matter in a game like this one since we arent trying to find elims or anything. Thoughts?
-
Count me in if you decide to extend the signups
-
This was still fun Thanks Kas and Hael! Unfortunately I’ll have to hop out - I’ve suddenly got a little too much on my plate for the coming week and I’m afraid activity might become a problem.
-
Sure, but because there are (thankfully) no PMs permitted in this game, whatever the elims know, we know. That way, they’ll have to try and figure out who the spy is through the thread only, which makes it significantly harder. Slim chance they’ll win the game through that route I think. As for what I as an elim would keep an eye for in order to pin down a potential spy, 1) Tunneling with confidence and 2) Switching from target to target with little reasoning when the lynch seems unachievable 3) Bringing up the tiniest thing about something someone said and turning that into their basis for a vote (which I guess can be a good way for the spy to go if they can maneuver the argument so that it sounds convincing but not too convincing, yknow?). I guess the optimal situation a spy can find themself in is their vote being the deciding vote between a number of potential lynch targets, each with some amount of votes and stuff - but obviously getting to that point is complicated. The spy reading the thread and trying to figure out how to approach all this: xD Edit: idk how this random quote box below got here but it doesn’t wanna leave for some reason lol
-
Hello hello Random fact but I just realised the last QF I played was more than A YEAR AGO! xD Anyway I think that if we play carefully this shouldnt be too hard: the Reform Spy + the Handler are huge assets. But it's gonna be tricky ofc. I wouldnt be surprised if an elim tries to drop hints at them being the spy so to get some votes on their side
-
I will play as Stick
-
GG everyone Great write up, Lum. XD I do always play SE with the intention of having fun first and winning second, and I admit it would’ve been very fun to convert, but with the MR having started off I figured it’d be best to end the game here. Plus I’d feel bad for stripping the village of its victory xD. I wasn’t sure how many of us would pick having fun over winning. My plan was to keep going for Rath until it went through xD I think my only concern with the game was that the village had way too many ways of clearing each other, with the whole role madness thing going on. Also how the game could only go one way or the other after D3 - the low number of players is probably to blame for that. But regardless, it was enjoyable. Thank you Lum and Coop for taking the time to run this game!
-
As much as I love Fura’s very true role claim, I think the game should’ve ended after D3 so my vote’s on concluding the game.
-
About 10 minutes before rollover the vote tally was such that Fura was getting lynched even after taking Drake’s manip into consideration, which was the closest I could ever hope to get xD Unfortunately CadCom had to come in with an accurate vote tally... Why thank you
-
If you insist, I’d love to arrange a visit for you Through, um, a friend, obviously.
-
Yeah no wonder I got no results for those actions...Silly me
-
Haha turns out I misread my GM PM I’m actually a Thug now how nice
-
There are in fact 3 votes on me right now, you’re missing Drake’s.
-
Oh dear, I get back from school and there's a MASS CLAIM HAHAH VERY MUCH NOT WHAT I WANTED xD Well, I am another Tineye: N1 I targeted Aman (which was mostly a random choice) and N2 I targeted Circada, as I thought there was a high chance she might get converted. Both my actions were largely useless. I guess I technically can EXTRA-prove my role next cycle by targeting one of you and then publicly sharing the results. All these claims are interesting, particularly the 2 lurchers. But as I said earlier, I'm not going to read too much into that. Also I don't understand why people keep saying Shane wouldnt have NKd Venture so if someone could explain that'd be awesome. I guess that leaves me with Fura. Despite my village read on you, it's more likely that you're the inquisitor than anybody else considering all the claims (except maybe shane). You proved in LG55 that you are very good in appearing helpful to the village as an elim, so all the number crunching D1 is in fact NAI (as I have also previously said), and because I've only played one game with elim!fura, that is unfortunately all I can reference. Is it though? For an inquisitor, claiming Lurcher is kind of perfect is it not? Another reason to maybe suspect Shane...hM
