Jump to content

Stick.

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    3863

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Stick.

  1. Stick.
    Maybe it's better to have this conversation in PMs
  2. Stick.
    Okay! Finally done ISOing Devotary this honestly shouldn't have taken as long as it has Day 1: First post talks about village smokers existing, and about how we mustn't be too quick to trust a self proclaimed Seeker. NAI The Second post says that they think Ventyl's claim is likely village indicative, defends Striker, supports Striker's suggestion of the village coinshot using their role every cycle. They note down illwei's actions as NAI due to meta reasons, and say that the Reading exe doesn't make much sense. Of note that they continue defending Striker in across the cycle and in D2 as well. The Third and last post of D1 notes that ties in the day are fine as long as they aren't near the end of turn, and throws a vote on Books because it would give more info than Reading. Note that this post was made 8 minutes before rollover. NAI probably - Devo always votes near the end-of-turn. Night 1:The night post comments on the vote manip, and says that the last-minute votes on Books aren't necessarily suspicious because the votes weren't close at all when they voted. These last-minute Books voters include Striker, Ash, TJ, and Devotary themself. Day 2: This post speculates that perhaps the reason the elims went for Randby instead of Ventyl was because they wouldn't expect a Lurcher to be protecting Randby, and in response to Maill saying that he sees a Striker-illwei e/e because of Striker’s vote taking pressure off Illwei, argues that Bip’s and Quinn’s vote played a bigger part in taking the pressure off illwei. (All three of whom [quinn, bip, striker] we now know to be village). Also comments how Araris’ and Fifth’s actions are NAI. In this post they defend Ash and say that Gears flipping evil shouldnt mean that illwei, quinn, and striker are villagers. Due to this post I can see elim!Devo being partners with elim!Gears attempting to plant some seeds for suspicion on Quinn and Striker (confirmed villagers) in the event that elim!Gears is exe'd. In their last D2 post where they vote Pyro they say that village!Striker is most likely and it is worth noting that they weren’t exactly suspicious of Pyro but voted Pyro anyway cuz probability. I dont really know what to note about this lol. Night 2: This post is of note because they say: But earlier in D2 had said: So there’s that. The rest of their N2 posts are mainly questions concerning the group PM and in this post they point out that people on the Pyro train couldn’t have been teammates of elim!Ash’s trying to save him because the train on Ash had dissolved before the pyro train began. The people on the Pyro train were Striker, Araris, TJ, illwei, and Devo. Overall what stands out to me is how they defended Striker so much - I would consider the possibility of a scan being involved, but Devo's defence for Striker began on D1 itself, so that is slightly suspicious. The Ash thing is definitely weird, and I can see the night post being a distancing attempt if Ash and Devo are elims together. Another thing is how a lot of their posts are NAI, which is always something that seems elim to me. Well Gears is the one with the Soothing so if anything, that should make the votes less tied If Maill is an elim then I'm willing to bet he lied about his role, so there isn't much I can do with that At this point I'm starting to question whether we even have a village seeker lol I agree with this Anyway I'd be willing to switch to Devotary - I'm fine with both a Gears and a Devo exe and to be honest I've now come to terms with a Maill exe as well. In my opinion we've done enough info exes to now move on from that, and I think we can always just exe Maill later if need be. But since a lot of us can't really move on without exe'ing Maill first, I dunno lol
  3. Stick.
  4. Stick.
    But had Quinn not used her own vote manip, the exe wouldn't have been affected by your soothing at all - did you know Quinn's role? And okay, fair enough on that second part I'm gonna take my own advice and trust my instincts too then Gears l would also be open to a Devo lynch - I'm still working on their ISO though ------------------------------------------------------------------ Sunny noticed two newcomers @Haelbarde @Condensation join the bloody mess that was Fallion's Tears. She could imagine how overwhelmed they must be - thrust in the midst of all the happenings. So, she decided to throw them a little welcome party with - of course - cake. She was certain that this would make up for all the inconvenience all this murder that had been happening around town lately might have caused for the pair. (image in spoiler) (image in spoiler) (shout-out to Stink for the idea )
  5. Stick.
    @Gears two questions here actually 1. Why did you soothe the vote on Maill (that is what you mean by "saved you once" yes?) 2. Why vote on him now? Because in our PM last turn you admitted that Quinn's flip does not affect your reading on Maill edit: my post count rn is my birth year, nice.
  6. Stick.
    why? I dont think she claimed - she was playing it safe in our PM when it came to letting out any information. Scan seems more likely...
  7. Stick.
    So that's why Tani wanted to die Did Bip tell anybody if she had role claimed to anyone? edit: ninjad
  8. Stick.
    so are you asking to get killed or exe'd?
  9. Stick.
    Do...you want to die? There was a chance they wouldn't have chosen you as a NK target tonight cuz you might've rolled Thug or Lurcher but uh I hope you're bluffing xDD edit: actually youre probably not in danger from the elims - cuz you're still under village suspicion generally (not from me though). coinshots might get you though
  10. Stick.
    Sunny had baked an orange cake yesterday. Right as it came out of the oven, she showed it to three mostly-decent-looking fellows, and they seemed to be approving of it. But once the rest of the townsfolk discovered the existence of this cake (the delectable aroma was too strong, alas), they weren't happy to have not been showed the cake earlier. They were right of course - the cake was a beauty deserved to be admired by everyone. Thus, Sunny left it out in the open for the day for everyone to see - right in the heart of Fallion's Tears. When Sunny returned to fetch the cake to take it home for the night, she was overcome with sorrow at discovering a quarter of the cake having been eaten by the townsfolk. She was not surprised, however, and she suspected more of the cake would be eaten. Maybe soon, maybe later. (image in spoiler)
  11. Stick.
    Were I a Seeker I would personally scan Devo/Burnt/maybe Maill. I think it's highly unlikely that Tani's elim, and that should be more obvious now given Quinn's flip. I agree that any Coinshots should probably go for Daisy/TWS. My current suspicions: Ash/TJ, Devo, TWS, Gears, Burnt, Daisy (Maill? mayhaps, but my gut says no.)
  12. Stick.
    I was relatively convinced that Quinn was village anyway, so this hasn't got much to do with Quinn's flip I've been meaning to look at Devo
  13. Stick.
    Not feeling so good about Devotary - post to come later She's right The write-up can wait
  14. Stick.
    see now Im content. I don't want a tie. But, now that we're at a tie 5 minutes before end of turn, the vote manip orders (which I assume must've already been sent), will make it so we dont, in fact, have a tie. I hope. Cuz a tie just means we have to do this all over again and...Im getting tired just thinking about it xD I thnk both are village, but if we dont exe someone now we're stuck in the same place
  15. Stick.
    ...touche
  16. Stick.
    I just read through all three (3) of TWS's posts, and I wouldn't be opposed to exe'ing them (I've thus far included them in all my elim team guesses in-thread, I'm pretty sure). Although I don't think I wanna do that while they're not around to defend themself, so I'm not voting this turn.
  17. Stick.
    As far as Dannex goes - I remember having a village read on them. Let's see. Their first post rang all the elim alarm bells for me: This was the whole post (excluding RP). Just dropping an opposing comment on (what we now know to be) a village train, sus. Their second post, though (below), is what made me lean village: Only because I feel like an actual elim wouldn't casually drop a statement like this one - it seems counterintuitive to the elims because it so so obviously gives the village a reason to exe Dannex in the event that a village smoker turns out (which has: Ventyl). And then this post also made me lean village on them, because of how they asked these questions in-thread instead of in their doc. Could be an IKYK. Then they went ahead and voted on Quinn, but I think it was just meant to be a joke? It did stay on for the rest of the cycle though... After this Dannex disappeared for two days (real-life time, not turns lol), and came back to say that they did not in fact cease to exist. After that they disappeared for 6 days, to return to say this: So yeah, I don't know about Dannex Will this exe give us a ton of info? Probably not. Is Dannex suspicious enough? Maybe? I personally have a village gut read on them edit: @Fifth Scholar
  18. Stick.
    I mean...it is...constructed I don't know Ash's alignment so I tried to piece together what I could - obviously the post is not an absolute truth or anything Just speculation
  19. Stick.
    inb4 vote manip ends it up in a tie pls no
  20. Stick.
    Yeah I got the initial 'derrick doesnt like this guy' bit but I just got confused when you called them a main suspicion here again - thanks for the clarification k im having lots of clown moments rn so ill likely abstain from voting unless something wild happens idk
  21. Stick.
    I've uh realised something so Ash Sooo is TJ a main suspicion or not? OKay maybe you've got a point there... I didn't really notice how odd that was until TJ pointed it out. xD Does anyone have a trustworthy vote count?
  22. Stick.
    I would include the people that voted on Pyro in this list too (Devo, TJ, illwei) - we know that Pyro was a villager, so dumping votes on him could also be elim teammates attempting to save elim!Ash. To the elims it wouldnt have made much of a difference whether Pyro or Striker got exe'd as long as it meant they'd save a teammate.
  23. Stick.
    yus I feel like we put up a good show for the elims xD
  24. Stick.
    Here’s an idea: someone make a group PM with everyone currently alive, excluding the four of us, and discuss this turn’s exe to exert vengeance (joking) ((but also, do it if you want to :P)) Yeah that’s how I interpreted it too
  25. Stick.
    I would provide you with one but I don't trust my vote counts anymore
×
×
  • Create New...